Articles

Is it cheaper to oversize a battery on day one or to augment it later?

A battery that fades has to be topped up or built too large. Oversizing pays for the whole fade on day one, at today’s price; augmentation pays for it as it happens, at a lower price.

A battery contracted to deliver 800 MWh of usable energy every year for 15 years loses 2.5% of its original capacity each year. Oversizing it on day one means building 1,230.8 MWh, $90.5m more than the 800 MWh that the contract pays for. Adding capacity every four years means building 864.9 MWh first and 280.9 MWh later, for a present value of $35.4m, $55.1m less.

The assumptions

Illustrative battery, invented figures, before tax
ItemValue
Usable energy the contract requires, every year800 MWh
Contract length15 years
Fade, a fixed share of the original capacity of each module, per year2.5%
Installed cost today$210 per kWh
Fall in installed cost, a year6.0%
Discount rate8.0%
Capacity usable in year n for a module installed in year soriginal × (1 − 2.5% × (n − s))

Year 1 has no fade, so a module installed in year 1 has lost 2.5% × 14 = 35% of its capacity by year 15. Fade is taken as linear to keep the arithmetic visible; real cells fade faster early on and the principle is unchanged.

Step 1: oversize on day one

Capacity needed = 800 / (1 − 2.5% × 14) = 800 / 0.65 = 1,230.8 MWh

Extra capacity = 1,230.8 − 800 = 430.8 MWh

Cost of the extra = 430.8 MWh × $210,000 = $90.5m, all spent today

Excel: =800/(1-0.025*14)

Step 2: augment every four years

Build enough on day one for years 1 to 4: 800 / (1 − 2.5% × 3) = 864.9 MWh

At the start of year 5, 9 and 13, add the module that restores 800 MWh in the last year of the next four: (800 − usable from existing modules in that year) / (1 − 2.5% × years it will have faded)

Excel: =(800-Existing)/(1-0.025*3)

Augmentation every four years, cost per kWh falling 6% a year
PurchaseAdded, MWhCost per kWhCost, $mPresent value, $m
Extra on day one64.9$21013.613.6
Start of year 593.5$16415.311.3
Start of year 9103.6$12813.37.2
Start of year 1383.8$1008.43.3
Total345.850.635.4

Total installed is 1,145.8 MWh against 1,230.8 for oversizing, 85.0 MWh less, and 60.9% of the oversizing cost is saved in present value. The saving comes from paying later and from paying a lower price: each module is bought for 6% less than the last.

What if: another interval, a fixed cost per visit, no price fall

Augmentation at different intervals, present value of cost, $m
IntervalPurchasesInstalled on day one, MWhTotal installed, MWhPresent valueWith $3.0m per purchase
Every 2 years7820.51,135.329.641.5
Every 3 years4842.11,141.232.639.5
Every 4 years3864.91,145.835.440.4
Every 5 years2888.91,152.939.042.4
Every 7 years2941.21,163.345.948.7
Oversize on day one01,230.81,230.890.590.5

Buying more often is cheaper until each purchase carries a cost of its own: with $3.0m of mobilisation and integration per purchase, the lowest cost is an augmentation every 3 years, $39.5m. If installed cost does not fall at all, augmenting every four years costs $46.8m, still $43.7m less than oversizing.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What is battery augmentation?

Adding new battery modules during the life of a project to replace the capacity lost to degradation, so that the usable energy stays at the contracted level. Here 800 MWh is kept for 15 years by three additions of 93.5, 103.6 and 83.8 MWh.

Why can augmentation be cheaper than oversizing?

It defers spending, so it is discounted, and it buys later modules at a lower price. Here $35.4m in present value against $90.5m, and the gap remains at $43.7m if installed cost does not fall.

How often should a battery be augmented?

More often is cheaper until each purchase has a fixed cost. With $3.0m per purchase in this example, every 3 years has the lowest present value cost, $39.5m.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Battery Storage Development Handbook value a fictional 200 MW / 800 MWh battery under merchant, toll and floor cases, with degradation, augmentation, the investment credit, the foreign entity test and debt. The battery in this article is simplified and its figures are invented; they are not those of the workbook. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on energy, infrastructure and land, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: infrastructure, data centres and energy → · All 1908 articles →