Articles

Does a 20 per cent promote actually pay the GP 20 per cent?

The rate in the term sheet does not decide the carry; the definition of profit underneath it does.

A fund that returns $170,000,000 on $100,000,000 of contributed capital, after an 8 per cent preferred return and a 100 per cent catch-up, pays the general partner $14,000,000: exactly 20 per cent of the $70,000,000 of profit. A completed catch-up hands back to the general partner whatever the preferred return took first. The promote overshoots only when the catch-up is drafted as 20 per cent of total profit and the 80/20 split then runs on top of it: that version pays $17,200,000, 24.6 per cent.

Worked in full in Real Estate Fund Management by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or see it on Amazon

The waterfall, step by step

The example is stripped down so the mechanics are visible. Limited partners contribute $100,000,000 at inception. The fund distributes $170,000,000 in a single liquidation at the end of year 5. The preferred return is 8 per cent per year, simple, on unreturned contributed capital. The catch-up is 100 per cent. The promote is 20 per cent. The general partner commitment is ignored. Every dollar moves once, so nothing in the result depends on timing.

Four steps then run in order, and each one consumes what the step before it left.

European-style waterfall: $170,000,000 distributed on $100,000,000 of capital.
StepAmount
Total distributions at the end of the fund$170,000,000
Return of capital to limited partners$100,000,000
Profit above capital$70,000,000
Preferred return, 8 per cent for 5 years$40,000,000
Remaining after the preferred return$30,000,000
Catch-up to the general partner$10,000,000
Remaining after the catch-up$20,000,000
Residual split 80/20, limited partners$16,000,000
Residual split 80/20, general partner$4,000,000
General partner total carry$14,000,000

The limited partners end with $156,000,000: $100,000,000 of capital, $40,000,000 of preferred return and $16,000,000 of residual. The two final totals sum back to $170,000,000, which is the only check that matters when a waterfall is being tested.

Learn the whole method: Real Estate Modeling

A course built on one logistics park, from the rent roll to the loan, the returns, a development, the JV waterfall and quarterly NAV, with Excel exercises, a 160-question quiz and the Real Estate Acquisition and Development Model, Pro Edition included ($149).

Try module 4 and ten quiz questions, free →

How big is the catch-up?

The catch-up runs 100 per cent to the general partner until it holds 20 per cent of everything distributed above capital so far: the preferred return plus the catch-up itself. Call the catch-up X. Then X = 20 per cent of ($40,000,000 + X), so X = $40,000,000 × 0.20 ÷ 0.80 = $10,000,000.

From that point every dollar is split 80/20, so the general partner stays at 20 per cent of profit all the way up: $10,000,000 plus 20 per cent of the remaining $20,000,000 is $14,000,000.

The trap is a catch-up written as “20 per cent of total profit”. It pays $14,000,000 at once, the right total in the wrong row, and the 80/20 split then hands the general partner another $3,200,000 of the $16,000,000 left. That drafting pays $17,200,000: 24.6 per cent, not 20.

Three readings, three answers

The phrase “20 per cent promote” does not settle the question, because it does not say what the 20 per cent is 20 per cent of. Three readings of the same three words produce three different cheques out of the same $70,000,000.

Same fund, same $70,000,000 of profit, three definitions of the promote.
Reading of “a 20 per cent promote”To the GP ($m)
Catch-up drafted as 20 per cent of total profit, then an 80/20 residual split on top17.2
Catch-up until the general partner holds 20 per cent of all profit, then 80/2014.0
Promote applies only to the profit left after the preferred return6.0

The widest reading pays $17.2 million. The narrowest pays $6.0 million. Nothing in the term sheet headline distinguishes them, and a limited partner model that assumes one while the document says another will misprice the fund by more than the entire residual split.

What to settle before the document is signed

Four definitions do the work. Each one should be answered in the fund documents in a way an auditor could apply without asking a question.

The last question is the one that survives a good market. A fund buys five assets. Two outperform and are sold in year 3, and under a deal-by-deal waterfall the general partner earns carry on those sales immediately. The remaining three run into leasing trouble and are sold at breakeven. The final fund return is mediocre, but the carry has already been taken. A fund-level waterfall makes that impossible; a clawback makes it recoverable, which is not the same thing and is worth less.

Run the four steps above on a live fund before the next close, and run them again under each of the three readings. If the three answers are close together, the drafting is tight. If they span $6.0 million to $17.2 million, the promote has not been negotiated yet — only its headline rate has.

Free Excel template: JV waterfall and promote model.

Questions readers ask

How does a GP catch-up work in a private real estate fund?

After capital and the preferred return are paid, the catch-up sends distributions to the general partner until it holds its target share of profit. On $70,000,000 of profit at a 20 per cent target, after a $40,000,000 preferred return, the catch-up is $10,000,000: enough for the general partner to hold 20 per cent of the pref plus the catch-up itself.

Does the preferred return count as profit when carry is calculated?

That depends on the document, and the gap is wide. Counted inside the profit base, with a catch-up that stops once the general partner holds 20 per cent, the general partner takes $14,000,000. Treated as profit the promote cannot reach, it takes $6.0 million on exactly the same $70,000,000. A catch-up drafted as 20 per cent of total profit, with the split run on top, pays $17,200,000.

Why do investors prefer a fund-level waterfall to deal-by-deal carry?

Sequencing. A fund buys five assets, sells two winners in year 3 and takes carry at once; the remaining three sell at breakeven and the fund return is mediocre. The general partner has already been paid. A fund-level waterfall prevents that; a clawback only tries to reverse it.

Run the numbers yourself: the free distribution waterfall model splits fund profits between investors and the manager in Excel, with preferred return, catch-up and carried interest. For a closed-end fund with up to eight assets, fees and a European or American waterfall, see the Real Estate Fund Model, Pro Edition ($129).

Read the whole case

This article is one calculation from Real Estate Fund Management. The book takes the same case from first principles to the decision, chapter by chapter, and every figure it prints is a live formula in the free companion workbooks.

Get the book on Amazon →Free companion files

Also on Amazon UK · Amazon Germany · Amazon France · Amazon Canada

Prefer a PDF? The same book is sold as a DRM-free PDF edition, searchable and printable. Get the PDF edition, $19.99

Not on Amazon: 24 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on insurance and retirement, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: real estate investing, finance and fund management → · All 1908 articles →

If this book helped — or didn’t — a few lines on Amazon are worth more than they look: they are what the next reader goes on. Write a review. The workbook stays free either way.