Articles

Successful efforts vs full cost: a worked example

The same leases, seismic, dry hole and wells booked under both methods for two years, the two pre-tax results, and the gap explained line by line.

Successful efforts and full cost are two ways of booking the same oil and gas spending. Under successful efforts, only the costs that find proved reserves stay on the balance sheet; under full cost, every acquisition, exploration and development cost of a country goes into one pool, dry holes included. Below, one producer's two years are booked both ways, and the gap between the two pre-tax results is explained line by line.

Worked in full in The Oil and Gas Accounting Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →

What each method keeps

As read in November 2026, successful efforts is set out in ASC 932: acquisition costs of leases are capitalized, geological and geophysical costs and delay rentals are expensed, an exploratory well stays capitalized only while it waits for its outcome and goes to expense if it is dry, and development costs are capitalized even when a development well is dry. Full cost is set out for SEC registrants in Regulation S-X Rule 4-10: every cost of acquiring, exploring and developing reserves in a cost center (a country) is capitalized in one pool, amortized on the reserves of the whole country and capped by a ceiling.

The case is fictional: Varnholt Exploration, Inc., a listed US independent producer with all its properties in one onshore basin, reporting under US GAAP with a calendar year. It reports under successful efforts; the book keeps a full cost ledger of the same transactions for comparison. Every price, reserve quantity and cost below is a teaching assumption of that case, not a market figure, and the facts of your own company govern.

The 2025 spending, booked twice

2025 itemSuccessful effortsFull costAmount
Unproved leases acquiredUnproved propertiesPool$12,500,000
Geological and geophysical costs (seismic)ExpensePool$3,200,000
Delay rentalsExpensePool$300,000
Saltcedar #1, dry exploratory wellExpensePool$9,000,000
Copperline #1, discoveryWells of the new fieldPool$11,000,000
Kettle Ridge development, one dry well includedWells of the fieldPool$14,000,000
Saltcedar lease surrenderedExpenseStays in the pool$2,500,000

Successful efforts sends $3,200,000 + $300,000 + $9,000,000 = $12,500,000 to exploration expense and $2,500,000 to the abandonment of unproved properties. Full cost expenses none of it: the pool grows by $50,700,000, the year's additions including the asset retirement costs of the new wells.

2025: full cost earns more

Before income taxSuccessful effortsFull cost
Revenue$56,000,000$56,000,000
Production costs($22,000,000)($22,000,000)
Exploration expense($12,500,000)-
Abandonment and impairment of unproved properties($2,500,000)-
DD&A($10,410,145)($16,045,902)
Accretion of asset retirement obligations($420,000)($420,000)
Result before income tax$8,169,855$17,534,098

The gap is $17,534,098 - $8,169,855 = $9,364,243: the $12,500,000 of exploration expense and the $2,500,000 lease that full cost keeps in the pool, less the higher full cost DD&A, $16,045,902 - $10,410,145 = $5,635,757. Full cost DD&A is higher because its base still carries every past dry hole and seismic survey; the computation is in the article on units-of-production depletion.

2026: the price falls and the order reverses

Before income taxSuccessful effortsFull cost
Revenue$52,200,000$52,200,000
Production costs($26,010,000)($26,010,000)
Exploration expense($1,750,000)-
Abandonment and impairment of unproved properties($3,600,000)-
DD&A($12,088,243)($19,116,819)
Ceiling write-down-($25,049,175)
Accretion of asset retirement obligations($505,400)($505,400)
Loss on settlement of an asset retirement obligation($70,000)-
Result before income tax$8,176,357($18,481,394)

The gap is now $8,176,357 + $18,481,394 = $26,657,751: the write-down of $25,049,175 plus the higher full cost DD&A of $7,028,576, less the successful efforts charges that the pool absorbs (exploration expense $1,750,000, the impairment of the Bitterwell lease $3,600,000 and the settlement loss $70,000). The write-down comes from the ceiling test, worked in the ceiling test example. Under successful efforts the same price fall triggers an impairment test of each field, and both fields pass: Kettle Ridge carries $76,094,112 against undiscounted cash flows of $251,045,000 at management's outlook of $66 per BOE.

Two years, two pictures

Over the two years successful efforts reports $8,169,855 + $8,176,357 = $16,346,212 before income tax; full cost reports a profit then a loss, a two-year loss of $947,296. The balance sheets diverge too: net capitalized costs at 31 December 2026 are $119,101,612 under successful efforts and $179,808,104 under full cost, after the write-down. The cash, the reserves and the production are identical in both columns.

Mistakes that recur in the file

Rules are described as read in November 2026 from the FASB Accounting Standards Codification (Topic 932, Extractive Activities, Oil and Gas; Topic 360 for the impairment of successful efforts fields) and SEC Regulation S-X Rule 4-10 for full cost, and they change. This page is education, not accounting, engineering or audit advice: your company's facts govern, and its accountants, reserve engineers and auditors decide.

Questions people ask

What is the main difference between successful efforts and full cost?

What happens to unsuccessful exploration. Successful efforts expenses geological and geophysical costs, delay rentals and dry exploratory wells; full cost capitalizes them in a pool with every other cost of the country.

Which method gives higher earnings?

Neither always. Full cost usually shows higher earnings while exploration fails, then lower earnings through higher depletion and, after a price fall, a ceiling write-down. In the book's case full cost earns $17,534,098 in 2025 and loses $18,481,394 in 2026.

Is a dry development well expensed under successful efforts?

No. Development costs are capitalized whether or not the well is productive; only exploratory dry holes go to expense.

Can a company switch from full cost to successful efforts?

A change of method is a change in accounting principle applied retrospectively under ASC 250, and the new method must be preferable. Moves toward successful efforts are the usual direction.

Do the two methods change cash flow?

No. The cash spent and received is the same; the methods change only what is expensed, when, and the classification of exploration spending in the cash flow statement.

Read the whole case

This article is one step of The Oil and Gas Accounting Handbook. The book follows one listed producer through two year-ends: reserves estimated and signed, ownership, royalties and joint interest billing, leases, dry holes and a suspended well, depletion field by field, impairment, the full cost pool and its ceiling, asset retirement obligations, the ASC 932 disclosures and the standardized measure, and the close that ties them together.

Paperback PDF edition, $19.99 Book page and free files

Free: the successful efforts vs full cost model in Excel.

Also on this site

Case figures computed by the book's model; the companies are fictional and every term is a teaching assumption. Figures checked on 21 November 2026. Rules described as read on the dates given; not accounting or audit advice.