Articles

At what oil price does a reserve-based borrowing base fall below the loan?

The borrowing base is a bank’s estimate of what the reserves are worth at its price deck. A fixed operating cost makes it fall faster than the price.

A reserve-based loan of $100.0m on producing oil reserves has a borrowing base of $119.2m when the bank’s price deck is $70.00 a barrel: 60% of a PV10 of $198.6m. The base equals the loan at $62.54, a 10.7% fall in the deck. At $50.00 the borrowing base is $67.7m and the borrower faces a deficiency of $32.3m.

The assumptions

Illustrative producing reserves, invented figures
ItemValue
Net oil production, year 11.50 million barrels
Annual decline20.0%
Life of the reserves in the report8 years
Lease operating cost$22.00 a barrel
Severance and ad valorem taxes7.0% of revenue
Discount rate (PV10)10.0%
Advance rate on PV1060.0%
Amount drawn$100.0m

The lender sets the oil price deck in each redetermination, usually twice a year. The reserve engineer supplies the volumes and costs; the bank applies its own prices and advance rate. Hedges, capital costs for new wells and general overhead are left out so that the effect of the price stands alone.

Step 1: the cash flow of the reserves at $70.00

Net cash flow = barrels × (price × (1 − 7.0%) − $22.00)

Year 1: 1.50 × (70.00 × 0.93 − 22.00) = $64.6m

Excel: =Barrels*(Price*(1-Tax)-Opex)

Reserves at a $70.00 deck, $m except barrels
YearMillion barrelsNet cash flowDiscount factorPresent value
11.5064.60.9158.8
21.2051.70.8342.7
30.9641.40.7531.1
40.7733.10.6822.6
50.6126.50.6216.4
60.4921.20.5612.0
70.3916.90.518.7
80.3113.60.476.3
Total6.24269.0198.6

Step 2: the borrowing base

PV10 = $198.6m

Borrowing base = 60.0% × PV10 = 0.60 × 198.6 = $119.2m

The $100.0m loan is 83.9% of the borrowing base, and 50.3% of the PV10: the bank has $98.6m of present value of reserves above the debt.

Step 3: the borrowing base at other prices

The same reserves under four price decks, $m
Oil pricePV10Borrowing baseHeadroomLoan / PV10
$50.00112.967.7-32.388.6%
$60.00155.893.5-6.564.2%
$70.00198.6119.219.250.3%
$80.00241.5144.944.941.4%

Each $1.00 on the deck moves the borrowing base by about $2.57m. A fall from $70.00 to $50.00 takes away $51.4m, 43.2% of the base, from a 28.6% fall in price: the operating cost is fixed in dollars, so the cash flow falls faster than the price.

Break-even deck: the price at which 0.60 × PV10 = 100.0 is $62.54

Deficiency at $50.00: 100.0 − 67.7 = $32.3m; at $60.00: 100.0 − 93.5 = $6.5m

What if: a higher discount rate or a lower advance rate

A bank that discounts at 12.0% instead of 10.0% gets a borrowing base of $113.0m at $70.00, and the break-even deck rises to $64.67. An advance rate of 55.0% takes the base to $109.2m and the break-even to $66.08; 50.0% takes it to $70.32. At 50.0% the break-even deck is above the $70.00 starting deck, so the loan would already be in deficiency: a change in the bank’s method can matter as much as a change in the price.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How is a reserve-based borrowing base calculated?

The bank takes the present value of the net cash flows of the producing reserves at its own price deck and discount rate, then applies an advance rate. Here 60.0% of a $198.6m PV10 gives $119.2m at $70.00.

At what oil price does the borrowing base fall below the loan?

At $62.54 for the $100.0m loan in this example, a 10.7% fall from $70.00. The price deck is set by the bank at each redetermination.

What happens when the borrowing base falls below the loan?

The borrower has a deficiency and normally a set period to cure it, by repaying, adding reserves as collateral or a mix. At $50.00 the deficiency in this example is $32.3m.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Oil and Gas Lender rebuild a fictional bank’s three oil and gas files: reserve reports run to the economic limit, three borrowing bases with hedge credit, a deficiency and its cure, covenants and a prepackaged chapter 11. The reserves in this article are invented and are not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 11 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on banking, credit and payments, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: credit, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →