Articles · Section 1091 Handbook

Substantially Identical Securities: ETFs, Mutual Funds, Options, and Bonds

Where the IRS draws the line on index ETFs, derivatives, fixed income, and digital assets.

Neither the Internal Revenue Code nor the Treasury Regulations provide a mechanical formula for what makes two securities "substantially identical" under IRC Section 1091(a). Successful tax-loss harvesting depends on understanding where the IRS draws hard lines across ETFs, options, bonds, and digital assets.

1. ETFs and Index Mutual Funds: Same Index vs Distinct Benchmark

Swapping two ETFs that track the exact same benchmark (such as two S&P 500 index ETFs) sits in an unlitigated gray zone that conservative institutional tax desks avoid because the underlying baskets and return streams are virtually indistinguishable. By contrast, swapping an S&P 500 ETF into a Russell 1000 or Total Market ETF introduces a different index provider, different constituent count (500 vs 1,000+ stocks), and distinct rebalancing rules while maintaining roughly 99% equity correlation.

In Meridian Cluster 7, Marcus sells 2,000 shares of MSPX (S&P 500 ETF) at $440.00 ($880,000.00) for a -$70,000.00 short-term loss and immediately buys $880,000.00 of MR1K (Russell 1000 ETF) on the same day. The swap triggers $0.00 of wash sale disallowance and locks in $28,560.00 in immediate federal tax savings at 40.80%.

2. Call Options (Section 1091(f)) and Deep-in-the-Money Puts (Rev. Rul. 85-87)

Under IRC Section 1091(a) and (f), acquiring a call option on the same stock within 30 days of a loss sale triggers wash sale disallowance. In Meridian Cluster 5 (STBL), Marcus sells 500 shares for a -$12,000.00 loss and buys 5 call contracts ($1,800.00 premium) 10 days later. The entire $12,000.00 loss is disallowed and added to the call option basis ($13,800.00), yet the broker reports $0.00 on Form 1099-B because options carry a distinct OCC symbol.

Under Revenue Ruling 85-87, writing a deep-in-the-money put option (for example, selling a $60.00 strike put for $20.50 when the stock trades at $40.00, where 97.56% of the premium is intrinsic value) is treated as a contract to acquire the stock and triggers the exact same disallowance.

3. Bonds and Convertible Securities

Under Revenue Rulings 58-210 and 58-211 and Hanlin v. Commissioner, 108 F.2d 429 (3d Cir. 1939), bonds are substantially identical only if they share the same issuer, same coupon, and substantially identical maturity and call dates. Changing issuer, coupon, or maturity meaningfully breaks substantial identity. Under Revenue Ruling 77-201, convertible preferred stock trading at parity with common stock is substantially identical to the underlying common.

4. Digital Assets Under Current US Law (November 2026)

Under IRS Notice 2014-21, spot cryptocurrency is classified as property rather than stock or securities, so IRC Section 1091 does not currently apply to spot crypto dispositions as of November 2026. However, spot crypto ETFs are securities fully subject to Section 1091, Form 1099-DA cost-basis reporting begins for 2026 covered digital assets, and instantaneous zero-risk crypto round-trips still face scrutiny under the Section 7701(o) economic substance doctrine.

Explore more: 61-day window & Section 1223(3) tacking and the Rev. Rul. 2008-5 IRA trap.

Go Deeper with the Handbook and Free Excel Calculator

Every calculation in this guide is modeled live in our free unlocked workbook and covered in full statutory detail in The Section 1091 Wash Sales and Tax-Loss Harvesting Handbook.

Explore the Handbook Download Free Excel Calculator

Related US Tax Handbooks by Julian R. Sterling