Articles · Section 1091 Handbook

Rev. Rul. 2008-5: The IRA and Roth IRA Permanent Wash Sale Loss Trap

How cross-account IRA purchases and DRIPs erase tax losses forever, and how to build an airtight firewall.

Most taxable wash sales merely defer a capital loss into the cost basis of replacement shares. Under Revenue Ruling 2008-5, however, buying a substantially identical security inside a Traditional IRA or Roth IRA within 30 days before or after a taxable loss sale permanently destroys the tax loss.

1. Why Revenue Ruling 2008-5 Destroys Basis Permanently

In Revenue Ruling 2008-5, the IRS ruled that when an individual sells stock at a loss in a taxable brokerage account and causes his or her Traditional IRA or Roth IRA to purchase substantially identical stock within the 61-day window, two consequences follow simultaneously: (1) the taxable loss is disallowed under IRC Section 1091(a), and (2) the individual's basis in the IRA or Roth IRA is not increased under Section 1091(d) because the IRA is a separate tax-exempt trust governed by Sections 408 and 408A.

2. Worked Impact: Meridian Cluster 4 (APFG)

Marcus sells 1,000 shares of APFG in his taxable account (Account A at Apex Clearing) on September 10, 2026 at $55.00 ($55,000.00), originally purchased June 3, 2024 at $75.00 ($75,000.00), realizing a -$20,000.00 long-term loss. Just 12 days later, his Traditional IRA at Beacon Brokerage (Account C) buys 1,000 shares of APFG at $56.00 ($56,000.00).

Compliance MetricAmount
Realized Taxable Loss (Account A)-$20,000.00
Apex Clearing Form 1099-B Box 1g Reported$0.00 (Broker blind to IRA)
Mandatory Form 8949 Code W Adjustment+$20,000.00
Traditional IRA Basis Step-Up Allowed$0.00 (Permanent Destruction)
Permanent Federal Tax Lost (23.80% LTCG / 40.80% STCG)$4,760.00 / $8,160.00

3. The Hidden Trigger: Automatic Dividend Reinvestments (DRIPs) and Broker Blindness

Because IRC Section 6045(g) limits Form 1099-B Box 1g reporting to same-account, identical-CUSIP trades, neither custodian flags this IRA wash sale. Worse, an automatic $25 dividend reinvestment inside an IRA within 30 days of a taxable loss sale triggers Revenue Ruling 2008-5 on the reinvested share count. Institutional wealth managers prevent this trap by enforcing strict ticker segregation between taxable and IRA accounts and disabling DRIPs on overlapping securities.

Also read: 61-day window & basis adjustment math and how to choose clean replacement ETFs without triggering Section 1091.

Go Deeper with the Handbook and Free Excel Calculator

Every calculation in this guide is modeled live in our free unlocked workbook and covered in full statutory detail in The Section 1091 Wash Sales and Tax-Loss Harvesting Handbook.

Explore the Handbook Download Free Excel Calculator

Related US Tax Handbooks by Julian R. Sterling