Articles · IRC Section 305(b)

IRC Section 305(b) Five Taxable Stock Dividend Exceptions: Complete Guide

Under IRC Section 305(a), a pure pro-rata stock dividend is tax-free and shareholder basis is allocated across old and new shares under Section 307(a). Yet the moment a corporation introduces a cash election, dual-class stock, or preferred equity, one of the five statutory exceptions in IRC Section 305(b)(1) through (b)(5) converts the stock distribution into a fully taxable Section 301 dividend measured at fair market value.

Summary of the Five Section 305(b) Exceptions

SubsectionTriggering StructurePrimary Treasury Reg.Tax Result
Section 305(b)(1)Any shareholder has an election to take cash/property or stockTreas. Reg. 1.305-2100% taxable under Section 301 to all eligible holders (even stock electors)
Section 305(b)(2)Cash/property to some holders + increased proportionate interest to othersTreas. Reg. 1.305-3Taxable Section 301 distribution to holders increasing interest
Section 305(b)(3)Preferred stock to some common holders + common stock to other common holdersTreas. Reg. 1.305-4Taxable Section 301 distribution to both recipient groups
Section 305(b)(4)Any distribution on preferred stock (except pure stock-split anti-dilution)Treas. Reg. 1.305-5Taxable Section 301 distribution (including PIK preferred dividends)
Section 305(b)(5)Distribution of convertible preferred stock (unless shown non-disproportionate)Treas. Reg. 1.305-6Presumed taxable unless issuer rebuts selective conversion risk

1. Section 305(b)(1): Optional Cash-or-Stock Dividends and Rev. Proc. 2017-45

Under Treasury Regulation Section 1.305-2(a), if any shareholder can elect cash instead of stock, the distribution is taxable under Section 301 to every eligible shareholder, including those who elect 100% stock. In our worked example (Meridian Precision Systems, Inc.), a $22.00M dividend ($2.00/share on 11,000,000 shares) with a 20.00% cash cap ($4.40M) and 60.00% cash demand yields a 33.3333% cash proration factor for cash electors. Both cash electors and 100% stock electors recognize the full $22,000.00 distribution on 11,000 shares as taxable Section 301 income, taking a fresh $40.00/share FMV basis under Section 301(d). For publicly offered REITs and RICs, Revenue Procedure 2017-45 provides a permanent safe harbor securing the Section 561 dividends paid deduction whenever the aggregate cash cap is at least 20% (note that the temporary 10% relief of Rev. Proc. 2021-53 expired on June 30, 2022).

2. Section 305(b)(2): Disproportionate Dual-Class Distributions and the 36-Month Rule

Section 305(b)(2) is a strict objective result test combining cash/property to some shareholders with an increase in proportionate interest in assets or E&P for others. When Class A (8,000,000 shares) receives a $1.50/share cash dividend ($12.00M) while Class B (2,000,000 shares) receives a 5.00% stock dividend (100,000 shares at $30.00 = $3.00M), Class B ownership increases from 20.0000% to 20.7921% (+79.21 bps). The entire $3.00M Class B stock dividend becomes taxable under Section 301. Under Treasury Regulation Section 1.305-3(b)(4), cash and stock distributions within 36 months require no proof of a plan; isolated redemptions under Section 302(a) are exempt, whereas periodic redemption plans trigger Section 305(c) deemed dividends.

3. Sections 305(b)(3), (b)(4), and (b)(5): Preferred Stock and Participating Carve-Outs

Virtually every distribution on "preferred stock" is automatically taxable under Section 305(b)(4). Under Treasury Regulation Section 1.305-5(a), stock is "preferred stock" if it does not participate in corporate growth to any significant extent (disregarding conversion rights). Uncapped participating preferred stock escapes Section 305(b)(4) and Section 305(c), whereas straight or standard convertible preferred stock remains fully in scope. Remember also that a pro-rata distribution of non-convertible preferred stock to a single class of common stock avoids Section 305(b)(3) and qualifies as tax-free under Section 305(a), but immediately triggers Section 306 preferred stock bailout taint if the corporation has any E&P.

Free Excel Calculator & Complete Handbook

Run these exact Section 305 calculations with live formulas in the free Section 305 Deemed Dividend Calculator in Excel, or get the full 15-chapter practitioner reference in The Section 305 Stock Dividends and Preferred Stock Handbook.

Further reading

Section 305(c) Preferred Stock Redemption Premiums: 0.25% De Minimis Test and Constant Yield Accrual

Section 305(c) Conversion Ratio Adjustments, Form 8937 Reporting, and Nonresident Dry Withholding

Related handbooks: Section 302 and 304 Redemptions · Section 351 Transfers · Section 704(b) and 704(c) · Pillar Two