Articles

Section 280G cutback or gross-up: what does each cost?

Cutback, best-net and gross-up priced for the executive and for the company on one example, with the private company shareholder vote that can make the question disappear.

When an executive's payments cross three times the base amount, someone has to absorb the 20 percent excise tax and the lost deduction. Employment agreements usually settle it in advance with one of three clauses: a cutback, which trims the payments to one dollar under the threshold; a best-net cutback, which trims them only if the executive keeps more that way; or a gross-up, which has the company pay the excise tax and the tax on that payment too. Each clause puts the cost on a different party, and the gross-up costs the most by far.

Worked in full in The Section 280G Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →

Why the choice matters: the cliff

As read in November 2026, section 280G(b)(2)(A) of the Internal Revenue Code makes payments contingent on a change parachute payments only when their present value equals or exceeds three times the base amount, and section 280G(b)(1) then measures the excess over one base amount, not three. Section 4999(a) taxes that excess at 20 percent in the hands of the executive, and section 280G(a) denies the company its deduction on it. Just above the threshold, a small extra payment therefore costs far more than it gives. The three clauses are three answers to that cliff, and the right one depends on the figures, not on habit.

The cutback

A cutback reduces the payments until their total counted in the test is three times the base amount less one dollar. Nothing is then a parachute payment, no excise tax is due and the company keeps every deduction. The agreement should say which payments are cut first, for example cash severance before equity, so that nobody has to decide it at the closing. The executive gives up the reduction; the company pays less and deducts all of it.

The best-net cutback

A best-net clause computes two nets and keeps the larger one: the executive's net after income and payroll taxes and the excise tax if everything is paid, and her net after income and payroll taxes if the cutback applies. The cutback wins when the total is only a little above the threshold, because the reduction is small and it removes the whole excise tax; the full payment wins when the total is far above it. The point where the answer flips depends on the base amount and on the executive's tax rate, so it is computed for each person, never guessed.

The gross-up

A gross-up has the company pay the executive an extra amount large enough to leave her where she would have been with no excise tax at all. That extra amount is itself compensation contingent on the change: it is an excess parachute payment, subject to income and payroll taxes, to the 20 percent excise tax and to the loss of the deduction. The gross-up is therefore the excise tax on the full payment divided by what is left of each dollar after the executive's marginal rate and the 20 percent. It pays tax on tax, and the company loses its deduction on the gross-up as well as on the original excess.

A worked example

A sample executive, not the book's case, has a base amount of $250,000 and payments contingent on the change with a present value of $900,000. Her combined marginal rate of income and payroll taxes is assumed at 45 percent, a teaching assumption, and the company's lost deduction is valued at the 21 percent corporate rate of section 11(b).

For the executiveAmount
Base amount$250,000
Total counted in the test$900,000
Excess parachute payment: $900,000 - $250,000$650,000
Excise tax at 20 percent$130,000
Cutback needed$150,001
Total after the cutback (three times the base amount less $1)$749,999
Executive's net, full payment: $900,000 x 55 percent - $130,000$365,000
Executive's net, cutback: $749,999 x 55 percent$412,499
Gross-up: $130,000 / (1 - 45 percent - 20 percent)$371,429
Cost to the companyAmount
Cutback: payments of $749,999, all deductible$749,999
Full payment: $900,000 plus 21 percent of the $650,000 excess$1,036,500
Gross-up: $900,000 + $371,429, plus 21 percent of the excess, gross-up included$1,485,929

The cutback takes $150,001 of payments away from her and still leaves her a larger net: $412,499 against $365,000, because paying everything would hand $130,000 of excise tax to the government. A best-net clause therefore keeps the cutback here. The gross-up leaves her with the net she would have had without any excise tax, but it costs the company $1,485,929, against $1,036,500 for the full payment and $749,999 for the cutback. Most of the difference is tax, not pay: the gross-up is taxed again in her hands, and none of the excess is deductible.

When the full payment beats the cutback

The case is fictional: Thurlstone Marine Systems, Inc., a privately held US C corporation acquired by merger for cash on October 15, 2025. Every compensation figure, award, date and rate below is a teaching assumption of that case, not a market figure, and the facts of your own company govern.

The answer flips when the total is far above the line. In the book, the chief executive's payments total $2,171,141 against a threshold of $1,374,000. She nets $851,500 if everything is paid and $755,699 after a cutback: the full payment is better by $95,801, so a best-net clause keeps it. For her base amount of $458,000, the breakeven is a total of $1,897,425: above it, paying everything nets more; below it, the cutback does. A gross-up on her payments would cost the company $3,715,414, against $2,530,901 for the full payment and $1,373,999 for the cutback.

Drafting points to check

Rules are described as read in November 2026 from the Internal Revenue Code (26 U.S.C. 280G, 4999, 275, 11 and 1361), Treas. Reg. 1.280G-1 (T.D. 9083), Rev. Proc. 2003-68, Rev. Rul. 2025-19 and the IRS instructions for Forms W-2, W-3, 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC, and they change. This page is education, not tax advice: ask the company's tax advisers how any rule applies to your company.

Questions people ask

What is a 280G cutback?

A clause that reduces the payments contingent on a change until their total is three times the base amount less one dollar, so that no payment is a parachute payment, no excise tax is due and the company keeps its deduction.

What is a best-net cutback?

A clause that applies the cutback only if the executive's net after taxes is larger with it than with the full payment and the 20 percent excise tax. Near the threshold the cutback usually wins; far above it, the full payment does.

How is a 280G gross-up calculated?

The excise tax on the full payment divided by (1 - the executive's marginal rate - 20 percent), because the gross-up is itself taxed and is itself an excess parachute payment.

Can a private company avoid section 280G with a shareholder vote?

In principle, if no stock is readily tradeable: more than 75 percent of the voting power entitled to vote, the disqualified individual's own shares excluded, must approve the payments after adequate disclosure (section 280G(b)(5); Q/A-7).

Which clause should an agreement use?

There is no general answer: it depends on the figures of each executive and on the parties. Compute the three outcomes for each person and ask the company's tax advisers and counsel.

Read the whole case

This article is one step of The Section 280G Handbook. The book follows one private company through its sale by merger: five people tested, five base amounts rebuilt, every payment marked once, accelerated vesting valued tranche by tranche, one executive over the line and one just under it, the excise tax and its withholding, the lost deduction, a cutback, a best-net comparison, a gross-up, a shareholder vote and five sensitivities.

Paperback PDF edition, $19.99 Book page and free files

Free: the Section 280G golden parachute calculator in Excel.

Also on this site

Case figures computed by the book's model; the companies are fictional and every term is a teaching assumption. Figures checked on 20 November 2026. Rules described as read on the dates given; not tax advice.