Articles

How is accelerated vesting valued under Section 280G Q&A-24?

The full value as a rule, the time value only for a vested payment paid early, and the time value plus 1 percent a month for a service-only award: one example of each.

Accelerated vesting is often the largest line of a section 280G calculation, and the one most often overstated. When a deal makes an award vest early, the regulations do not always count its full value: if the executive would have received it anyway by staying, only the value of receiving it sooner, plus 1 percent a month for the service no longer required, is contingent on the change. Q/A-24 of Treas. Reg. 1.280G-1 (often written Q&A-24) sets out the cases, and each award takes exactly one of them.

Worked in full in The Section 280G Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →

Why vesting is a payment at all

As read in November 2026, Q/A-11 and Q/A-13 of Treas. Reg. 1.280G-1 treat transfers of property, including the vesting of restricted stock and units and the acceleration of options, as payments in the nature of compensation. A payment is considered made when it is includible in income, and an option is treated as transferred when it vests, valued on all the facts and circumstances, including the spread, the volatility and the remaining term. Q/A-24 adds that accelerated vesting of an option, or the lapse of a restriction on stock, is treated as significantly increasing its value. The acceleration itself is therefore a payment, and it has to be valued.

The general rule: the full payment counts (Q/A-24(a))

Q/A-24 starts from the full amount: a payment contingent on the change is counted in full unless one of the two narrower rules below applies. Performance awards show the rule at work. When vesting depends on a performance goal that has not been met before the change, Q/A-24(d)(3) makes the full value at the change contingent, because the executive was never sure to receive the award by staying; the 1 percent per month rule does not apply. Amounts payable under an employment agreement for periods after a termination also follow the general rule.

Vested payments paid early (Q/A-24(b))

When a payment was already vested and the change only brings forward the date on which it is paid, the contingent portion is the accelerated amount less the present value of the payment absent the acceleration. Nothing is added for service, because none was still required. A vested deferred compensation balance paid at the closing instead of on a later fixed date is the usual case. In the book's case, a balance of $180,000 due on January 15, 2027 is paid at a change of October 15, 2025: its present value absent the acceleration is $170,203, and only $9,797 enters the test.

Service-only awards that vest early (Q/A-24(c))

When an award vests because of the change and, before the change, it was conditioned only on continued service, the contingent portion is the amount of the accelerated payment less its present value at the date it would otherwise have vested, plus 1 percent of the accelerated payment for each full month between the vesting date at the change and the date on which it would otherwise have vested. The result is never more than the accelerated payment itself. The first part measures the time value of receiving the award sooner; the second is the regulation's fixed price for the service the executive no longer has to give.

Written as a formula, for each tranche: contingent portion = value at the change - present value of that value at the scheduled vesting date + 1 percent x full months x value at the change, capped at the value at the change. Months are full months only, so a tranche 17 and a half months away takes 17. A tranche that was due to vest a few weeks after the closing contributes little; a tranche several years away can approach its full value, and the cap then binds.

A worked example

A sample executive, not the book's case, holds two awards when her company changes hands on June 30, 2026. Each award is valued at the deal price of $12.00 per share. The discount rate here is 4.00 percent, an assumption of the example and not a published rate: for a real calculation, the rate is 120 percent of the applicable federal rate in effect on the change date, compounded semiannually.

LineAmount
Restricted stock units, service only: 25,000 x $12.00$300,000
Scheduled vesting dateDecember 31, 2027
Present value of $300,000 at that date, discounted at 4.00 percent$282,651
Full months between the change and the scheduled date18
1 percent x 18 months x $300,000$54,000
Contingent portion: $300,000 - $282,651 + $54,000$71,349
Performance units, goal not met: 10,000 x $12.00, counted in full$120,000

Of the $300,000 of restricted stock units, only $71,349 is contingent on the change, about a quarter of their value, because she would have received them by staying 18 more months. The performance units count in full, $120,000, although they are worth well under half as much as the restricted units: their goal had not been met, so nothing in Q/A-24(c) reduces them. Counting the restricted units at $300,000 instead would overstate her total by more than her whole performance award, and could push an executive near the threshold over it.

Options: value first, then Q/A-24

An option has to be valued before Q/A-24 can be applied to it. As read in November 2026, Rev. Proc. 2003-68 allows any method consistent with generally accepted accounting principles that reflects the Q/A-13 factors, and offers a safe harbor: number of shares x spot price x a factor from its table. The factor depends on volatility (low up to 30 percent, medium above 30 and below 70 percent, high at 70 percent or more), on the spread (spot price divided by exercise price, less one, which may be rounded down to the next lower interval) and on the term in full months to the latest expiry, which may be rounded down to a 12-month interval; the table cannot be used above 120 months. For stock that is not publicly traded, the spot price has to be consistent with the transaction price, and when the corporation is not required to register its stock, the procedure requires medium volatility.

The example of the free golden parachute calculator runs both steps. Sixty thousand options at $5.00, with a deal price of $10.00 and a medium-volatility factor of 68.3 percent, are worth $409,800. They were due to vest on March 31, 2027, a year after the change, so their present value at the change is $393,887, the 12 months add $49,176, and the contingent portion is $65,089.

What reasonable compensation cannot do

Reasonable compensation for services rendered before the change can reduce an excess parachute payment, but Q/A-24 closes that route for the portions it computes: the portion under Q/A-24(b) or (c) cannot be reduced by reasonable compensation. A covenant not to compete or a consulting arrangement after the closing is analyzed on its own line, under its own rules, and is never netted against an acceleration.

The same rules in the book

The case is fictional: Thurlstone Marine Systems, Inc., a privately held US C corporation acquired by merger for cash on October 15, 2025. Every compensation figure, award, date and rate below is a teaching assumption of that case, not a market figure, and the facts of your own company govern.

The chief executive's three tranches of 40,000 options, each valued at $214,400 under the safe harbor, show how the 1 percent rule grows with time: the tranche that was four months from vesting contributes $12,143, the one 16 months away $47,087. Her performance stock units, whose 2026 revenue goal had not been met at the change, count in full at $240,000. No tranche of the case reaches the cap.

Checks before the figure goes to the committee

Rules are described as read in November 2026 from the Internal Revenue Code (26 U.S.C. 280G, 4999, 275, 11 and 1361), Treas. Reg. 1.280G-1 (T.D. 9083), Rev. Proc. 2003-68, Rev. Rul. 2025-19 and the IRS instructions for Forms W-2, W-3, 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC, and they change. This page is education, not tax advice: ask the company's tax advisers how any rule applies to your company.

Questions people ask

What is Q&A-24 under Section 280G?

It is Q/A-24 of Treas. Reg. 1.280G-1, which says how much of a payment accelerated by a change in control is contingent on the change: the full amount as a rule, less for vested payments paid early (Q/A-24(b)) and for service-only awards that vest early (Q/A-24(c)).

How does the 1 percent per month rule work?

For an award conditioned only on continued service, add 1 percent of the accelerated payment for each full month between the change and the date it would otherwise have vested to the time value of the acceleration. The result never exceeds the value of the payment.

Do performance awards get the reduced valuation?

Not when the goal had not been met before the change: Q/A-24(d)(3) then makes the full value contingent, and the 1 percent rule does not apply.

Which discount rate applies?

120 percent of the applicable federal rate under section 1274(d), compounded semiannually, in effect on the change date (section 280G(d)(4); Q/A-32). For October 2025, Rev. Rul. 2025-19 gives 4.52 percent for the short term.

Can reasonable compensation reduce the accelerated portion?

No. The portion computed under Q/A-24(b) or (c) cannot be reduced by reasonable compensation. Ask the company's tax advisers how the rules apply to a specific award.

Read the whole case

This article is one step of The Section 280G Handbook. The book follows one private company through its sale by merger: five people tested, five base amounts rebuilt, every payment marked once, accelerated vesting valued tranche by tranche, one executive over the line and one just under it, the excise tax and its withholding, the lost deduction, a cutback, a best-net comparison, a gross-up, a shareholder vote and five sensitivities.

Paperback PDF edition, $19.99 Book page and free files

Free: the Section 280G golden parachute calculator in Excel.

Also on this site

Case figures computed by the book's model; the companies are fictional and every term is a teaching assumption. Figures checked on 20 November 2026. Rules described as read on the dates given; not tax advice.