What each election requires, what it includes every year, how far a loss is allowed, and the same 500 shares run under both.
A QEF election taxes your share of the fund's earnings every year, ordinary earnings as ordinary income and net capital gain as long-term capital gain, and needs a PFIC Annual Information Statement from the fund. A mark-to-market election taxes the rise in the share price every year as ordinary income and allows a fall only up to the gains already included, and needs stock that counts as marketable. On 500 shares bought at $40.00, the QEF holder pays $203 and $200 in two years; the mark-to-market holder pays $1,008, then recovers $528.
Worked in full in The PFIC Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →
Without an election, a PFIC holder lives under section 1291: little happens while the fund accumulates, and then a large distribution or a sale is spread back over the holding period, taxed at the top rate of each earlier year and charged interest. Both elections replace that deferred charge with current taxation. They tax different things, ask for different paperwork, and fail in different ways, so the better one depends on the fund and on what the holder can document, not on a general preference.
A qualified electing fund is a PFIC for which the shareholder has elected under section 1295. The election is made on Form 8621, attached to the return for the first year it is to apply and filed by the due date of that return, including extensions. Once made, it applies to every later year unless it is revoked with the consent of the IRS. A retroactive election is possible only in narrow cases, under the protective statement regime or with consent, as the instructions read in November 2026.
The practical condition is the statement. For each year, the fund must give the shareholder a PFIC Annual Information Statement showing the shareholder's pro rata share of the fund's ordinary earnings and net capital gain, or enough information to compute them. Many foreign funds were never built to produce one. Without it, the election cannot be supported, however attractive it looks on paper.
Each year, the shareholder includes the pro rata share of the fund's ordinary earnings as ordinary income and the pro rata share of its net capital gain as long-term capital gain, whether or not anything is paid out. Basis goes up by the amounts included. A later distribution paid out of earnings already included is not taxed again; it reduces basis instead. Section 1294 lets a shareholder elect to extend the time to pay the tax on undistributed inclusions, subject to interest and to events that end the extension; that is a separate choice, made on top of the QEF election.
The cleanest case is a pedigreed QEF: a fund that has been a QEF for every PFIC year of the holder's holding period. Section 1291 then does not apply to its distributions or to a sale. If the election comes after the first PFIC year of the holding period, the earlier years remain tainted unless a purging election is made.
Section 1296 is open only for marketable stock. As read in November 2026, that means stock regularly traded on a national securities exchange registered with the SEC, on the national market system, or on an exchange or market the Treasury finds adequate. The statute also reaches some foreign funds comparable to a regulated investment company that redeem at net asset value, but only to the extent the regulations provide; whether a given redeemable fund would qualify is a point to confirm with your adviser before relying on the election.
At the close of each year, the holder compares the fair market value of the stock with its adjusted basis. An increase is included as ordinary income. A decrease is deductible as an ordinary loss, but only up to the unreversed inclusions: the gains included in earlier years, less the losses already allowed. Basis moves with each amount included or deducted. A gain on a sale is ordinary, and a loss on a sale is ordinary only up to the unreversed inclusions; the rest falls under the general rules.
Timing matters here too. If the election is made after the holding period begins and the fund was not a QEF for every PFIC year before, section 1296(j) applies section 1291 in the first election year: the mark for that year is treated as gain on a disposition, spread back and charged interest. The election cleans the future, not the past.
A sample holder, not the book's case. On January 6, 2025, an investor buys 500 shares of a foreign fund at $40.00 a share. The fund issues a PFIC Annual Information Statement, and its shares are regularly traded on a qualifying exchange, so either election is available from the first year. Each year is taxed at an illustrative 32 percent on ordinary income and 15 percent on net capital gain, a teaching assumption rather than anyone's bracket. The fund closes 2025 at $46.30 and 2026 at $43.00.
| Year and line | QEF election | Mark-to-market election |
|---|---|---|
| 2025: inclusion or mark | Ordinary $541, capital gain $197 | Gain $3,150 (close $46.30) |
| 2025: tax at the illustrative rates | $203 | $1,008 |
| 2026: inclusion or mark | Ordinary $600, capital gain $50 | Loss $1,650 (close $43.00), allowed in full |
| 2026: tax at the illustrative rates | $200 | -$528 |
| What drives the figure | The fund's earnings | The share price at year end |
Under the QEF election, the tax follows the fund's reported earnings: $541 of ordinary earnings and $197 of net capital gain in 2025 give $203; $600 and $50 in 2026 give $200. The price does not enter the calculation at all, and the basis carries the inclusions forward until the shares are sold.
Under mark-to-market, 2025 is a good year on the screen and an expensive one on the return: 500 shares x ($46.30 less $40.00) is a gain of $3,150, all ordinary, for $1,008 of tax. In 2026 the price falls to $43.00. The loss of $1,650 is allowed in full because it stays below the $3,150 included the year before, and it saves $528 at the illustrative rate.
Two readings follow. In a year of rising prices and modest earnings, the QEF holder pays less now and keeps part of the gain for later. In a falling market after a strong year, mark-to-market gives tax back, but only up to what was taxed before: a fall that went deeper than the earlier gains would leave the excess loss unused under section 1296. Over a long holding period, the order of the two elections can reverse, and the gain left untaxed at the end has to be counted before calling a winner.
The book's case is fictional: Leander and Annelise Ellingrove, a married couple of United States citizens filing jointly for 2026 after years abroad, with four foreign holdings: a distributing fund bought in four lots and taxed under the default regime, a balanced fund under a QEF election from the first year, listed index shares under a mark-to-market election made late, and a holding company owned through a foreign operating company. Every amount, price, date and rate is a teaching assumption, not a market figure.
The book runs its distributing fund from 2017 to 2026 under the three regimes at the same illustrative rates. Taxes paid to date come to $9,881 under a QEF election from the first year, $20,031 under the default regime and $23,190 under mark-to-market; the gain not yet taxed at the end of 2026 is $24,338 under the QEF election, $27,590 under the default regime and $0 under mark-to-market. Its listed holding shows the limit on losses: in 2026 the shares lose $7,560 of value, but only $3,420 is deductible and $4,140 is not allowed.
Rules are described as read in November 2026 from the Internal Revenue Code (26 U.S.C. 1291, 1293, 1295, 1296, 1297, 1298 and 6501), the IRS Instructions for Form 8621 (Rev. December 2025) and the IRS table of quarterly interest rates, and they change. Regulations are cited only as those instructions cite them. State rules are not covered. This page is education, not tax advice: the facts of your own return govern, and your tax adviser decides how any rule applies to it.
Not in practice. The election needs, for each year, the shareholder's pro rata share of ordinary earnings and net capital gain or the information to compute them, and the statement is where that information comes from.
Only for marketable stock: stock regularly traded on a qualifying exchange or market, and some funds redeemable at net asset value to the extent the regulations provide. Whether a particular fund qualifies is a point to check with your tax adviser.
No. A year-end decline is deductible only up to the unreversed inclusions, the earlier gains less the losses already allowed. Any excess is not allowed under section 1296.
No. If the election comes after the first PFIC year of the holding period, the earlier years stay under section 1291 unless a purging election is made, and a late mark-to-market election brings a section 1291 charge in its first year.
It depends on the fund's paperwork, its market, how it earns its return and the holder's history with it. The comparison has to be run on the actual holding, and the decision belongs to your tax adviser.
This article is one step of The PFIC Handbook. The book follows one couple through one return: four foreign holdings tested against the income and asset tests, a holding company reached through a 60 percent stake in an operating company, a distributing fund bought in four lots with one lot sold, excess distributions spread over thousands of days, a QEF election from the first year, a mark-to-market election made late, a purge, four Forms 8621 filled line by line, and the same fund run under the three regimes.
Paperback PDF edition, $19.99 Book page and free files
Free: the PFIC excess distribution calculator in Excel.
Case figures computed by the book's model; the companies are fictional and every term is a teaching assumption. Figures checked on 20 November 2026. Rules described as read on the dates given; not tax advice.