Articles

How is a PFIC excess distribution calculated?

The 125 percent test against the three prior years, the excess spread by day over the holding period, tax at the highest rate of each earlier year, and interest on top.

An excess distribution is the part of this year's PFIC distributions that runs above 125 percent of the average received in the three prior years. That part is not taxed as an ordinary dividend. It is spread day by day over the time the shares were held; the slice that lands on the current year is ordinary income, and each earlier slice is taxed at the highest rate of its own year, with interest from that year's due date. On 1,000 shares paying $2.50 after three years averaging $0.95, $1,313 is excess, and it brings $437 of deferred tax and $86 of interest.

Worked in full in The PFIC Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →

Why a PFIC distribution is not just a dividend

A foreign fund that keeps its income inside and pays little out lets a United States investor defer tax for years. The default PFIC regime of section 1291 takes that deferral back, but only when cash comes out or the shares are sold. It does so with two tools. The first decides how much of a distribution is suspicious: anything well above the recent pattern. The second treats that suspicious amount as if it had been earned evenly over the whole holding period, taxes each earlier year's share at the top rate of that year, and charges interest as if the tax had been paid late. Nothing in the calculation depends on how much income the fund actually earned in those years.

The regime applies to a fund for which the holder has made neither a QEF election nor a mark-to-market election, or made one too late to cover every PFIC year of the holding period. It works share by share, although shares bought on the same day share one holding period and can be computed together. In practice, that means one calculation per purchase lot.

Step 1: the 125 percent test

Add up the distributions received on the lot during the current year. Then take the distributions received in the three preceding taxable years and divide by three; if the shares have been held for a shorter time, the instructions for Form 8621 divide by the number of earlier years of the holding period instead. Anything above 125 percent of that average is the total excess distribution for the year. The rest, up to the 125 percent line, is the nonexcess distribution, which is taxed under the ordinary dividend rules.

Three refinements matter. In the year the holding period begins, there is no excess distribution at all, whatever the amount paid. If the shares were not held for the whole year, the test is annualized. And the computation is made in the currency of the distribution and translated at the spot rate of the payment date; the example below stays in dollars to keep the steps visible.

Step 2: spread the excess over the holding period, day by day

The holding period starts the day after purchase and, for a distribution, ends on the date it is paid. The excess is allocated ratably to each day of that period. A year with more days of holding receives a larger share, which is why a partial first year and a partial current year usually get small slices. Two kinds of slice are taxed as ordinary income of the current year, with no interest: the slice for the current year itself, and any slice for days before the company's first year as a PFIC. Every other slice becomes an increase in tax.

Step 3: tax each earlier slice at that year's top rate

Each slice allocated to an earlier PFIC year is multiplied by the highest rate of tax in effect for that year under section 1, whatever the investor's actual bracket was. The table in the instructions for Form 8621, as read in November 2026, gives 37 percent for 2018 to 2025 and 39.6 percent for 2013 to 2017. The sum of these increases is the deferred tax. It is added to the tax of the current year.

Step 4: interest from each year's due date

Interest runs on each year's increase from the due date of that year's return, without extensions, to the due date of the current year's return. The rate is the underpayment rate of section 6621, which changes by quarter, and the interest is compounded daily. Older slices therefore carry more interest even at the same rate of tax. When the calculation is done before the rates for the last months are published, the missing quarter has to be assumed and stated; the example below assumes 7 percent for January 1 to April 15, 2027.

A worked example

A sample holder, not the book's case. On January 10, 2022, an investor buys 1,000 shares of a foreign fund that has been a PFIC since before the purchase, and makes no election. Nothing is paid in 2022. The fund then pays $0.90, $0.95 and $1.00 per share in 2023, 2024 and 2025, and a much larger $2.50 per share on June 15, 2026. All figures are teaching assumptions.

LineAmount
Shares held, bought January 10, 20221,000
Distributions per share, 2023 / 2024 / 2025$0.90 / $0.95 / $1.00
Average of the three prior years, per share$0.95
125 percent of that average, per share$1.1875
2026 distribution, paid June 151,000 x $2.50 = $2,500
Nonexcess distribution (up to 125 percent of the average)$1,187
Excess distribution$1,313
Part allocated to 2026 (current year, ordinary income)$135
Deferred tax on the parts allocated to 2022 to 2025, at 37 percent$437
Interest on that deferred tax to April 15, 2027$86

The three prior years are 2023, 2024 and 2025; 2022 is part of the holding period but falls outside the three-year window. Their average is $0.95 per share, and 125 percent of it is $1.1875. On 1,000 shares, $1,187 of the $2,500 paid is therefore nonexcess and $1,313 is excess. The cents are dropped on the nonexcess line, so the two parts still add up to the distribution.

The holding period runs from January 11, 2022 to June 15, 2026. The excess is spread over it in proportion to days:

YearDays heldTax on the sliceInterest from
202235537 percentApril 15, 2023
202336537 percentApril 15, 2024
202436637 percentApril 15, 2025
202536537 percentApril 15, 2026
2026166Ordinary income of 2026, no interestNone

The 166 days of 2026 take $135, taxed as ordinary income of 2026. The four earlier years take the rest, each at 37 percent, for $437 of deferred tax. Interest on each year's piece runs from April 15 of the following year to April 15, 2027, at the quarterly underpayment rates, for $86. The 2022 slice is the oldest and carries the most interest, even though it covers fewer days than 2024.

Read the result against the cash. Of a $2,500 distribution, $1,187 is a dividend taxed at the holder's ordinary rules, $135 is ordinary income, and the rest of the excess produces $437 of tax plus $86 of interest. The rate on the old slices is the top rate, not the investor's own: a holder in a lower bracket pays more than a dividend would have cost, which is precisely what the regime is designed to do.

A sale works the same way

Gain on the sale of PFIC stock under the default regime is treated like an excess distribution: all of it, not just a part above any threshold. It is spread by day over the holding period of the lot sold, taxed at the top rate of each earlier year with interest, and only the current year's slice is ordinary income. A loss is not offset against it under section 1291. The instructions also treat stock as disposed of when it is pledged as security for a loan, which can trigger the calculation without any sale.

What the calculation needs from the file

Mistakes that recur