Articles

When does a lump-sum window trigger pension settlement accounting?

The threshold test, the share of the obligation settled, the loss recycled from accumulated other comprehensive income, and the entry, on one plan's window.

A lump-sum window removes obligation and assets from a pension plan at the same time, so the funded status barely moves. The accounting can still move a lot: once the payouts of the year exceed a threshold, ASC 715 requires a pro rata share of the net loss in accumulated other comprehensive income to be recognized in cost at once. Below, one window is tested, measured and booked.

Worked in full in The Pension Accounting Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →

What counts as a settlement

As read in November 2026, a settlement under ASC 715-30 is an irrevocable action that relieves the employer or the plan of primary responsibility for a benefit obligation and eliminates significant risks related to it: lump-sum cash payments to participants in exchange for their rights, or the purchase of nonparticipating annuity contracts. A lump-sum window offered to terminated vested participants is the common case.

The case is fictional: Kessenridge Fabrication, Inc., a listed US maker of castings that reports under US GAAP with a calendar year and sponsors a funded final average pay plan. Every rate, obligation, return and amount below is a teaching assumption of that case, not a market figure, and the facts of your own plan govern.

The window

In the fourth quarter of 2026 the company offered a lump sum to its 860 terminated vested participants. 412 accepted, and the plan paid them $12,400,000 from its trust on 31 December 2026. The lump sums equal the obligation settled, so the payment itself creates no gain or loss on conversion.

Step 1: the threshold test

Settlement accounting is required when the cost of all settlements in a year exceeds the sum of service cost and interest cost of that year. Below the threshold it is permitted but not required, and the policy chosen must be applied consistently. This company's policy is not to apply settlement accounting at or under the threshold.

Settlement test and loss, 2026Amount
Service cost 2026$2,700,000
Interest cost 2026$8,496,550
Threshold: service cost + interest cost$11,196,550
Lump sums paid on 31 December 2026$12,400,000
Settlement accounting required?Yes
Obligation before the lump sums, remeasured at 31 December 2026$155,000,000
Share of the obligation settled8 percent
Net loss in AOCI after the remeasurement$24,000,000
Settlement loss: 8 percent x $24,000,000$1,920,000

Step 2: remeasure, then take the share

The obligation and the assets are remeasured at the settlement date. Here the payment date is the year-end, so the year-end valuation serves: the actuary's obligation before the lump sums is $155,000,000, and $12,400,000 / $155,000,000 = 8 percent of it is settled. The net loss subject to recycling is the one after that remeasurement: $23,332,900 at 1 January, less the corridor amortization of $703,900, less the obligation gain of $2,496,550, plus the asset loss of $3,867,550, that is $24,000,000. Had the window paid out in mid-year, a remeasurement at the payment date would have been needed.

Step 3: the loss, and what it leaves out

The settlement loss is 8 percent x $24,000,000 = $1,920,000. The prior service cost of $3,000,000 in accumulated other comprehensive income is not part of it: a settlement recycles net gains and losses, not prior service cost. The net loss falls to $22,080,000.

Step 4: the entry

Entry at 31 December 2026DebitCredit
Settlement loss (other components of net periodic benefit cost)$1,920,000
Other comprehensive income (reclassification)$1,920,000

The payment of $12,400,000 needs no entry in the company's books: it leaves the trust, and the obligation and the plan assets each fall by the same amount. The closing obligation is $155,000,000 - $12,400,000 = $142,600,000, the assets are $127,592,210, and the funded status is a liability of $15,007,790. The loss sits below income from operations and raises net periodic pension cost to $5,250,690.

Settlement or curtailment?

A curtailment cuts future service; a settlement pays out accrued benefits. As an illustration only, outside the case, a plant closure ending 25 percent of the expected future years of service would recognize 25 percent of the prior service cost of $3,000,000, a loss of $750,000, while the fall of $1,100,000 in the obligation would first offset the net loss in accumulated other comprehensive income. The two events have different tests and different measurements, and the order of recognition matters when both occur.

Mistakes that recur in the file

Under IAS 19

IAS 19 measures a settlement gain or loss as the difference between the obligation settled and the price paid. Here the two are equal, so there is no settlement result in profit or loss, and nothing is recycled from other comprehensive income.

Rules are described as read in November 2026 from the FASB Accounting Standards Codification (Topic 715, Subtopics 715-20 and 715-30) and IAS 19, and they change. This page is education, not accounting, actuarial or audit advice: your plan's facts govern, and its accountants, actuaries and auditors decide.

Questions people ask

When is settlement accounting required for lump-sum payments?

When the cost of all settlements in the year exceeds the sum of service cost and interest cost for the year. Below that threshold it is a policy choice applied consistently.

How is the settlement loss measured?

Remeasure the obligation and the assets at the settlement date, take the share of the obligation settled, and apply it to the net gain or loss in accumulated other comprehensive income after that remeasurement. In the book's case, 8 percent x $24,000,000 = $1,920,000.

Is prior service cost recycled in a settlement?

No. A settlement recycles a pro rata share of the net gain or loss only; prior service cost keeps its own amortization schedule.

Does the payment of lump sums need a journal entry?

Not when the trust pays them: the obligation and the plan assets fall together inside the funded status. The entry is the reclassification of the settlement loss.

Is an annuity purchase a settlement too?

Yes, the purchase of nonparticipating annuity contracts that relieves the plan of the obligation is a settlement, tested and measured the same way.

Read the whole case

This article is one step of The Pension Accounting Handbook. The book follows one listed company and its two plans through two year-ends: the obligation rolled forward and remeasured, the discount rate set and defended, plan assets and their expected return, the corridor, a benefit improvement and a retiree medical cap, a lump-sum window that crosses the settlement threshold, the balance sheet and other comprehensive income, and the pension note written line by line, with IAS 19 compared where it differs.

Paperback PDF edition, $19.99 Book page and free files

Free: the pension cost and funded status model in Excel.

Also on this site

Case figures computed by the book's model; the companies are fictional and every term is a teaching assumption. Figures checked on 20 November 2026. Rules described as read on the dates given; not accounting or audit advice.