Articles

How much does a one-point fall in the discount rate cut the funded status of a pension plan?

Liabilities are priced off the discount rate and assets mostly are not. The gap between their durations, not the market return, moves the funded status.

A plan with $1,000m of assets and $1,100m of liabilities of duration 12 is 90.9% funded. A one-point fall in the discount rate raises the liabilities by 12.2% and the assets by only 3.5%, taking the funded ratio to 83.9% and the deficit from $100m to $199m.

The assumptions

Illustrative pension plan, invented figures
ItemValue
Assets$1,000m: $550m equities, $350m bonds, $100m cash
Liabilities$1,100m at a 5.0% discount rate, modelled as a single payment in year 12, a duration of 12
BondsZero-coupon bonds maturing in 10 years, on the same curve as the liabilities
Equities and cashDo not move with the discount rate in this model
Rate shockParallel move of 1 percentage point in all rates

The plan starts 90.9% funded: 1,000 ÷ 1,100, a deficit of $100m.

Step 1: the liabilities when the rate falls to 4.0%

Liabilities = 1,100 × (1.05 ÷ 1.04)12 = 1,100 × 1.1217 = $1,233.9m, an increase of $133.9m or 12.2%

Excel: =1100*(1.05/1.04)^12

Step 2: the assets

Bonds = 350 × (1.05 ÷ 1.04)10 = 350 × 1.1004 = $385.1m, a gain of $35.1m

Total assets = 550 + 385.1 + 100 = $1,035.1m, a gain of 3.5%

Step 3: the funded status

Funded ratio = 1,035.1 ÷ 1,233.9 = 83.9%, against 90.9% before

Deficit = 1,233.9 − 1,035.1 = $198.7m, up from $100.0m

A 1-point fall in rates raises the liabilities by $133.9m and the assets by only $35.1m. The deficit grows by $98.7m, 99% more, and the funded ratio falls 7.0 points. The hedge ratio is 26.5%: the bonds carry $3,333m of dollar duration against $12,571m for the liabilities.

What if: more of the plan is in bonds

Funded ratio after a 1-point move in rates
Bonds, equities, cash, $mHedge ratioRates −1 pointNo changeRates +1 point
350 / 550 / 10026.5%83.9%90.9%98.6%
450 / 450 / 10034.1%84.7%90.9%97.7%
550 / 350 / 10041.7%85.5%90.9%96.8%

Moving $200m from equities into bonds lifts the hedge ratio from 26.5% to 41.7% and holds the funded ratio at 85.5% after a fall in rates, against 83.9%. The plan gives up the equity return that would close the $100m deficit; the model ignores that return and the effect of rates on equities.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What happens to a pension plan when the discount rate falls?

The liabilities rise faster than the assets. Here a 1-point fall adds $133.9m to liabilities and $35.1m to assets, so the funded ratio drops from 90.9% to 83.9%.

What is the hedge ratio of a pension plan?

The assets’ dollar duration divided by the liabilities’. With $350m of 10-year bonds against $1,100m of duration-12 liabilities it is 26.5%.

How do you protect funded status from falling rates?

Hold more long bonds or use swaps. Moving $200m from equities to bonds lifts the hedge ratio to 41.7% and keeps the plan at 85.5% funded after the same fall.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Asset Owner Investment Officer rebuild a fictional US public pension plan, its capital market assumptions, policy portfolios and asset-liability Monte Carlo with live formulas. The figures in this article use invented inputs and are not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Paperback on this topic

The Pension Risk Transfer Professional
170 pages, printed on demand and shipped worldwide, direct from the author: $32.99 paperback, $19.99 PDF. Not sold on Amazon. See the book →

The bookshop
151 handbooks and exam guides by Julian R. Sterling that are not on Amazon, sorted by subject. 15% off from 2 books. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: private equity and private markets → · All 1908 articles →