Liabilities are priced off the discount rate and assets mostly are not. The gap between their durations, not the market return, moves the funded status.
A plan with $1,000m of assets and $1,100m of liabilities of duration 12 is 90.9% funded. A one-point fall in the discount rate raises the liabilities by 12.2% and the assets by only 3.5%, taking the funded ratio to 83.9% and the deficit from $100m to $199m.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Assets | $1,000m: $550m equities, $350m bonds, $100m cash |
| Liabilities | $1,100m at a 5.0% discount rate, modelled as a single payment in year 12, a duration of 12 |
| Bonds | Zero-coupon bonds maturing in 10 years, on the same curve as the liabilities |
| Equities and cash | Do not move with the discount rate in this model |
| Rate shock | Parallel move of 1 percentage point in all rates |
The plan starts 90.9% funded: 1,000 ÷ 1,100, a deficit of $100m.
Liabilities = 1,100 × (1.05 ÷ 1.04)12 = 1,100 × 1.1217 = $1,233.9m, an increase of $133.9m or 12.2%
Excel: =1100*(1.05/1.04)^12
Bonds = 350 × (1.05 ÷ 1.04)10 = 350 × 1.1004 = $385.1m, a gain of $35.1m
Total assets = 550 + 385.1 + 100 = $1,035.1m, a gain of 3.5%
Funded ratio = 1,035.1 ÷ 1,233.9 = 83.9%, against 90.9% before
Deficit = 1,233.9 − 1,035.1 = $198.7m, up from $100.0m
A 1-point fall in rates raises the liabilities by $133.9m and the assets by only $35.1m. The deficit grows by $98.7m, 99% more, and the funded ratio falls 7.0 points. The hedge ratio is 26.5%: the bonds carry $3,333m of dollar duration against $12,571m for the liabilities.
| Bonds, equities, cash, $m | Hedge ratio | Rates −1 point | No change | Rates +1 point |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 350 / 550 / 100 | 26.5% | 83.9% | 90.9% | 98.6% |
| 450 / 450 / 100 | 34.1% | 84.7% | 90.9% | 97.7% |
| 550 / 350 / 100 | 41.7% | 85.5% | 90.9% | 96.8% |
Moving $200m from equities into bonds lifts the hedge ratio from 26.5% to 41.7% and holds the funded ratio at 85.5% after a fall in rates, against 83.9%. The plan gives up the equity return that would close the $100m deficit; the model ignores that return and the effect of rates on equities.
The liabilities rise faster than the assets. Here a 1-point fall adds $133.9m to liabilities and $35.1m to assets, so the funded ratio drops from 90.9% to 83.9%.
The assets’ dollar duration divided by the liabilities’. With $350m of 10-year bonds against $1,100m of duration-12 liabilities it is 26.5%.
Hold more long bonds or use swaps. Moving $200m from equities to bonds lifts the hedge ratio to 41.7% and keeps the plan at 85.5% funded after the same fall.
The free companion files for The Asset Owner Investment Officer rebuild a fictional US public pension plan, its capital market assumptions, policy portfolios and asset-liability Monte Carlo with live formulas. The figures in this article use invented inputs and are not in them. No account and no email address.
The Pension Risk Transfer Professional
170 pages, printed on demand and shipped worldwide, direct from the author: $32.99 paperback, $19.99 PDF. Not sold on Amazon. See the book →
The bookshop
151 handbooks and exam guides by Julian R. Sterling that are not on Amazon, sorted by subject. 15% off from 2 books. Browse the bookshop →
Reading guide: private equity and private markets → · All 1908 articles →