Articles

Is the lowest net interest cost bid the cheapest for a municipal issuer?

Net interest cost adds up the dollars and ignores when they are paid. True interest cost discounts them. When bids differ in coupons and premium, the two measures can rank them in opposite order.

Two bids for $10.0 million of five-year serial bonds: Bid X, 3.00% coupons at par less a $90,000 discount, has the lower net interest cost, 3.30% against 3.37%. Bid Y, 3.50% and 5.00% coupons with a $400,000 premium, has the lower true interest cost, 3.27% against 3.32%. Bid Y hands the issuer $400,000 more on closing day and charges for it in later, mostly longer-dated, interest. Discounting at 3.30%, Y costs the issuer $13,891 less in present value.

The assumptions

Illustrative general obligation serial issue, annual coupons for hand arithmetic
ItemBid XBid Y
Par amount, $2,000,000 maturing each year for 5 years$10,000,000$10,000,000
Coupons, maturities 1 to 33.00%3.50%
Coupons, maturities 4 and 53.00%5.00%
Reoffering premium$0$400,000
Underwriter’s discount$90,000$90,000
Net proceeds to the issuer$9,910,000$10,310,000

Real issues pay semiannually and TIC is then the semiannual rate doubled. Annual periods keep the arithmetic checkable by hand and do not change the ranking logic.

Step 1: net interest cost

NIC = (total coupon interest − net premium) ÷ bond-years

Bond-years = Σ par × years to maturity = 2.0 × (1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5) = 30.0 million

Bid X pays 2.0 million × 3.00% × 15 = $900,000 of interest, less a net premium of −$90,000 (a discount). NIC = (900,000 + 90,000) ÷ 30,000,000 = 3.30%. Bid Y pays 2.0 million × (3.50% × 6 + 5.00% × 9) = $1,320,000, less a net premium of $310,000: NIC = (1,320,000 − 310,000) ÷ 30,000,000 = 3.37%. By NIC, X is cheaper by 6.7 basis points.

Step 2: true interest cost

TIC is the discount rate at which the present value of all debt service equals the net proceeds, the issuer’s internal rate of return on borrowing. The debt service is principal plus interest on the bonds still outstanding.

Annual debt service, $
YearBid XBid Y
12,300,0002,410,000
22,240,0002,340,000
32,180,0002,270,000
42,120,0002,200,000
52,060,0002,100,000
Total10,900,00011,320,000

Solve for TIC: net proceeds = Σ debt servicet ÷ (1 + TIC)t

Excel: =IRR(range), with net proceeds positive in year 0 and debt service negative

Bid X: $9,910,000 received against $10,900,000 repaid gives 3.32%. Bid Y: $10,310,000 against $11,320,000 gives 3.27%. Discounting Bid Y’s debt service at 3.2742% brings the net present value to zero, which confirms the root. By TIC, Y is cheaper by 4.9 basis points: the ranking has reversed.

Why the two measures disagree

NIC treats a dollar of premium received today and a dollar of interest paid in year 5 as equal. TIC does not. Bid Y’s premium arrives at closing, while the extra interest it costs falls due over five years, with the heaviest 5.00% coupons on the longest bonds. Over the five years Y pays $420,000 more than X, but receives $400,000 more now. The flows of Y less X are +$400,000 at closing, then −$110,000, −$100,000, −$90,000, −$80,000 and −$40,000: a loan from the bidder at an implied rate of 1.89%. If the issuer’s own discount rate, for example the yield on its construction fund, is above 1.89%, Y is cheaper; below it, X is.

What if: the issuer values cash at 3.30%

At a 3.30% discount rate the present value of debt service less net proceeds is +$6,498 for Bid X and −$7,392 for Bid Y, a gain, so Y is cheaper by $13,891. NIC would have awarded the bonds to the bid that costs $13,891 more in present value.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What is the difference between net interest cost and true interest cost?

NIC is total coupon interest less net premium, divided by bond-years, and treats all dollars as equal in time. TIC is the discount rate at which the present value of all debt service equals the net proceeds, so it accounts for when each dollar is paid.

Can the lowest NIC bid have a higher TIC?

Yes. On a $10.0 million five-year serial issue, a 3.00% par bid has an NIC of 3.30% and a TIC of 3.32%, while a bid with a $400,000 premium and higher coupons has an NIC of 3.37% but a TIC of 3.27%.

How do you calculate TIC in Excel?

List the net proceeds as a positive number in year 0 and each year's debt service as a negative number, then apply IRR to the range. For semiannual coupons, double the semiannual IRR.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Municipal Bond Analyst rebuild a fictional city, its water and sewer utility and its general obligation issue, with the pricing of twenty maturities, true interest cost and tax-equivalent yield. The two five-maturity bids in this article are invented and are not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 36 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on how to read the documents, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: credit, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →