Articles

How much does a cash-funded debt service reserve cost a municipal issuer?

A reserve fund protects bondholders and costs the issuer the gap between what it borrows at and what the fund earns. That gap can be priced before choosing between cash and a surety.

A municipality that needs $50.0 million of project funds and issues 4.00% bonds over 30 years must borrow $53.64 million to also fund a $3.10 million debt service reserve, at 1% issuance cost. With the reserve invested at 2.50%, the reserve costs the issuer $0.84 million in present value, 1.67% of the project funds. A surety policy at 2.50% of its limit covers the same requirement for $0.07 million.

Bondholders in many municipal revenue issues are protected by a reserve fund holding about a year of debt service. It is funded on day one, usually out of the bond proceeds, and released when the bonds mature. The issuer does not lose the money, but it pays interest on it for thirty years while the fund earns less than the bonds cost. That gap is the price of the protection.

The assumptions

One illustrative revenue bond issue
ItemValue
Project funds needed$50.0 million
Bond yield and coupon4.00%
Term, level annual debt service30 years
Cost of issuance, as % of par1.0%
Reserve invested at2.50%
Surety premium, as % of the limit2.50%

Step 1: the debt service factor

Annual debt service per $1 of par = y / (1 − (1 + y)−n)

Excel: =-PMT(y, n, 1)

At 4.00% over 30 years the factor is 0.05783, so every dollar of par costs 5.783 cents a year. With level debt service the maximum annual debt service is the same as the average.

Step 2: the issue with and without the reserve

Without a reserve, the par is whatever leaves $50.0 million after the 1% cost: 50.0 / 0.99 = $50.505 million. With a reserve equal to maximum annual debt service, it is a share 0.05783 of par, so par must satisfy P × (1 − 0.01 − 0.05783) = 50.0.

Par with reserve = project funds / (1 − issuance cost − debt service factor)

P = 50.0 / 0.93217 = $53.638 million. The reserve is 53.638 × 0.05783 = $3.102 million, 5.78% of par. The test against the other two limits is met: 10% of par is $5.36 million and 125% of average debt service is $3.88 million, both above the requirement.

Step 3: what the reserve costs

The issuer borrows $3.133 million more than without a reserve. Of that, $3.102 million sits in the reserve, earning 2.50% and returning at maturity; the rest pays issuance cost. Present values are at the 4.00% bond yield, with a 30-year annuity factor of 17.2920.

Net PV cost = extra par − reserve × earnings rate × annuity factor − reserve / (1 + y)n

3.133 − 3.102 × 2.50% × 17.2920 − 3.102 / 1.0430 = 3.133 − 1.341 − 0.956 = $0.836 million.

Step 4: the surety alternative

A surety replaces the reserve with a promise to pay. The issuer pays its premium, 2.50% of the limit, out of proceeds, and borrows no reserve. Par must satisfy P × (1 − 0.01 − 2.50% × 0.05783) = 50.0, so P = $50.579 million, a premium of $73 thousand and an extra $74 thousand of par against the no-reserve case.

Cost of meeting a reserve requirement ($ million, present value)
StructureParNet PV costCost as % of project funds
No reserve50.5050.0000.00%
Surety at 2.50% of the limit50.5790.0740.15%
Cash reserve earning 2.50%53.6380.8361.67%

What if: the reserve earns more or less

The earnings rate decides the cost. At the bond yield of 4.00% the reserve costs nothing beyond issuance, $0.031 million. At 1.00% it costs $1.640 million, which is 3.28% of project funds. Each point of earnings is worth $0.536 million: $3.102 million × 1.00% × 17.2920.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How big is a debt service reserve fund?

Commonly the lesser of three amounts: maximum annual debt service, 10% of par and 125% of average annual debt service. Here those are $3.10 million, $5.36 million and $3.88 million, so the requirement is $3.10 million.

Why does a reserve cost the issuer anything if it is returned?

Because the issuer pays 4.00% on the bonds that fund it and the reserve earns less, 2.50% here. The shortfall is $47 thousand a year for 30 years, plus 1% issuance cost on the extra par.

When does a surety beat a cash reserve?

When its premium is below the PV of the negative carry. At 2.50% of the limit the premium is $73 thousand, against $836 thousand for the cash reserve; at a 4.00% earnings rate cash costs only $31 thousand and the surety no longer wins.

The workbooks behind this article

The workbooks for this book follow municipal credit analysis through coverage, security and pricing. The reserve fund arithmetic in this article is a separate illustration and is not in them.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 36 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on how to read the documents, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: credit, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →