Articles

Is a higher bid with regulatory risk worth more than a certain lower bid?

The seller does not receive the headline price. It receives a probability-weighted price, later, with a fallback if the deal fails. Put every bid on that basis.

A seller has two bids for an infrastructure platform. Bid A is $520m, needs a regulatory approval that has a 75% chance and closes in 12 months. Bid B is $495m, is 95% likely and closes in 3 months. At the seller's 8% discount rate, A is worth $466.4m and B $483.1m. B is worth $16.7m more despite a $25m lower price.

The assumptions

Illustrative sale process, invented figures, $m
ItemBid ABid B
Headline price520495
Chance the approval is granted75%95%
Months to completion123
Reverse break fee if refused155
Value of the platform if the sale fails440440
Seller's discount rate8%8%

If the approval is refused, the seller keeps the platform, worth $440m at that date, and collects the break fee. The platform's cash flows during the wait go to the seller under either bid, so they are left out.

Step 1: the expected value at completion

Expected value = chance × price + (1 − chance) × (fallback value + break fee)

Bid A = 0.75 × 520 + 0.25 × (440 + 15) = 390.00 + 113.75 = $503.75m

Bid B = 0.95 × 495 + 0.05 × (440 + 5) = 470.25 + 22.25 = $492.50m

Step 2: discount to today

Bid A = 503.75 ÷ 1.0812/12 = $466.4m

Bid B = 492.50 ÷ 1.083/12 = $483.1m

Excel: =(0.95*495+0.05*(440+5))/(1+8%)^(3/12)

What each bid is worth today, $m
MeasureBid ABid B
Headline price520.0495.0
Expected value at completion503.8492.5
Present value today466.4483.1
Present value if completion were certain481.5485.6

Even if A were certain to be approved it would be worth $481.5m, below B's $483.1m, because a year of waiting costs 8% of the price. That is the point of the lower bid winning: A needs a higher price, not only a better chance.

Step 3: the price that would make A equal

Price A such that 0.75 × price + 0.25 × 455 = 483.1 × 1.08

Price A = (521.8 − 113.75) ÷ 0.75 = $544.0m, 24.0 above the actual bid

What if: better odds, a lower discount rate

Present value of each bid, $m
CaseBid ABid BHigher
Base case466.4483.1Bid B
Bid A approval chance 90%475.5483.1Bid B
Discount rate 4%484.4487.7Bid B
Bid B chance 85%466.4478.2Bid B
Bid A chance 90% and discount rate 4%493.8487.7Bid A

One change is not enough to reverse the ranking, but two together are. At a 4% discount rate bid A needs a 80.3% chance of approval to match bid B, and at 8% it can never match it because even a certain approval leaves it behind.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How do you compare a high bid with regulatory risk to a lower certain bid?

Weight each price by its chance of completing, add the fallback value and break fee for the failure case, and discount over the time to completion. Here that gives $466.4m and $483.1m.

Why can a lower bid be worth more?

A year's wait at 8% costs about 7.4% of the price, and the 25% chance of refusal costs a further $16.3m in expected value. Bid B, at $495m, is worth $16.7m more.

What price would make the slower bid equal?

$544.0m in this example, or $24.0m above the actual bid, at a 75% chance of approval.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Infrastructure M&A Handbook rebuild the sale of a fictional tank storage platform, with two binding bids, regulatory delay cases, equity bridge and exit in live formulas. The two bids in this article are invented and are not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on markets, funds and compliance, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: infrastructure, data centres and energy → · All 1908 articles →