Articles

How many bidders should a property sale process invite?

Every extra bidder raises the expected price, but by less than the one before. The right size for a process is where the next invitation stops paying for itself.

If buyers value a building uniformly between $92.0m and $108.0m, the expected best bid is $100.00m with one bidder, $104.00m with three and $106.40m with nine. Each extra bidder adds 16.0 ÷ (N × (N + 1)), so at $0.15m of cost per bidder the optimum is 9 bidders.

The assumptions

Illustrative sale process, invented figures
ItemValue
PropertyA stabilised office building
Each buyer's valueUniform between $92.0m and $108.0m, independent of the others
BidsEach buyer bids its value
Cost to the seller of each extra bidder$0.15m of data-room, tour and management time
ReserveNone

The seller does not know any buyer's value, only the range. A property sale is a contest to find the buyer whose value is highest, so the price depends on the best of the draws.

Step 1: the expected best bid

For N bidders with values uniform between a low L and a high H, the expected highest value is L + (H − L) × N ÷ (N + 1)

N = 1: 92.0 + 16.0 × 1 ÷ 2 = $100.00m, the middle of the range

N = 3: 92.0 + 16.0 × 3 ÷ 4 = $104.00m

N = 9: 92.0 + 16.0 × 9 ÷ 10 = $106.40m

Excel: =92+16*N/(N+1)

Step 2: what each extra bidder adds

Gain from the Nth bidder = 16.0 ÷ (N × (N + 1))

2nd bidder: 16.0 ÷ 6 = $2.667m

5th bidder: 16.0 ÷ 30 = $0.533m

9th bidder: 16.0 ÷ 90 = $0.178m

10th bidder: 16.0 ÷ 110 = $0.145m

Expected price by number of bidders, $m
BiddersExpected highest bidGain from last bidderExpected second-highest bid
1100.00--
2102.672.66797.33
3104.001.333100.00
4104.800.800101.60
5105.330.533102.67
6105.710.381103.43
8106.220.222104.44
10106.550.145105.09
12106.770.103105.54

The first few bidders do most of the work. Going from one bidder to three adds $4.00m, and going from three to nine adds $2.40m. The second-highest bid is what an English auction with rising bids ends at, since the winner needs to beat only the next-best buyer; it is always lower than the highest bid by 16.0 × 1 ÷ (N + 1) in this setup.

Step 3: where to stop

Invite another bidder while its gain is at least its cost: 16.0 ÷ (N × (N + 1)) ≥ 0.15

N × (N + 1) ≤ 16.0 ÷ 0.15 = 106.7, so N = 9 (9 × 10 = 90, while 10 × 11 = 110)

The 9th bidder adds $0.178m for $0.150m, the 10th would add $0.145m

Net of costs, the expected price at 9 bidders is 106.40 − 9 × 0.15 = $105.05m

What if: the cost, or the range, is different

Optimal number of bidders by cost per bidder (range $92.0m to $108.0m)
Cost per bidderOptimal biddersExpected highest bid, $mGain from last, $mGain from next, $mExpected price net of costs, $m
$0.05m17107.110.0520.047106.26
$0.15m9106.400.1780.145105.05
$0.30m6105.710.3810.286103.91

A narrower range lowers the value of competition. With values between $94.0m and $106.0m, a spread of 12.0 instead of 16.0, the gain from the Nth bidder is 12.0 ÷ (N × (N + 1)), and at $0.15m a bidder the optimum is 8 bidders. The expected best bid with 3 bidders is $103.00m and with 8 it is $104.67m.

The model has no reserve, no collusion and no bidders who walk away. Real processes also lose bidders who drop out at best-and-final, so the number invited is usually larger than the number the model prefers.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How many bidders should a property sale process invite?

Enough that the next bidder adds less than it costs. With values from $92.0m to $108.0m and $0.15m of cost per bidder, that is 9.

Why does each extra bidder add less?

Because the expected highest of N values rises at a falling rate. The 2nd bidder adds $2.667m and the 9th adds $0.178m.

Does the answer change in an auction where the winner pays the second-highest bid?

The price is lower, $104.80m at 9 bidders against $106.40m, but each added bidder is still worth less than the one before, so the logic for stopping is the same.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Real Estate Capital Markets Advisor rebuild a fictional apartment refinancing, a joint venture equity raise and an industrial sale with live formulas, plus an editable toolkit. The sale process in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 10 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on tax and incentives, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: real estate investing, finance and fund management → · All 1908 articles →