Articles

Is a cash balance plan worth it for a small practice?

It usually is for owners in their fifties with steady income and a small staff, provided they count the staff cost, share the cost fairly between owners, and plan for bad years before they sign.

In the worked case, adding a cash balance plan to a 401(k) costs the practice $403,040 a year more and saves $169,277 of tax at a 42 percent rate. The older owner gives up $171,102 of take-home pay and puts $274,100 more into her accounts: 1.60 dollars of retirement money per dollar given up.

The cost, all in

Two-dentist practice, income before owners' pay $1,900,000; full year; teaching assumptions.
Item401(k) aloneWith cash balance
Employer cost a year$134,500$537,540
Owners' share of employer contributions72.0 percent87.3 percent
Staff employer rate5.0 percent9.1 percent (budget 10.9 percent)
Share of the practice's income7.1 percent28.3 percent

The staff rate comes from the nondiscrimination test. In the example a simplified screen passes at 9.1 percent by a hair; the departure of one young employee, or a stricter reading of the gateway, would need about 10.9 percent, $13,320 a year more. Budget for the higher figure until the actuary has spoken.

Who pays for whose credit

Contributions come out of profits before they are split. With profits shared 60/40, the older owner receives 69.4 percent of the owners' contributions, so her partner would fund $43,680 a year of her retirement. A salary differential of $72,800 to the younger owner moves it back, at a Medicare cost of about $2,766; in an S corporation, special allocations are not available, and the arrangement needs counsel.

Worked in full in The Cash Balance Plan Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the cash balance plan calculator in Excel: the cost against a 401(k) alone, the tax saved, who pays for whose credit and the 415 ceiling tested each year, with its checks.

Deferral, not exemption

$100,000 put through the plan for six years at 5 percent and withdrawn at 37 percent leaves $84,426; taken as pay at 42 percent and invested in a fully taxed account it leaves $68,853; at long-term rates on the growth, $71,545. The edge is real, $12,881 to $15,573 per $100,000, and it vanishes only at a withdrawal rate of 48.6 percent.

What can go wrong

Sources

  1. IRS Notice 2021-48, funding relief under the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 (15-year amortization)
  2. IRS, Combined limits under IRC Section 404(a)(7)

Figures checked on 18 November 2026. The practice in the examples is fictional and its figures are teaching assumptions, not market norms, quotes or rules of law. Not legal, tax, actuarial or investment advice.

Questions readers ask

Who is a cash balance plan good for?

Profitable businesses with steady income, owners old enough to need large credits, and a staff whose cost is proportionate. It suits less well a business that may close within a few years or owners who want cash now.

How much does a cash balance plan cost to run?

In the example, about $4,500 a year of actuarial and administration fees and $3,000 to set up, beside the 401(k) fees; the staff contributions are the larger cost.

Can a cash balance plan be stopped?

It can be frozen or terminated, but a plan must be intended as permanent, and ending it within a few years without a business reason can put its tax treatment at risk.

Read the whole book

This article is one step from The Cash Balance Plan Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to cash balance plans for business owners, medical and professional practices: design, testing, funding and tax, how much you can put away, what your staff will cost and what can go wrong, worked through one practice.

Also on this site