Articles

Cash balance plan beside a 401(k): why the 6 percent rule matters

When a practice sponsors both plans, Section 404(a)(7) caps the combined deduction. Plans insured by the PBGC escape it; small professional practices, exempt from the PBGC, do not, and must keep employer 401(k) contributions within 6 percent of pay.

In the worked case, keeping the owners' $47,500 profit sharing beside the new plan would push employer 401(k) contributions to 9.04 percent of pay and make $44,400 nondeductible. Cutting the owners to 6 percent, $21,600 each, brings the total to 5.49 percent and the problem disappears.

The combined limit

When an employer sponsors a defined benefit plan and a defined contribution plan with at least one common participant, the deduction for both is capped at the greater of 25 percent of the participants' compensation and the defined benefit plan's minimum required contribution. Elective deferrals do not count, and employer contributions to the defined contribution plan up to 6 percent of pay are disregarded: that is where the familiar 31 percent comes from.

The exemption that creates the trap: the combined limit does not apply to a plan insured by the PBGC. A professional service employer that has never had more than 25 active participants is exempt from PBGC coverage, so its plan is inside the combined limit.

The example, two ways

Two-dentist practice, 14 participants, 401(k) pay $1,460,000; teaching assumptions.
ItemOld profit sharing kept6 percent design
Employer 401(k) contributions, percent of pay9.04 percent5.49 percent
25 percent of participants' pay$365,000not applicable
Cash balance credits (minimum)$450,340$450,340
Nondeductible$44,400$0

With the old profit sharing, the combined limit would be the greater of $365,000 and the plan's minimum of $450,340: the credits alone use it up, every dollar of 401(k) money above 6 percent becomes nondeductible, and the cushion that lets a defined benefit plan fund ahead is lost. A 10 percent excise applies to nondeductible contributions, unless the employer makes the election of Section 4972(c)(7), a point for the accountant.

Worked in full in The Cash Balance Plan Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

Free: the cash balance plan calculator in Excel: the cost against a 401(k) alone, the tax saved, who pays for whose credit and the 415 ceiling tested each year, with its checks.

What the PBGC exemption saves, and costs

A covered plan pays a flat premium of $111 per participant in 2026 and $116 in 2027, plus a variable premium if underfunded: $1,554 for the example's 14 participants. The exemption saves that, and brings the combined limit with it. A practice that grows past 25 active participants changes regime.

Sources

  1. IRS, Combined limits under IRC Section 404(a)(7)
  2. PBGC, premium rates for 2026 and 2027

Figures checked on 18 November 2026. The practice in the examples is fictional and its figures are teaching assumptions, not market norms, quotes or rules of law. Not legal, tax, actuarial or investment advice.

Questions readers ask

What is the 31 percent limit for cash balance plans?

It is shorthand for the combined deduction limit: 25 percent of participants' pay, plus employer 401(k) contributions of up to 6 percent of pay, which are disregarded.

Does the combined limit apply to my plan?

Only if the defined benefit plan is not insured by the PBGC, typically a plan covering only owners or the plan of a professional service employer with 25 or fewer active participants. Your actuary should say which regime applies.

Can the staff still get more than 6 percent?

Yes, through the cash balance plan. The 6 percent is measured on all 401(k) participants together, so the design gives the owners less in the 401(k) and the staff part of their benefit in the cash balance plan.

Read the whole book

This article is one step from The Cash Balance Plan Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to cash balance plans for business owners, medical and professional practices: design, testing, funding and tax, how much you can put away, what your staff will cost and what can go wrong, worked through one practice.

Also on this site