Technical accounting · IAS 12 & IFRS 2
How IAS 12.68A-68C remeasures share-based payment deferred tax assets to intrinsic value at every reporting date, splits excess tax benefits to equity, and diverges sharply from US GAAP ASU 2016-09.
In most jurisdictions, corporate tax deductions for share-based payments arise when options are exercised or RSUs are delivered, based on the share's intrinsic value on the settlement date rather than grant-date fair value. Under IAS 12 paragraphs 68A to 68C, this creates a continuously remeasured deferred tax asset with a strict allocation rule between profit or loss and equity.
At each reporting date, the entity estimates the future tax deduction attributable to employee services already rendered using the closing share price (IAS 12.68B). If that estimated tax deduction exceeds the cumulative IFRS 2 expense recognized for those unvested awards, IAS 12.68C caps the deferred tax benefit recognized in profit or loss at the statutory tax rate multiplied by the cumulative IFRS 2 expense. The entire excess is credited directly to equity. When the share price subsequently falls, equity deferred tax is reversed first before any shortfall hits profit or loss.
In Nordcrest Technologies SE Plan A (25% statutory tax rate, grant-date RSU fair value EUR 42.00), the year-end share price rises to EUR 54.00 in FY1 and EUR 62.00 in FY2 before dropping to EUR 36.00 in FY3 (creating a EUR 127,500 tax shortfall on Tranche 3 delivery):
| Period | Share Price | Closing DTA | IAS 12 P&L Tax | IAS 12 Equity Tax | ASC 718 P&L Tax |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY1 (2026) | EUR 54.00 | EUR 963,000 | EUR 1,746,500 | EUR 499,000 | EUR 1,282,500 |
| FY2 (2027) | EUR 62.00 | EUR 868,000 | EUR 773,500 | EUR 511,000 | EUR 1,379,500 |
| FY3 (2028) | EUR 36.00 | EUR 0 | EUR 177,000 | -EUR 280,000 | EUR 765,000 |
| 3-Year Total | - | EUR 0 | EUR 2,697,000 | EUR 730,000 | EUR 3,427,000 |
Under ASC 718 as amended by ASU 2016-09, deferred tax assets are not remeasured for share price movements during the vesting period; they remain anchored to cumulative US GAAP compensation cost. At settlement, 100% of every tax windfall (EUR 285,000 in FY1 and EUR 445,000 in FY2) and every tax shortfall (EUR 127,500 in FY3) flows directly through income tax expense in profit or loss, never through equity. Consequently, Nordcrest's three-year cumulative tax benefit of EUR 3,427,000 is split EUR 2,697,000 P&L / EUR 730,000 Equity under IFRS, versus 100% (EUR 3,427,000) in P&L under US GAAP.
The Deferred_Tax_IAS12 tab in the free IFRS 2 Share-Based Payment Calculator automates the P&L cap, equity excess, and falling-share-price reversal logic. Full journal entries appear in Chapters 11 and 13 of The IFRS 2 Share-Based Payment Handbook.