Technical accounting · IFRS 2

IFRS 2 Equity-Settled vs Cash-Settled Awards, Repricings, and Cancellations

How grant-date lock-in contrasts with cash-settled SAR mark-to-market volatility, how incremental fair value works on repricings (IFRS 2.27), and why cancellations accelerate expense (IFRS 2.28).

The single most consequential classification boundary in IFRS 2 is the distinction between equity-settled awards (measured once at grant-date fair value and never remeasured for subsequent share-price movements) and cash-settled awards such as Share Appreciation Rights (remeasured to fair value through profit or loss at every reporting date until final cash settlement).

1. Cash-settled SARs: full P&L volatility through settlement (IFRS 2.30-33D)

In Nordcrest Technologies SE Plan C, 150,000 SARs with a EUR 45.00 strike vest at the end of FY2 and are exercised in Q1 FY3 (52,000 units at EUR 19.50 intrinsic value, cash EUR 1,014,000) and at FY4 expiration (80,000 units at EUR 3.00 intrinsic value, cash EUR 240,000). Because the liability is remeasured via Black-Scholes-Merton at each year-end (EUR 1,134,000 in FY1, EUR 2,725,800 in FY2, EUR 216,000 in FY3 after the share price drops to EUR 36.00, and EUR 0 in FY4), annual P&L expense swings from EUR 1,134,000 in FY1 and EUR 1,591,800 in FY2 to a net P&L credit of -EUR 1,495,800 in FY3 and EUR 24,000 in FY4. Over the four-year lifecycle, cumulative P&L expense (EUR 1,254,000) equals cumulative cash paid (EUR 1,254,000) to the exact euro.

2. Option repricing: incremental fair value under IFRS 2.27 and B43

When share prices fall below an option's strike price, boards frequently reprice underwater options. Under IFRS 2.27, the entity cannot replace the original grant-date fair value. Instead, it continues recognizing the original grant-date cost and adds the incremental fair value measured on the modification date (post-modification FV minus pre-modification FV). In Nordcrest Plan D1 (108,000 active options originally granted at EUR 68.00 strike and EUR 9.19 FV), repricing the strike to EUR 54.00 at the start of FY2 lifts option fair value from EUR 11.99 to EUR 16.00, creating EUR 4.01 of incremental fair value per option (EUR 433,080 total, amortized at EUR 216,540 per year across FY2 and FY3 on top of the EUR 330,840 annual original cost).

3. Early cancellation with cash buyout above fair value (IFRS 2.28)

Cancelling an equity-settled award never reverses previously recognized expense. Under IFRS 2.28(a), all unrecognized original grant-date expense accelerates immediately into profit or loss. Under IFRS 2.28(b), any cash buyout is deducted from equity only up to the cancel-date fair value of the cancelled awards; any premium paid above fair value is expensed immediately in P&L. In Nordcrest Plan D2 (72,000 active options cancelled at the start of FY3 with a EUR 15.63 cash buyout versus EUR 14.13 cancel-date fair value), Nordcrest records EUR 220,560 of accelerated original expense, EUR 1,017,360 as a debit to equity, and EUR 108,000 of excess buyout premium directly to P&L (total FY3 P&L charge: EUR 328,560).

Model SARs, repricings, and cancellations in Excel

Test your own repricing terms, buyout premiums, and SAR fair values in the free IFRS 2 Share-Based Payment Calculator, or see Chapters 6 to 8 of The IFRS 2 Share-Based Payment Handbook.

Related reading