The letter is built from your own Forms 1095-C. The response, built from your own records, decides what remains.
To respond to Letter 226-J, return Form 14764 by the date in the letter and show any changes on Form 14765, the Employee PTC Listing, with the indicator codes of the Form 1095-C instructions and the records behind them. Removing one part-time employee listed for 8 months brings a proposed (b) payment of $14,500.00 down to $11,600.00.
Worked in full in The ACA Employer Mandate Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
Free: the ACA employer mandate penalty calculator in Excel: the 95 percent offer test month by month, the (a) and (b) payments with the cap, the amounts for 2025 to 2027 and the three affordability safe harbor ceilings, with live formulas.
Letter 226-J is the IRS's proposal of a section 4980H payment. It is built from two sources: the employer's own Forms 1094-C and 1095-C, and the returns of employees who received a premium tax credit. It comes with a summary table of the proposed payment by month, Form 14764 (the ESRP response, on which the employer agrees or disagrees) and Form 14765, the Employee PTC Listing, which names each full-time employee and month behind a (b) amount, with the line 14 and line 16 codes as filed.
The response date is printed in the letter. Section 4980H(d)(4), added in December 2024, requires the IRS to allow at least 90 days from the first letter for proposals in taxable years beginning after December 23, 2024, while the IRS questions and answers still described the response as generally due 30 days after the letter when this was written. Follow the date in the letter and ask counsel if it gives fewer than 90 days.
A letter proposes a (b) payment for 2025 on 5 employees, each listed for 8 months. One of them was part-time in every listed month, but line 16 of her Form 1095-C was left blank instead of showing code 2B, so the IRS had no way to know.
| Step | Employee-months | (b) amount for 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Proposed | 5 × 8 | $14,500.00 |
| After the response removes the part-time employee | 5 × 8 − 8 | $11,600.00 |
The response marks code 2B for her months on Form 14765, as the letter's instructions ask, rather than through a corrected return, and attaches her payroll hours by month. It does not contest the other four employees if the file cannot show a safe harbor or an offer that would remove them: contesting months the file cannot defend costs credibility on the months it can.
The trap: filing corrected Forms 1095-C to answer the letter. The changes the employer wants on the Employee PTC Listing go on Form 14765 with the indicator codes of the instructions. Whether to correct the filed forms separately is a different question, for the CPA.
The IRS answers with an acknowledgement letter, Letter 227, in one of several versions: it may accept the changes, reduce the amount or keep it. An employer that still disagrees may ask for a conference with the IRS Independent Office of Appeals by the date in that letter. The period to assess a section 4980H payment is now six years from the later of the due date and the filing date of the employer's return for the year (section 6501(n), for returns due after 2024), so the hours, offers and safe harbor computations behind each Form 1095-C have to outlast the people who prepared them. The penalty calculation article shows how the amounts are built, and the safe harbor article what a line 16 code needs behind it.
Figures checked on 21 November 2026. Rules as read in November 2026. Illustrative examples, not tax, legal or benefits advice: a CPA and ERISA counsel confirm how the rules apply to a real employer. The employers and employees in the examples are fictional.
The IRS letter that proposes an employer shared responsibility payment under section 4980H, with a summary table, Form 14764 for the response and Form 14765, the Employee PTC Listing.
Until the response date printed in the letter. Section 4980H(d)(4) requires at least 90 days from the first letter for proposals in taxable years beginning after December 23, 2024; ask counsel if the letter gives fewer.
No. The letter's instructions ask for the changes to be shown on Form 14765 with the indicator codes, not through corrected returns. Whether to correct the filed forms separately is a question for the CPA.
The IRS replies with Letter 227. An employer that still disagrees can request a pre-assessment conference with the IRS Independent Office of Appeals by the date in that letter.
This article is one calculation from The ACA Employer Mandate Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to section 4980H and Forms 1094-C and 1095-C: applicable large employer status and controlled groups, full-time employees and the look-back method, the 95 percent offer, affordability safe harbors, the (a) and (b) payments, Letter 226-J and the 2024 reporting changes.
DRM-free PDF, $19.99 · Paperback, $32.99, shipped worldwide · Free Excel calculator