Articles

How do you allocate the transaction price under ASC 606?

In proportion to each performance obligation's standalone selling price (SSP): the bundle discount is shared by all of them unless strict conditions are met.

Under ASC 606, the transaction price is allocated to each performance obligation in proportion to its standalone selling price. A $310,000 bundle whose parts would sell separately for $337,000 carries an 8.0% discount, shared proportionately: $95,667.66 to the sensors, $32,195.85 to installation and $182,136.49 to a three-year subscription, before $3,600 of expected credits that belong to the subscription alone.

Worked in full in The Revenue Recognition Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback

The rule in one sentence

Each performance obligation receives the transaction price multiplied by its standalone selling price and divided by the sum of the standalone selling prices of all the obligations in the contract (ASC 606-10-32-28 to 32-31). The SSP is the price at which the company would sell that good or service separately.

Step 1: find the standalone selling prices

The case is a fictional sensor maker, Halverton Systems, and a contract with Corvane Foods: 400 sensors at $250, installation at $30,000 and a monitoring subscription at $60,000 a year for three years, $310,000 in all. The SSP of each item comes from the best evidence available:

Standalone selling prices
ObligationMethodSSP
400 sensorsObservable: median standalone price $260104,000
InstallationExpected cost $25,000 plus 40% margin35,000
Subscription, 3 yearsObservable renewal price $66,000 a year198,000
Total337,000

Observable prices come first. When there are none, ASC 606-10-32-34 allows an adjusted market assessment, expected cost plus a margin, or, only for items with highly variable or uncertain prices, the residual approach.

Step 2: allocate the fixed price

Sensors = 310,000 x 104,000 / 337,000 = 95,667.66

Installation = 310,000 x 35,000 / 337,000 = 32,195.85

Subscription = 310,000 - 95,667.66 - 32,195.85 = 182,136.49

The last obligation takes the balance so that the three amounts add exactly to the price. The $27,000 discount (8.0% of the SSP total) is spread across all three in proportion to their SSPs, which is the default rule.

Step 3: allocate variable consideration where it belongs

The contract gives Corvane service credits if platform uptime falls short, capped at $6,000 a year. Expected credits are $1,200 a year, $3,600 over three years. Because the credits depend only on the subscription, ASC 606-10-32-40 requires them to be allocated entirely to it. The subscription total becomes $182,136.49 - $3,600 = $178,536.49, or $4,959.35 a month over 36 months, not the $5,000 a month that the annual invoice suggests.

Why not the residual approach?

Subtracting the sensor and installation SSPs from the price would leave the subscription $171,000, loading the whole discount onto it. The residual approach is allowed only when an item's SSP is highly variable or uncertain. A subscription with observable renewal prices is neither.

When the discount can be aimed at one item

Only when all three conditions of ASC 606-10-32-37 are met: each item is regularly sold on its own, a bundle of some of them is regularly sold at a discount, and that discount matches the one in the contract with observable evidence. Without that evidence, the discount stays proportional.

The trap: allocating on the invoice lines. Order lines are priced by sales; the allocation follows standalone selling prices. Here the sensors were invoiced at $100,000 but carry $95,667.66 of revenue.

Takeaway

Free Excel template: ASC 606 Revenue Workbook (SSP allocation, variable consideration, revenue schedule and contract balances).

Also on this site: expected value or most likely amount · contract asset or contract liability.

Questions readers ask

What is a standalone selling price under ASC 606?

The price at which the entity would sell a promised good or service separately to a customer. The best evidence is the observable price of separate sales; otherwise it is estimated by an adjusted market assessment, expected cost plus a margin or, in limited cases, the residual approach.

Can a discount be allocated to only one performance obligation?

Only if the entity regularly sells each item on its own, regularly sells a bundle of some of them at a discount, and that discount is substantially the same as the one in the contract, with observable evidence. Otherwise the discount is allocated proportionately.

Is the price reallocated if standalone selling prices change later?

No. The allocation is set at contract inception. Later changes in the transaction price are allocated on the same basis as at inception, but changes in standalone selling prices are not.

Sources: FASB Accounting Standards Codification, Topic 606 (paragraphs cited in the text) and Subtopic 340-40. Figures computed by the author's model and checked on 17 November 2026. Education only, not accounting advice.

Read the whole case

This article is one calculation from The Revenue Recognition Handbook. The book follows one company's revenue through a year, from the first contract review to the year-end disclosures, and every figure it prints is a live formula in the free workbook.

Get the PDF edition, $19.99 Paperback · Free companion files