Use the expected value for a range of outcomes or many similar contracts; use the most likely amount for a binary outcome. Then apply the constraint.
ASC 606 allows two methods to estimate variable consideration. The expected value (probability-weighted sum) suits a range of outcomes: service credits of $0, $3,000 or $6,000 a year at 70%, 20% and 10% give $1,200 a year. The most likely amount suits a binary outcome: a 5% rebate on $330,000 that is 80% likely is estimated at $16,500, not $13,200.
Worked in full in The Revenue Recognition Handbook by Julian R. Sterling, with every figure reproduced in a free workbook.Get the PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
ASC 606-10-32-8 lets the entity choose, for each type of uncertainty, the method that better predicts the amount it will be entitled to, and apply it consistently throughout the contract:
A fictional sensor company, Halverton Systems, sells a three-year monitoring subscription to Corvane Foods with uptime credits capped at $6,000 a year. From three years of history across about 600 contracts:
| Credit | Probability | Weighted |
|---|---|---|
| $0 | 70% | 0 |
| $3,000 | 20% | 600 |
| $6,000 | 10% | 600 |
| Expected credit | 1,200 |
Expected credits = 1,200 x 3 years = 3,600
Transaction price = 310,000 - 3,600 = 306,400
The most likely amount would be zero, ignoring a 30% chance of paying something. With several outcomes and a large population of similar contracts, the expected value predicts better.
A distributor, Brightline Industrial Supply, buys sensors at $220 and earns a 5% rebate on every unit of the year if it buys more than 5,000 units. In the first quarter it bought 1,500 units, $330,000. At 31 March the chance of crossing the threshold is judged at 80%.
Most likely amount = 1,500 x 220 x 5% = 16,500
Expected value = 80% x 16,500 = 13,200, an amount that cannot occur
First-quarter revenue = 330,000 - 16,500 = 313,500 (209 a unit)
Brightline bought 1,300 units in the second quarter, recognized at $209: $271,700. By 30 September, with 3,900 units bought, the chance of the rebate fell to 25%. The most likely outcome is now no rebate, and the change is recognized in the period: the $30,800 accrued on 2,800 units is reversed into revenue. Because that release raises revenue, it passes the constraint test first: with the fourth-quarter order book far below the threshold, a reversal was judged improbable. Third-quarter revenue, before returns, is 1,100 x $220 + $30,800 = $272,800.
Variable consideration is included only to the extent that it is probable that a significant reversal of cumulative revenue recognized will not occur when the uncertainty is resolved (ASC 606-10-32-11). The constraint bites on amounts that would raise revenue, such as performance bonuses. Credits and rebates lower revenue: the risk there is under-estimating them, so both estimates are tested each quarter against actual outcomes.
The trap: picking the method that gives the nicer number. The method follows the type of uncertainty and stays the same for the life of the contract.
Free Excel template: ASC 606 Revenue Workbook (SSP allocation, variable consideration, revenue schedule and contract balances).
Also on this site: how to allocate the transaction price under ASC 606 · contract asset or contract liability.
When there are several possible outcomes or a large number of contracts with similar characteristics, such as service credits, returns or tiered discounts. It reflects the full range of outcomes.
When the outcome is binary: a bonus earned or not, a rebate threshold met or not. The expected value would give an amount that cannot actually occur.
No. The method is chosen for each type of uncertainty and applied consistently throughout the contract. The estimate itself is updated at each reporting date.
Sources: FASB Accounting Standards Codification, Topic 606 (paragraphs cited in the text) and Subtopic 340-40. Figures computed by the author's model and checked on 17 November 2026. Education only, not accounting advice.
This article is one calculation from The Revenue Recognition Handbook. The book follows one company's revenue through a year, from the first contract review to the year-end disclosures, and every figure it prints is a live formula in the free workbook.
Get the PDF edition, $19.99 Paperback · Free companion files