Articles

How much must a fund sell to cure a passive concentration breach?

A position limit is tested against NAV, so a fund can breach it without trading when one holding rises or the rest of the portfolio falls. The cure is arithmetic, and it depends on what happens to the cash.

A fund holds $58.0m in one position, 11.6% of a $500.0m NAV, against a 12.0% limit. The position rises 25% and becomes 14.09% of NAV, a breach with no trade. Selling $10.76m and keeping the cash cures it. If the proceeds are distributed the sale must be $12.23m.

The assumptions

Illustrative fund, invented figures
ItemValue
Fund NAV at the start$500.0m
Largest position$58.0m (11.6% of NAV)
All other assets$442.0m
Single-position limit12.0% of NAV
Move in the largest position+25%, with other assets unchanged

The fund is inside its limit at the start. The limit is tested against current NAV, so the share of a position can change with no trade at all. A breach caused by market movement is usually called passive, and many agreements allow a period to correct it, but the amount to sell is the same whatever the label.

Step 1: how little room there is

Share = position ÷ NAV = 58.0 ÷ 500.0 = 11.6%

Largest position allowed = limit ÷ (1 − limit) × other assets = 12% ÷ 88% × 442.0 = $60.27m

Room to rise = 60.27 ÷ 58.0 − 1 = 3.9%

Excel: =12%/(1-12%)*442

A position at 11.6% of NAV looks comfortable, but a gain of only 3.9% takes it to the limit, because the position is also a growing part of the NAV it is measured against. The same breach follows if the other assets fall 3.8% with the position unchanged.

Step 2: how much to sell after a 25% gain

Position = 58.0 × 1.25 = $72.5m, NAV = 72.5 + 442.0 = $514.5m, share = 14.09%

If the proceeds stay in the fund as cash: sale = position − 12% × NAV = 72.5 − 61.74 = $10.76m

If the proceeds are distributed, NAV also falls: sale = (position − 12% × NAV) ÷ (1 − 12%) = 10.76 ÷ 0.88 = $12.23m

Excel: =(72.5-12%*514.5)/(1-12%)

Selling $10.76m and holding the cash returns the position to exactly 12.0% of an unchanged $514.5m NAV. Distributing the cash shrinks the denominator and needs $12.23m. Check: (72.5 − 12.23) ÷ (514.5 − 12.23) = 12.0%.

What if: other moves and another limit

Sale needed to restore the 12.0% limit
CasePositionNAVShareSale, cash keptSale, cash distributed
Position rises 25%$72.5m$514.5m14.09%$10.76m$12.23m
Position rises 50%$87.0m$529.0m16.45%$23.52m$26.73m
Other assets fall 10%$58.0m$455.8m12.72%$3.30m$3.75m

The distributed case always needs a larger sale, by a factor of 1 ÷ (1 − 12%) = 1.136. A looser limit gives more room: at 15.0% the position could rise to $78.0m, a 34.5% gain, before any sale is needed.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What is a passive concentration breach?

A breach caused by market movements rather than a new investment. Here a 25% gain takes a position from 11.6% to 14.09% of NAV against a 12.0% limit.

How much must the fund sell to cure it?

The excess over the limit. In this example it is $10.76m if the cash stays in the fund and $12.23m if it is distributed.

How can a fund see a passive breach coming?

By measuring headroom: the largest position allowed is limit divided by one minus limit, times other assets. Here it is $60.27m, only 3.9% above the current $58.0m.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Private Markets Risk Manager rebuild the risk dashboard of a fictional manager and three of its funds over four quarter ends, with leverage, a NAV loan, a liquidity stress test and a loan-to-value breach and its remediation, plus an editable toolkit of checklists. The fund in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on markets, funds and compliance, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: private equity and private markets → · All 1908 articles →