Articles

How much cash does a cash-out refinance release, and what does it do to the DTI?

A cash-out refinance is limited by value or by income, whichever binds first, and it reprices the whole old balance, not just the cash.

A borrower with a $500,000 home, a $280,000 balance at 3.25% and an income of $9,500 a month can borrow up to 80% of value, $400,000. After 2.5% closing costs of $10,000 the cash out is $110,000. The principal and interest payment rises from $1,364 to $2,661 and the debt-to-income ratio from 28.0% to 41.7%, so the cash costs $1,297 a month, not the new payment on $110,000.

The assumptions

Illustrative cash-out refinance, 30-year fixed
ItemValue
Home value$500,000
Existing balance / rate / term left$280,000 / 3.25% / 25 years
New rate / term7.00% / 30 years
Maximum loan to value80%
Closing costs, on the new loan2.5%
Taxes and insurance / other debts, monthly$700 / $600
Gross income, monthly / DTI limit$9,500 / 43%

Step 1: the loan the property allows

Maximum loan by value = home value × maximum LTV

Cash out = new loan − payoff − closing costs

Excel: =B2*B8 and =C2-B3-B9*C2

$500,000 × 80% = $400,000. Closing costs are 2.5% × $400,000 = $10,000, so the cash out is $400,000 − $280,000 − $10,000 = $110,000.

Step 2: the loan the income allows

Payment cap = 43% × income − taxes and insurance − other debts

Loan by DTI = PV(rate ÷ 12, 360, −payment cap)

Excel: =PV(0.07/12,360,-B14)

0.43 × $9,500 = $4,085, less $700 and $600 is a payment cap of $2,785. At 7.00% over 30 years that supports a loan of $418,607. The value test gives $400,000 and the income test $418,607, so the binding test is value.

Step 3: what the cash costs each month

Before and after the refinance
BeforeAfter
Loan balance$280,000$400,000
Principal and interest, monthly$1,364$2,661
Taxes, insurance and other debts$1,300$1,300
Debt-to-income ratio28.0%41.7%

The payment rises by $1,297 a month. Most of that is not the cost of the $110,000 of cash: the whole $280,000 balance moves from 3.25% to 7.00%. The same $110,000 borrowed as a separate loan at 7.00% over 30 years would cost $732 a month, against the $1,297 the refinance adds. The refinance costs more per month because it reprices the old balance, and the extra is the real price of the cash.

What if: income is $8,200

The payment cap becomes 0.43 × $8,200 − $1,300 = $2,226 and the income test supports $334,585, below the $400,000 the value allows. The binding test switches to income, the loan is $334,585 and the cash out falls to $46,220 after $8,365 of costs. A $1,300 fall in monthly income removes $63,780 of cash out.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How much cash can a borrower take out in a cash-out refinance?

The lower of the loan by value and the loan by income, less the payoff and costs. At 80% of a $500,000 home with a $280,000 balance and 2.5% costs, $110,000.

Does a cash-out refinance change the DTI?

Yes, through the new payment on the whole balance. Here the payment rises from $1,364 to $2,661 and the DTI from 28.0% to 41.7%.

When does income limit the cash out instead of value?

When the loan the 43% DTI supports is below 80% of value. At $8,200 of monthly income the income test gives $334,585 against $400,000 by value.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Mortgage Underwriter rebuild a fictional borrower file, with income, debt-to-income, loan to value, mortgage insurance and the decision memo, in live formulas. The loans in this article are invented and are not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 11 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on banking, credit and payments, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: real estate investing, finance and fund management → · All 1908 articles →