Private mortgage insurance is a monthly cost until the balance falls to 80% of the original value, and it also counts in the debt-to-income ratio. The duration depends on the loan to value and on the rate, not on the premium.
A buyer puts 10% down on a $400,000 home: a $360,000 loan at 6.5% over 30 years, a payment of $2,275.44 and PMI of 0.60% a year, $180 a month. The balance reaches 80% of the original value, $320,000, after 95 months (7 years 11 months), so PMI costs $17,100 if the borrower asks for cancellation, or $19,620 if it ends automatically at 78% in month 109. The same home with 5% down at 0.90% costs $285 a month for 124 months, $35,340. PMI also adds 1.89 points to the front-end ratio.
| Item | 10% down | 5% down |
|---|---|---|
| Home price and appraised value | $400,000 | $400,000 |
| Loan amount | $360,000 | $380,000 |
| Interest rate | 6.50% | 6.50% |
| Annual PMI, % of original loan | 0.60% | 0.90% |
| Property tax and insurance | $520 a month | $520 a month |
PMI is charged on the original loan amount and does not fall as the balance falls, which is the common structure for borrower-paid monthly premiums. The cancellation rules below are those of a typical US conventional loan, 80% on request and 78% automatically, subject to the loan being current. Check the loan documents for the actual terms.
Payment = L × i ÷ (1 − (1 + i)−N), i = rate ÷ 12, N = 360
Monthly PMI = original loan × annual rate ÷ 12
Excel: =-PMT(6.5%/12,360,360000)
Payment on $360,000: $2,275.44. PMI: 360,000 × 0.60% ÷ 12 = $180. For the 5% down loan, the payment is $2,401.86 and PMI is 380,000 × 0.90% ÷ 12 = $285.
The balance after k payments is L × (1 + i)k − payment × ((1 + i)k − 1) ÷ i. The target is 80% of the original value, 0.80 × 400,000 = $320,000, and 78%, $312,000. The balance first falls below $320,000 at month 95 ($319,708) and below $312,000 at month 109 ($311,822). That is 7 years 11 months and 9 years 1 months, because in the early years most of the payment is interest: the loan loses only 11.2% of its balance in the first 7.9 years.
Cost = monthly PMI × months. If the borrower requests cancellation at 80%: 95 × $180 = $17,100. If PMI stays until the automatic termination at 78%: 109 × $180 = $19,620, $2,520 more for not asking. For the 5% down loan the 80% mark is month 124 (10 years 4 months): 124 × $285 = $35,340, 2.1 times the cost of the 10% down loan, from a monthly premium 1.6 times higher and a duration that is 1.3 times longer.
Front-end ratio = (payment + tax and insurance + PMI) ÷ gross monthly income
Back-end ratio = (housing payment + other monthly debts) ÷ gross monthly income
With income of $9,500 a month and other debts of $450: without PMI the front-end ratio is (2,275.44 + 520) ÷ 9,500 = 29.43% and with PMI 31.32%. The back-end ratio is 34.16% without and 36.06% with PMI. To keep the back-end ratio at 43%, the borrower needs income of $7,966 a month with PMI against $7,548 without: $419 a month more, because every PMI dollar must be covered by $2.33 of income.
After 24 payments the balance is $351,683. On the original value of $400,000 the ratio is 87.9%. If a new appraisal shows $440,000, a rise of 10%, the ratio becomes 79.93%, below 80%. Lenders often allow cancellation on current value after a minimum period, commonly two years, with an appraisal. The PMI paid is 24 × $180 = $4,320, instead of $17,100: a saving of $12,780, less the appraisal fee.
On a $360,000 loan at 6.5% over 30 years, the balance falls to 80% of the original value after 95 months, 7 years 11 months. If the borrower asks for cancellation then, PMI of $180 a month costs $17,100 in total.
Yes, it is part of the housing payment. With income of $9,500 a month it raises the front-end ratio from 29.43% to 31.32% and the back-end ratio from 34.16% to 36.06%.
Often, with a new appraisal and after a minimum holding period, commonly two years. If the home above is worth $440,000 after 24 months, the loan to value is 79.93% and PMI can end after $4,320 instead of $17,100.
The free companion files for The Mortgage Underwriter rebuild a fictional borrower file, with income, debt-to-income, loan to value, mortgage insurance and the decision memo, in live formulas. The loans in this article are invented and are not in them. No account and no email address.
Not on Amazon: 11 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on banking, credit and payments, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →
Reading guide: real estate investing, finance and fund management → · All 1908 articles →