Articles

How much borrow cost does a short thesis need to overcome?

A short pays the borrow fee and the dividend while it waits, and earns interest on the proceeds. The net carry sets how far the stock has to fall before the idea makes money.

A $50 million short in a stock at $40, held nine months, pays a 12% borrow fee, pays a 2% dividend and earns 4.3% on the cash proceeds. The net carry is -9.7% a year, so the stock must fall 7.27%, to $37.09, before the short breaks even. If the thesis works and the price reaches $32, the short earns $6.36 million, 12.7% of the position, and the borrow fee alone has taken 45% of the price gain.

A long position earns the dividend and pays nothing while it waits. A short does the reverse: it pays the dividend, pays a fee for the borrowed stock, and earns interest on the cash from the sale. The thesis can be right on price and still lose money after these carry items. The break-even is the first number to compute for any short.

The assumptions

One illustrative short
ItemValue
Short sold at$40.00
Shares sold short1.25 million
Position value$50.0 million
Horizon9 months
Borrow fee12.0% a year
Dividend yield2.0% a year
Interest on cash proceeds4.3% a year
Price target$32.00 (20% fall)

Step 1: the carry per share

Borrow fee = price × fee × time

Dividends paid = price × dividend yield × time

Interest earned = price × cash rate × time

Borrow fee: 40.00 × 12.0% × 0.75 = 3.60. Dividends: 40.00 × 2.0% × 0.75 = 0.60. Interest on the proceeds: 40.00 × 4.3% × 0.75 = 1.29. The net cost of waiting is 3.60 + 0.60 − 1.29 = 2.91 per share.

Step 2: the break-even

Break-even price = start price − net carry cost per share

Break-even fall = (fee + dividend yield − cash rate) × time

Excel: =(Fee+DivYield-CashRate)*Time

(12.0% + 2.0% − 4.3%) × 0.75 = 7.275%, which is $2.91 on $40.00. The stock must reach $37.09 for the short to cover its costs.

Step 3: profit if the thesis works

A fall to $32 gives 8.00 per share. Net profit is 8.00 − 2.91 = 5.09 per share, so on 1.25 million shares $6.36 million, 12.7% of the position or 17.0% annualised. The borrow fee alone is 3.60 / 8.00 = 45.0% of the gross price gain.

Step 4: across borrow fees

Nine-month short, price target $32
Borrow feeNet carry a yearBreak-even fallNet profit per shareProfit as % of positionFee as % of price gain
0.5%1.8%-1.35%8.5421.3%2%
3.0%-0.7%0.53%7.7919.5%11%
8.0%-5.7%4.28%6.2915.7%30%
12.0%-9.7%7.27%5.0912.7%45%
20.0%-17.7%13.27%2.696.7%75%
30.0%-27.7%20.78%-0.31-0.8%113%

The fee that exactly cancels a 20% fall solves (fee + 2.0% − 4.3%) × 0.75 = 20%, so fee = 20% / 0.75 + 4.3% − 2.0% = 29.0%. Above it the idea loses money even if the stock falls to $32.

What if: the fee spikes to 30%

A crowded short can see its fee reprice sharply. At 30% the net carry is -27.7% a year, the break-even fall is (30.0% + 2.0% − 4.3%) × 0.75 = 20.78%, and a fall to $32 returns -0.31 per share, -0.8% of the starting price, against 12.7% at 12%. The 30% fee is above the 29.0% limit, so the short loses money although the stock fell 20%.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

What is a borrow fee on a short position?

The annual rate the lender charges for stock that is scarce, applied to the value of the shares borrowed. At 12% on $50 million for nine months it costs $4.50 million.

Why do short sellers earn interest on the proceeds?

The cash from selling the borrowed shares is held as collateral and earns a short-term rate, 4.3% here, less any rebate adjustments. On $50 million for nine months that is $1.612 million.

Does the borrow fee stay constant?

No. It is repriced as availability changes and can rise sharply when a short becomes crowded. At 30% the break-even fall is 20.8% instead of 7.3%.

The workbooks behind this article

The workbooks for this book follow a long-short fund through position sizing, exposure and performance arithmetic. The borrow-fee grid in this article is a separate illustration and is not in them.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 36 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on how to read the documents, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: corporate finance, valuation and markets → · All 1908 articles →