The loss budget fixes the size. The conviction, the expected return and the borrow cost decide only whether the position is worth taking at that size.
If the stock goes from $32 to the bull case of $44, a short loses 37.5% of its value. A fund of $2,400 million that will accept a loss of 0.5 per cent of NAV ($12 million) can therefore short 1.33% of NAV: $32.0 million, or 1,000,000 shares. At that size the expected net return of 15.94% adds 21.2 basis points to NAV.
A short position has an asymmetric payoff: the gain is capped at the stock going to zero and the loss is not capped at all. The practical answer is to size the position so that the stock’s bull case, not its base case, costs a fixed share of the fund. This article works through that sizing for the short in the book’s Velmont case.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Fund NAV | $2,400.0 million |
| Share price | $32 |
| Bear case price, probability | $20, 60% |
| Base case price, probability | $30, 25% |
| Bull case price, probability | $44, 15% |
| Borrow cost (annual) | 2.5% |
| Loss budget, short position (share of NAV) | 0.5% |
A short loses when the price rises. The loss as a share of the position is the bull price over today’s price, less one:
Loss in the bull case = bull price ÷ price − 1. In Excel: =B4/B2-1, with the price in B2 and the bull price in B4.
44 ÷ 32 − 1 = 37.5%. For every $1 shorted, the bull case costs 0.375.
The position size is the loss budget divided by that loss:
Position (% of NAV) = loss budget ÷ loss in the bull case. In Excel: =B7/B5, with the budget in B7 and the loss in B5.
0.5% ÷ 37.5% = 1.333% of NAV. On $2,400 million that is 0.013333 × 2,400 = $32.0 million, or 32,000,000 ÷ 32 = 1,000,000 shares. Check: $32.0 million × 37.5% = $12.0 million, which is 0.50 per cent of NAV.
The size says nothing about the return. Weight the three prices:
Expected price = Σ probability × price. Expected net return on the short = (price − expected price) ÷ price − borrow cost. In Excel: =SUMPRODUCT(B8:B10,C8:C10).
0.60 × 20 + 0.25 × 30 + 0.15 × 44 = 12.00 + 7.50 + 6.60 = $26.10. The expected gross return on the short is (32 − 26.1) ÷ 32 = 18.44%, and after the 2.5 per cent borrow cost 15.94%. On $32.0 million that is $5.10 million, or 21.25 basis points of NAV. The borrow alone costs $0.80 million a year.
The bull case is the judgment that matters. A higher bull price means a larger loss per dollar and a smaller position:
| Bull case price | Loss if it comes | Position (% of NAV) | Position ($m) | Shares |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $38 | 18.75% | 2.67% | 64.0 | 2,000,000 |
| $44 | 37.50% | 1.33% | 32.0 | 1,000,000 |
| $52 | 62.50% | 0.80% | 19.2 | 600,000 |
| $64 | 100.00% | 0.50% | 12.0 | 375,000 |
The position of $32.0 million is sized for $44. If the stock goes further and nothing is done, the loss passes the budget:
| Price | Rise from $32 | Loss ($m) | Loss (% of NAV) | Over budget? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $38 | 18.75% | 6.00 | 0.25% | no |
| $44 | 37.50% | 12.00 | 0.50% | no |
| $50 | 56.25% | 18.00 | 0.75% | yes |
| $56 | 75.00% | 24.00 | 1.00% | yes |
| $64 | 100.00% | 32.00 | 1.33% | yes |
Size from the loss, not from the gain: loss budget over bull-case loss gives 1.33% of NAV here, $32.0 million. Then check that the expected net return of 15.94% justifies the borrow and the squeeze risk at that size. If the bull case moves from $44 to $52, the same budget supports a position of only $19.2 million. For the full short case, with the short interest and days to cover, see The Hedge Fund Analyst.
The inputs are in Hedge_Fund_Analyst_Model.xlsx: the Inputs sheet holds NAV, the Velmont prices and probabilities, the borrow cost and the 0.5 per cent short loss budget, and the Short sheet computes the expected value, the expected return after borrow, the loss if the bull case comes and the position in per cent of NAV and in dollars. The bull-case table and the price table above are not in the workbook; they use the same formulas.
Divide the loss budget by the loss if the bull case comes. A 0.5% budget and a 37.5% bull-case loss give 1.33% of NAV, $32.0 million on $2,400 million.
Because the loss on a short is not capped. The bear case sets the gain, which is at most 100% of the position; the bull case sets the loss that the budget must absorb.
It reduces the return by 2.5% a year here: the expected gross return of 18.44% becomes 15.94%, and the borrow costs $0.80 million a year on the position.
Every figure above is built from the inputs in the free companion files for The Hedge Fund Analyst, which also hold the Brayford long case, a quarter of attribution into beta and alpha, and the management and performance fees. No account and no email address.
Not on Amazon: 24 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on insurance and retirement, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →
Reading guide: corporate finance, valuation and markets → · All 1908 articles →