The Treasury hedge removes the rate move and leaves the spread. Each basis point of widening costs $11,530 on a $57,751 edge, so the edge lasts 5.0 bp.
A dealer buys $20 million of a 5 per cent seven-year corporate bond from a client at a 110 bp spread over the 7-year Treasury, against a 105 bp mid, and sells Treasuries against it. The bid is 0.2888 points under mid, an edge of $57,751. The position carries $11,530 of credit spread risk per basis point, which the Treasury hedge does not touch, so 5.0 bp of widening takes the whole edge. On day two the Treasury curve fell 8 bp and the spread widened 3 bp: the hedge worked, and the position still lost $34,551, 59.8 per cent of the edge.
Chapters 7, 8 and 9 of the book follow this one ticket from the request for quote to the hedge, day two and the resale. This article asks the question the day-two loss raises: how much widening can the edge absorb before the trade is under water? Every figure comes from the Thornbury Vale case and is recalculated below from the formulas.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Corporate bond | 5% coupon, 7 years, semiannual |
| 7-year Treasury, 4% coupon, yield | 4.10% |
| Mid spread and mid yield | 105 bp, 5.15% |
| Mid price | 99.127719 |
| Desk bid spread and bid yield | 110 bp, 5.20% |
| Bid price (the desk buys) | 98.838966 |
| Client sale | $20 million face |
| DV01 per $1 million: bond at the bid, 7-year Treasury | $576.51 and $601.07 |
| Day two: Treasury yields, bond spread | −8 bp and +3 bp |
The edge is the gap between mid and bid, times the face:
Edge = (mid price − bid price) ÷ 100 × face. In Excel: =(B2-B3)/100*B4*1000000 in B5, with the mid price in B2, the bid price in B3 and the face in millions in B4.
99.127719 − 98.838966 = 0.288753 points, and 0.288753 ÷ 100 × 20,000,000 = $57,751. The same edge in spread terms is the bid spread less the mid spread, 110 − 105 = 5 bp, because repricing the bond 5 bp wider at flat Treasuries returns exactly the bid price.
The risk of a bond to its own spread, the CS01, is its DV01 times the face. A one-basis-point move in the spread over the Treasury and a one-basis-point move in the yield reprice the bond alike:
CS01 = DV01 per $1 million × face in millions. In Excel: =B6*B4 in B7, with the DV01 per $1 million of the bond at the bid in B6.
576.51 × 20 = $11,530 a basis point. The edge covers 57,751 ÷ 11,530 = 5.01 bp by this shortcut, and exactly 5.00 by repricing; the 0.01 is the convexity the shortcut ignores. In Excel: =B5/B7, the edge over the CS01.
The Treasury hedge matches the DV01 of the bond: 11,530.18 ÷ 601.07 = 19.18 million of the 7-year note sold (the book rounds it to $19.2 million), a ratio of 0.9591. In Excel: =B7/B8, with the Treasury DV01 per $1 million in B8.
On day two the Treasury yield falls 8 bp to 4.02 per cent and the spread widens 3 bp, so the bond’s yield moves from 5.15 to 5.10 per cent and its mid price from 99.127719 to 99.417474. The long bond gains (99.417474 − 99.127719) ÷ 100 × 20,000,000 = $57,951. The 19.18 million of Treasuries, 99.396812 before and 99.879023 after, lose $92,502. The net is −$34,551.
| Source | Long bond | Treasury hedge | Net |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rates: yield down 8 bp | +$92,818 | −$92,502 | +$316 |
| Spread: widening 3 bp | −$34,674 | $0 | −$34,674 |
| Both moves together (interaction) | −$193 | $0 | −$193 |
| Day two | +$57,951 | −$92,502 | −$34,551 |
The hedge did its job: rates netted +$316 on a move of 8 bp. The loss is the spread. Of the $57,751 earned in step 1, $34,551 is gone, 59.8 per cent, and $23,200 is left, 40.2 per cent. In Excel the shortcut is =-B7*B9, with the spread change in basis points in B9.
With Treasuries flat and the position hedged, the bond’s profit over its bid cost after a widening of w bp is the repriced bond minus the bid price, times the face: (price at 5.15% + w bp − 98.838966) ÷ 100 × 20,000,000. The shortcut is edge − CS01 × w.
| Widening | Repriced profit | Share of edge used | CS01 shortcut |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 bp | $46,185 | 20.0% | $46,221 |
| 2 bp | $34,626 | 40.0% | $34,690 |
| 3 bp | $23,076 | 60.0% | $23,160 |
| 5 bp | $0 | 100.0% | $100 |
| 7 bp | −$23,044 | 139.9% | −$22,961 |
| 10 bp | −$57,551 | 199.7% | −$57,551 |
Each basis point of widening uses a fifth of the edge. The line is nearly straight, and slightly convex: the shortcut reads $100 at 5 bp where repricing reads zero. The 5 bp is a fact about this ticket: the dealer bought 5 bp wide of mid, so a 5 bp move back to the bid level returns the bond to its cost. On the day-two figures, 3 bp of widening plus an 8 bp fall in Treasuries leaves $23,200, close to the $23,076 of the spread move alone.
On a hedged trade the edge is a number of basis points: bid spread less mid spread, here 5 bp, worth $57,751 at $11,530 a basis point. Three basis points of widening on day two took $34,551 of it, and 5.0 bp takes all of it. Before bidding, divide the edge by the CS01 and compare the result with how far the spread typically moves between the purchase and the resale. For the same arithmetic on a whole portfolio, see How do you calculate a credit spread stress loss with spread duration?
The case is in Fixed_Income_Desk_Model.xlsx. On the Client Trade sheet, C10 gives the $57,751 edge, C12 the DV01 and CS01 of the trade, C14 and C15 the hedge and its ratio, C22 the day-two net of −$34,551 and C23 the spread move times CS01. The break-even grid above is not printed in the workbook: to rebuild it, set the Treasury change to 0 and the spread change to 5 on the Inputs sheet (C23 and C24), and C10 plus C22 comes to zero. Setting the desk bid spread to 108 (C20) brings C10 plus C22 to −$4.
No. The hedge matches the bond’s rate risk, not its credit spread risk. On the $20m position the Treasury hedge leaves a CS01 of $11,530 a basis point, so a 3 bp widening costs $34,674 on a repricing (34,591 by the CS01 shortcut) however well the hedge works.
Because the rate move was hedged away and the spread move was not. The rates leg netted +$316 (bond +$92,818, Treasury hedge -$92,502); the 3 bp of widening cost $34,674, and an interaction term another $193, for a net of -$34,551.
The edge divided by the trade’s CS01: $57,751 over $11,530 is 5.01 bp by the shortcut and exactly 5.00 bp by repricing, the 110 bp bid spread less the 105 bp mid. At a 108 bp bid the edge is $34,674 and covers 3.00 bp.
The Thornbury Vale case is a live workbook in the free companion files for The Fixed Income Trader, which also hold the pricing of four Treasuries and a corporate bond, the curve and roll-down, risk limits, value at risk and the desk’s year. The Checks sheet sets each printed figure beside the computed one. No account and no email address.
How to Read a Bond Indenture
108 pages, printed on demand and shipped worldwide, direct from the author: $32.99 paperback, $19.99 PDF. Not sold on Amazon. See the book →
The bookshop
151 handbooks and exam guides by Julian R. Sterling that are not on Amazon, sorted by subject. 15% off from 2 books. Browse the bookshop →
Reading guide: credit investing, private credit and distressed debt → · All 1908 articles →