Articles

How long can a client hold a stock on a total return swap before buying it is cheaper?

A total return swap gives the client the stock's price and dividends without buying it, so it saves stamp duty on the way in. The saving is paid for every year by a financing spread and by dividend leakage.

A total return swap on GBP 50.0m of a UK stock costs GBP 487.5k a year more than owning the shares, 0.975% of the notional. The 0.5% stamp duty it avoids, GBP 250.0k, is used up in 6.2 months: held for longer than that, buying the stock is cheaper.

The assumptions

Illustrative swap against a purchase, invented figures
ItemValue
Exposure wantedGBP 50.0m of one UK-listed stock
Benchmark rate4.30% a year, also what the client earns on cash
Swap financingClient pays benchmark plus 0.65% on the notional
Dividends3.0% yield; the swap passes through 90% of them, the dealer keeps 10% against its tax cost
Collateral10% of the notional posted to the dealer, earning the benchmark less 0.25%
PurchaseStamp duty of 0.5% on buying the shares; no stamp duty on the swap; dealer hedge exempt
Price movesIdentical either way, so they cancel; trading costs and tax on the swap are left out

The client wants GBP 50.0m of exposure either way. The cash it does not spend on shares keeps earning the benchmark, so each route is measured against holding GBP 50.0m in cash.

Step 1: the annual carry of owning the shares

Dividends received: 50.0 × 3.0% = GBP 1.50m

Interest forgone on the cash spent: 50.0 × 4.30% = GBP 2.150m

Net carry against cash: 1.50 − 2.150 = GBP -0.650m a year

Step 2: the annual carry of the swap

Interest on the 90% of cash kept: 45.0 × 4.30% = GBP 1.9350m

Interest on the collateral: 5.0 × (4.30% − 0.25%) = GBP 0.2025m

Financing paid: 50.0 × (4.30% + 0.65%) = GBP 2.4750m

Dividends received: 50.0 × 3.0% × 90% = GBP 1.3500m

Net: 1.9350 + 0.2025 − 2.4750 + 1.3500 = GBP 1.0125m, which is GBP -1.1375m against holding cash

Step 3: what the swap costs more than owning, and the break-even

Extra annual cost: -0.6500 − (-1.1375) = GBP 0.4875m, or 0.975% of the notional

It splits into the 0.650% spread, 0.300% of dividends kept by the dealer (10% of 3.0%) and 0.025% of collateral rebate shortfall: 0.650 + 0.300 + 0.025 = 0.975%

Stamp duty saved: 50.0 × 0.5% = GBP 0.250m

Break-even holding period: 0.250 ÷ 0.4875 = 0.513 years = 6.2 months

Excel: =0.005*50/(50*(0.0065+0.1*0.03+0.1*0.0025)) gives the break-even in years

Cost of each route by holding period, GBP m (positive last column favours the swap)
Holding period, monthsStamp duty on buyingExtra cost of swapSwap advantage
3.00.250.120.13
6.00.250.240.01
6.2 (break-even)0.250.250.00
9.00.250.37-0.12
12.00.250.49-0.24
24.00.250.97-0.72

Below 6.2 months the swap is cheaper because the stamp duty is paid at once while the swap's extra cost builds up month by month. At 12 months owning is ahead by GBP 0.237m, and at 24 months by GBP 0.725m.

What if: the terms are better

Extra cost of the swap and break-even holding period
CaseExtra cost, % of notional a yearExtra cost, GBP k a yearBreak-even, months
Base case0.975%487.56.2
Dealer passes through 100% of dividends0.675%337.58.9
Swap spread 0.40%0.725%362.58.3
Both0.425%212.514.1

With full dividend pass-through the swap costs 0.675% a year and the break-even stretches to 8.9 months. With a 0.40% spread as well it reaches 14.1 months. Even then a client planning to hold for two years is better off buying. The comparison leaves out leverage, voting rights, the tax treatment of swap payments and the dealer's own cost of funds.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How long can a client hold a stock on a total return swap before buying it is cheaper?

About 6.2 months here. The swap costs GBP 487.5k a year more than owning, and the 0.5% stamp duty saved is GBP 250.0k.

Why does the swap cost more than just its financing spread?

Because the dealer keeps 10% of the dividends and pays a rebate on the collateral that is 0.25% below the benchmark. Those two add 0.325% to the 0.650% spread.

Does the break-even depend on the dividend yield?

Yes, through the pass-through. At a 3.0% yield every 10 points of leakage costs 0.30% a year; with full pass-through the break-even is 8.9 months instead of 6.2.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Equity Sales and Trading Professional rebuild a fictional equities desk's year, with commissions, trading cost, execution quality and the desk's profit and loss. The swap in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on markets, funds and compliance, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: corporate finance, valuation and markets → · All 1908 articles →