Articles

How big a secondaries sleeve does a fund of funds need to repay its fee layer?

A secondary bought at a discount shows a gain on day one. How much of the second fee layer that gain repays depends on the discount, and below a threshold it cannot repay it at all.

A fund of funds that charges 0.90% a year on $100.0 million of commitments for eight years adds a second fee layer of $7.2 million. A secondary bought at a 10% discount to net asset value shows an immediate gain of 11.1% of the price paid, so it takes $64.8 million of secondaries, 64.8% of the programme, to repay the layer from the discount alone. At a 5% discount the whole $100 million is not enough.

The assumptions

Illustrative fund of funds, $ millions
ItemValue
Programme size (commitments)100.0
Fund of funds fee, on commitments0.90% a year
Fee period8 years
Discount on secondaries5% to 25% of NAV

The question is narrow: how much of the second fee layer a secondaries sleeve repays at purchase, from the discount alone. Returns on the underlying funds, carry and the time value of the fees are left out, and the reported NAV is assumed to be right.

Step 1: the cost of the fee layer

Fee layer = programme × fee rate × years

Excel: =B2*B3*B4

$100.0 million × 0.90% × 8 = $7.2 million, 7.2% of the programme. An investor paying direct would not pay it.

Step 2: what a discount is worth when you buy

A stake with net asset value of 100 bought at a price of 100 × (1 − d) gives a gain on day one of 100 × d. Expressed on the money paid, the gain is d ÷ (1 − d): 11.1% at a 10% discount, 17.6% at 15%, 25.0% at 20%.

Gain on a purchase of A = A × d ÷ (1 − d)

Break-even purchase = fee layer × (1 − d) ÷ d

Excel: =B5*(1-B6)/B6

Step 3: the sleeve that pays for the layer

Secondaries purchased to repay a $7.2 million fee layer from the discount
DiscountGain on money paidBreak-even purchaseShare of programmeGain if all $100m
5%5.3%136.8 (above 100)not reachable5.3
8%8.7%82.882.8%8.7
10%11.1%64.864.8%11.1
15%17.6%40.840.8%17.6
20%25.0%28.828.8%25.0
25%33.3%21.621.6%33.3

At a 10% discount, $64.8 million × 11.1% = $7.2 million. At 15% the sleeve is $40.8 million, at 20% it is $28.8 million. Below a discount of 6.7% the layer cannot be repaid even if the whole programme is bought on the secondary market, because P × d ÷ (1 − d) falls under 7.2.

What if: the fee layer is 0.60%

At 0.60% the layer is $4.8 million, and the break-even sleeve at a 10% discount falls from $64.8 million to $43.2 million. A 5% discount now needs $91.2 million, still short of what a typical secondary allocation can supply. A cheaper layer is worth more than a deeper discount on part of the book.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How much secondaries does a fund of funds need to repay its fee layer?

Fee layer ÷ (d ÷ (1 − d)). With a $7.2 million layer and a 10% discount, $64.8 million, 64.8% of a $100 million programme.

Why is a 10% discount worth 11.1% of the money paid?

Because the stake is bought at 90 for a NAV of 100. The gain of 10 is 10 ÷ 90 = 11.1% of the price.

Can a secondaries sleeve always repay the fee layer?

No. Below a discount of 6.7%, even buying the whole $100 million programme on the secondary market would not repay a $7.2 million layer.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Fund of Funds Investor rebuild Larkspur Private Markets Fund IV, the fictional $600 million fund of funds, with its primaries, secondaries, co-investments, second layer of fees and carry, J-curve and gross and net returns. The team-size arithmetic in this article uses invented costs and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 24 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on insurance and retirement, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: private equity and private markets → · All 1908 articles →