Articles

At what programme size does investing directly beat a fund of funds?

A direct team has a fixed cost and a low variable cost; the fund of funds is the opposite. The programme size decides which is cheaper.

A fund of funds charging 0.75% on commitments plus 0.15% of expenses costs 0.90% a year. A direct team costing $1.20 million a year plus 0.10% of commitments breaks even at $150.0 million of commitments: 1.20 ÷ (0.90% − 0.10%). Adding a 5% carry on a 70% gain lowers it to $104.3 million, and a $2.00 million team raises it to $250.0 million before carry.

The assumptions

Illustrative annual figures for a programme of private equity fund commitments
ItemValue
Fund of funds management fee, on commitments0.75%
Fund of funds expenses, on commitments0.15%
Fund of funds carry5% of gains
Direct programme: team, data and legal, fixed per year$1.20 million
Direct programme: variable cost (advisers, travel, audit) on commitments0.10%
Life of the programme10 years

The cost is expressed per year on the programme’s total commitments. Both routes buy the same underlying funds and pay the same underlying fees and carry, so those cancel. The comparison covers only the extra layer.

Step 1: cost of each route

Fund of funds cost = (fee + expenses) × commitments

Direct cost = fixed cost + variable rate × commitments

Break-even size = fixed cost ÷ (fund of funds rate − variable rate)

Excel: =Fixed/((Fee+Exp)-Var)

The fund of funds rate is 0.75% + 0.15% = 0.90%. The break-even is 1.20 ÷ (0.90% − 0.10%) = $150.0 million of commitments.

Step 2: the cost at different sizes

Annual cost, $ million, before carry
Commitments ($m)Fund of fundsDirectDirect, % of commitmentsCheaper
500.451.252.50%Fund of funds
1000.901.301.30%Fund of funds
1501.351.350.90%Equal
2001.801.400.70%Direct
3002.701.500.50%Direct

Below $150.0 million the fixed team cost spreads over too little capital: at $50 million the direct route costs 2.50% a year against 0.90%. Above it the variable rate of 0.10% wins: at $300 million the direct route costs 0.50%.

Step 3: add the carry

The fund of funds also takes carry. If the programme gains 70% of commitments over 10 years before this layer’s carry, 5% of that is 3.50% of commitments, or 0.35% a year. The fund of funds rate becomes 0.90% + 0.35% = 1.25%, and the break-even size falls to 1.20 ÷ (1.25% − 0.10%) = $104.3 million.

What if: the direct team costs $2.00 million a year

A larger team, with a dedicated analyst and an adviser on retainer, moves the fixed cost to $2.00 million. The break-even before carry becomes 2.00 ÷ 0.80% = $250.0 million, and with carry 2.00 ÷ 1.15% = $173.9 million. A fixed cost 67% higher raises the break-even by the same 67%, because the size is proportional to the fixed cost.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

How do you find the size at which a direct programme beats a fund of funds?

Divide the direct team's fixed annual cost by the difference between the fund of funds rate and the direct variable rate. With $1.20 million of fixed cost, 0.90% and 0.10% the answer is $150.0 million.

Does the fund of funds carry change the break-even?

Yes, it lowers it. A 5% carry on a 70% gain over ten years adds 0.35% a year to the fund of funds rate and brings the break-even to $104.3 million.

Why is the size not the whole answer?

Cost is only part of it. A direct team must also obtain allocations in oversubscribed funds and build a diligence record, and neither appears in the cost comparison.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Fund of Funds Investor rebuild Larkspur Private Markets Fund IV, the fictional $600 million fund of funds, with its primaries, secondaries, co-investments, second layer of fees and carry, J-curve and gross and net returns. The team-size arithmetic in this article uses invented costs and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 19 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on markets, funds and compliance, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: private equity and private markets → · All 1908 articles →