Project departures by cause, apply the plan's distribution timing, value the vested shares and spread each payout over its installments.
An ESOP repurchase obligation is the cash a company must provide to buy back vested shares from departing participants. Project departures by cause, apply the Section 409(o) timing (retirees within a year, others from the sixth year), value the shares and spread payments over up to five years. A retiree with 2,000 shares at $33.15 receives five payments of $13,260.
Worked in full in The ESOP Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
Free: the ESOP transaction model in Excel, with the whole Carrow case, the stress case and the repurchase schedule.
An ESOP company must, in practice, buy back the vested shares of every participant who leaves, because private company shares cannot be sold to anyone else. Section 409(o) sets when payments must start: within a year after the plan year of retirement, death or disability, and in the sixth plan year after any other departure. Payments may be spread over up to five years; for 2026, accounts above $1,455,000 get one more year per $290,000, up to five more.
Repurchase cash in year Y = Σ over departure years d of (vested shares leaving in d × value per share in d) ÷ installments, for each d whose payment window includes Y
Two participants of a fictional ESOP company each hold 2,000 allocated shares at the end of 2033, when the appraised value is $33.15 a share. One retires; the other quits and is 60% vested.
| Retiree | Other leaver | |
|---|---|---|
| Vested shares | 2,000 | 1,200 |
| Value at departure | $66,300 | $39,780 |
| Payments | 5 x $13,260, 2034 to 2038 | 5 x $7,956, 2039 to 2043 |
The trap: most plans pay a deferred leaver at the value of the year of distribution, not the year of departure. If the share price rises in the five years of deferral, the bill rises with it.
In the case of the book, a 100% ESOP releases 40,000 shares a year over a 30-year internal loan. Each year participants holding 3% of allocated shares retire, die or become disabled, and 4% leave for other reasons.
| Year | Value per share | Repurchase cash |
|---|---|---|
| 2029 | $12.02 | $0.00 million |
| 2031 | $22.09 | $0.03 million |
| 2033 | $33.15 | $0.09 million |
| 2036 | $51.75 | $0.27 million |
| 2027 to 2036 | $0.78 million |
Ten years in, the payments look small: $0.78 million in total. But the 298,516 shares in participant accounts at the end of 2036 are worth $15.45 million, the company still owes $2.58 million of installments, and 800,000 shares have yet to be released. The obligation keeps growing long after the acquisition debt is gone.
Redemption (the company buys and retires the shares), recycling (the plan buys them with company contributions and reallocates them), a cash reserve, corporate-owned life insurance for death payouts, and room under the bank covenants. A repurchase obligation study, run on the real census for at least twenty years, tells the board which mix it needs.
Figures checked on 17 November 2026. Federal tax only, illustrative, and not legal or tax advice. The company in the examples is fictional.
Under Section 409(o), within one year after the end of the plan year of retirement, disability or death; for other departures, by the end of the sixth plan year after leaving. The plan can pay sooner.
Yes. Substantially equal annual payments over up to five years; for 2026, accounts above $1,455,000 can take one extra year per $290,000, up to five extra years.
Not as a liability for a private company. ASC 718-40 requires disclosure of the fair value of allocated shares subject to a repurchase obligation.
Because more shares are allocated each year, more participants reach retirement, and each share is worth more once the acquisition debt is gone.
This article is one calculation from The ESOP Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to selling a private company to an employee stock ownership plan: feasibility, valuation, financing, Section 1042, S corporation ESOPs and the repurchase obligation.
DRM-free PDF, $19.99 · Paperback, $32.99, shipped worldwide · Free Excel model