Articles

Does a mortgage help or hurt the return on cash-rent farmland?

Farmland yields little in rent and the rest of the return is growth in the land. A loan at 6.5% is a bet that the growth is higher than the gap between the rate and the yield.

Farmland bought at $12,000 an acre and leased for $480 of cash rent yields 3.25% after $90 of costs. A mortgage for 40% of the price at 6.5% costs more than the land yields, so the cash yield on equity falls to 1.08%. The loan only raises the total return if the land appreciates by more than 3.25% a year: at 3.0% growth the levered return is 6.08%, against 6.25% for an all-equity buyer.

The assumptions

Illustrative cash-rent farm, per acre
ItemValue
Purchase price$12,000
Cash rent received$480
Property tax, insurance and upkeep paid by the owner$90
Mortgage, interest only40% of price, 6.5%
Land value growth3.0% a year

With a cash-rent lease the operator bears the crop and the input costs, and the owner receives a fixed rent. The land return is the rent yield plus the change in land value. Rent is held constant for simplicity; in practice it is reset at each lease renewal. Fees, taxes on income and principal repayments are left out.

Step 1: the net yield and the cost of debt

Net operating income = 480 − 90 = $390 an acre

Net yield = 390 ÷ 12,000 = 3.25%

Interest = 40% × 12,000 × 6.5% = 4,800 × 6.5% = $312 an acre

Excel: =(Rent-Costs)/Price

The rent yield of 3.25% is below the 6.5% rate, so the debt is negatively leveraged on cash flow: every borrowed dollar costs 3.25 points more than it yields.

Step 2: the cash yield on equity and the coverage

Equity = 12,000 − 4,800 = $7,200

Cash yield on equity = (390 − 312) ÷ 7,200 = 1.08%

Debt service coverage = 390 ÷ 312 = 1.25x

The all-equity buyer receives 3.25% in cash; the levered buyer receives 1.08% on a smaller cheque. Coverage of 1.25x is acceptable to most farm lenders, but interest leaves only $78 of free cash an acre, so the equity depends on land growth for its return.

Step 3: the total return with land growth

Unlevered return = net yield + growth = 3.25% + 3.00% = 6.25%

Levered return = (390 + 0.03 × 12,000 − 312) ÷ 7,200 = (390 + 360 − 312) ÷ 7,200 = 6.08%

Break-even growth = mortgage rate − net yield = 6.50% − 3.25% = 3.25%

One-year return on equity by land growth
Land growthAll-equity returnReturn with 40% mortgageDifference, points
0.00%3.25%1.08%-2.17
2.00%5.25%4.42%-0.83
3.00%6.25%6.08%-0.17
3.25%6.50%6.50%0.00
5.00%8.25%9.42%1.17
7.00%10.25%12.75%2.50

The mortgage cost is a fixed 6.5%. It raises the equity return only when the total return on the land, rent yield plus growth, is higher than that rate. At 3.25% growth the total is exactly 6.50% and the two columns are equal. At 0% growth the levered buyer is 2.17 points worse off; at 7.0% growth 2.50 points better off.

What if: a bigger loan, or a cheaper one

At 50% loan-to-value and 3.0% growth the levered return is 6.00%, lower than the 6.08% at 40%, because each extra loan dollar costs more than the 6.25% the land earns. A rate of 5.5% on the 40% loan gives 6.75% at 3.0% growth, above the 6.25% unlevered, and moves the break-even growth to 2.25%. The coverage at 5.5% is 1.48x.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

Is a mortgage on cash-rent farmland positive or negative leverage?

Negative on cash flow when the net rent yield is below the interest rate: here 3.25% against 6.5%. On total return it depends on land appreciation, which needs to exceed 3.25% a year.

What land growth does leverage need to break even?

The mortgage rate minus the net rent yield: 6.50% minus 3.25% = 3.25% a year.

Why does a bigger loan lower the return here?

Each extra borrowed dollar costs 6.5% and the land earns 6.25% at 3.0% growth. At 50% loan-to-value the equity return is 6.00%, below the 6.08% at 40%.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Farmland and Timberland Investor rebuild a fictional land fund: row-crop farms leased for cash rent and bought with a mortgage, an almond orchard and a pine plantation, from rent and yields to appraisals, marks and the fund’s net returns. The farm in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 11 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on banking, credit and payments, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: real estate investing, finance and fund management → · All 1908 articles →