Articles

At what age should a pine plantation be harvested to maximise the value of the land?

A timber stand is cut when waiting another year no longer pays. The Faustmann test adds the value of the land for the next rotation, which makes the cutting age earlier than one harvest alone would suggest.

At a 6% discount rate the plantation should be cut at 30 years, where the land expectation value peaks at $425 an acre. At 7% a single harvest with no replanting would still wait until 30 years, but once the land is valued for the next rotation the answer drops to 25.

The assumptions

Illustrative loblolly pine plantation, per acre, invented figures
ItemValue
Planting cost$450 an acre at year 0, repeated at every rotation
Annual costs$12 an acre a year for taxes, insurance and management
Discount rate6% a year, nominal
GrowthMerchantable volume and stumpage price by age, in the table below
Thinnings and carbonNone, so one clearfell harvest at the chosen age

Stumpage is the price of standing timber. Older stands carry more volume and a larger share of sawtimber, so the price per ton rises with age until it flattens at 40 years.

Step 1: the value of the stand by age, and how fast it grows

Stand value = volume × price: at 30 years 185 tons × $30 = $5,550 an acre

Growth in value over five years, annualised: (valueT ÷ valueT−5)1/5 − 1. From 25 to 30 years: (5,550 ÷ 3,900)0.2 − 1 = 7.3%

From 30 to 35 years the stand grows by 4.1% a year, less than the 6% the money could earn elsewhere

Excel: =(5550/3900)^(1/5)-1

Stand value, growth and present values by harvest age
Age, yearsVolume, tonsPrice, $ a tonStand value, $Growth in last 5 yearsPV of one harvest at 6%, $Land expectation value, $
1560$12720n/a300-457
20105$181,89021.3%5892
25150$263,90015.6%909398
30185$305,5507.3%966425
35212$326,7844.1%883297
40232$337,6562.4%744126
45246$338,1181.2%590-49

Growth in value is above 6% through age 30 and below it after, so cutting at 30 is the last age at which waiting still pays. The present value of one harvest, with replanting ignored, peaks at the same age ($966 against $883 at 35).

Step 2: the value of the land with replanting

Faustmann land expectation value: LEV = (V − c × (1 + r)T) ÷ ((1 + r)T − 1) − a ÷ r

At T = 30: (1 + r)30 = 5.7435, so the numerator is 5,550 − 450 × 5.7435 = 2,965.4 and the denominator is 4.7435

First term: 2,965.4 ÷ 4.7435 = $625.2; annual costs: 12 ÷ 0.06 = $200.0

LEV = 625.2 − 200.0 = $425.2 an acre

Excel: =(5550-450*1.06^30)/(1.06^30-1)-12/0.06

LEV is what a buyer could pay for bare land today and earn 6% by planting and cutting at 30 forever. The same calculation gives $398 at 25 years and $297 at 35, so 30 is the maximum, and at 15 years the stand has not paid back its planting cost.

What if: the discount rate is different

Cutting age and land value by discount rate
Discount rateSingle-harvest optimum, yearsFaustmann optimum, yearsMaximum LEV, $ an acre
4%35301,523
5%3030845
6%3030425
7%3025158
8%2525-10

A higher rate shortens the rotation, because waiting costs more and the land is worth more when freed for the next crop. At 4% the single harvest waits until 35 years and the Faustmann age is 30; at 7% they are 30 and 25. At 8% the best LEV is −$10, so planting does not earn 8% at any age.

Cutting age and land value at 6% under other assumptions
CaseSingle-harvest optimum, yearsFaustmann optimum, yearsMaximum LEV, $ an acre
Base case3030425
Stumpage prices 15% lower3030250
Stumpage prices 30% lower303074
Planting cost $700 an acre3030122
Annual cost $20 an acre3030292

The cutting age holds at 30 in every case but the land value does not: a 15% fall in stumpage cuts the maximum LEV from $425 to $250, a 30% fall to $74, and a planting cost of $700 to $122. The model has no thinning income, no carbon payments, no price cycle and no option to delay a harvest in a weak market.

The common mistakes

Takeaway

Questions readers ask

At what age should a pine plantation be harvested?

At 30 years in this case, where the land expectation value peaks at $425 an acre at a 6% discount rate with $450 planting and $12 a year of costs.

Why does a higher discount rate mean earlier harvests?

Waiting costs more at a higher rate and the land can be replanted sooner. The Faustmann age drops from 30 years at 6% to 25 at 7%, and the maximum land value falls from $425 to $158 an acre.

How much does a fall in timber prices change the answer?

A 30% fall in stumpage leaves the cutting age at 30 but takes the land expectation value from $425 to $74 an acre.

The workbooks behind this article

The free companion files for The Farmland and Timberland Investor rebuild a fictional land fund: row-crop farms leased for cash rent and bought with a mortgage, an almond orchard and a pine plantation, from rent and yields to appraisals, marks and the fund’s net returns. The stand in this article is invented and is not in them. No account and no email address.

Open the companion files →

Not on Amazon: 10 paperbacks by Julian R. Sterling on real estate and housing, printed on demand and shipped worldwide. Browse the bookshop →

Also on this site

Reading guide: real estate investing, finance and fund management → · All 1908 articles →