Technical Articles · Common Law Debt vs. Equity

Debt vs. Equity Common Law Factors: Mixon, Fin Hay Realty, and Roth Steel

How US courts weigh Estate of Mixon, Fin Hay Realty, Roth Steel Tube, and PepsiCo Puerto Rico under Treas. Reg. 1.385-1(b) before Section 1.385-3 applies.

Treas. Reg. 1.385-1(b) establishes a strict order of operations: common law debt-vs-equity principles apply first, before Treas. Reg. 1.385-3 is ever tested. Even if an intercompany note fits comfortably under the $50M threshold or avoids the 36-month Funding Rule, an IRS exam team can still recharacterize it as equity under Estate of Mixon, Fin Hay Realty, and Roth Steel Tube.

Why Common Law Scrutiny Intensified After Section 1.385-2 Revocation

When T.D. 9880 revoked the formal Treas. Reg. 1.385-2 documentation regulations in November 2019, it eliminated automatic equity recharacterization for missing credit memos. It did not relax substantive common law standards. Under IRC Section 385(c), the issuer's initial characterization binds the taxpayer, not the IRS. Without contemporaneous creditworthiness analysis, market interest benchmarking, and disciplined payment enforcement, related-party debt remains highly vulnerable in Tax Court and IRS Appeals.

Synthesizing the Landmark Circuit Tests

Federal courts evaluate substance over form using overlapping multi-factor frameworks: 13 factors in Estate of Mixon v. United States (5th Cir. 1972), 16 factors in Fin Hay Realty Co. v. United States (3d Cir. 1968), and 11 factors in Roth Steel Tube Co. v. Commissioner (6th Cir. 1986), reinforced by modern corporate disputes such as PepsiCo Puerto Rico, Inc. v. Commissioner (T.C. Memo. 2012-269). Courts do not simply count factors; they weigh economic reality around five decisive pillars: unconditional fixed maturity, independent outside-lender creditworthiness, cash-flow repayment capacity, seniority relative to general creditors, and actual enforcement behavior.

Quantitative Common Law Scorecard Applied to MIH Instruments

In the Meridian Industrial Holdings Group (MIH) model, an 11-factor weighted scorecard (weights summing to 100%, with 65.00+ indicating Common Law Debt, 50.00 to 64.99 indicating Gray Zone audit risk, and below 50.00 indicating Common Law Equity) separates defensible debt from vulnerable hybrids:

MIH InstrumentPrincipalWeighted ScoreCommon Law GateSec. 1.385-3 Outcome
T1: Subordinated Note-for-Distribution$48.00M62.40Gray Zone (High Risk)Sheltered by QC + $50M Cap
T2: Senior Unsecured LuxCo Cash Loan$90.00M84.55Common Law Debt$45.00M Recharacterized
T3: Senior Cayman Acquisition Loan$65.00M81.18Common Law Debt$55.00M Recharacterized
T4: NL FinCo Revolving Cash Pool$35.00M88.60Common Law DebtExempt (QSTDI Safe Harbor)
T5: Perpetual / PIK Hybrid Benchmark$30.00M24.75Common Law EquityFails Gate 1 Before 1.385-3

The contrast between T2 and T5 illustrates the two-gate architecture. T5 (24.75) fails Gate 1 immediately because its PIK-toggle interest, deep subordination, and excessive leverage would never be accepted by an unrelated commercial bank under the Fin Hay Realty outside-lender test. Conversely, T2 (84.55) passes Gate 1 effortlessly as bona fide senior debt, yet still loses $45.00M of debt status at Gate 2 because of US HoldCo's subsequent cash distribution within 18 months.

Building an Audit-Ready Intercompany Debt File

Tax directors defending intercompany loans under common law should maintain four contemporaneous artifacts at issuance: (1) an executed promissory note with a fixed maturity date, default remedies, and market coupon benchmarked under Section 482; (2) a standalone debt-capacity study demonstrating leverage and interest-coverage headroom; (3) board resolutions documenting business purpose; and (4) bank wire confirmations proving timely cash interest payments rather than open-ended accruals.

Continue exploring the framework in Treas. Reg. 1.385-3 Funding Rule and the 36-Month Per Se Period and Section 385 Recharacterization: Withholding and Consolidation Risk.

Model your group's Section 385 exposure

Download the free 5-tab Section 385 Funding Rule Calculator or read the full practitioner guide in The Section 385 Debt vs Equity Handbook.

Read the handbook Get the Excel template

Related handbooks by Julian R. Sterling