Test whether it is a separate contract; if not, remeasure the liability at the rate of the modification date and adjust the right-of-use asset by the same amount.
A lease modification under ASC 842 is a change in the scope of or the consideration for a lease. If it grants an additional right of use priced at its standalone price, it is a separate contract. Otherwise the lessee remeasures the liability with its discount rate at the effective date, reassesses classification and, for an extension, adjusts the right-of-use asset by the change in the liability. A 36-month warehouse extension adds $699,494 to both.
Worked in full in The Lease Accounting Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
Free: the ASC 842 lease accounting model in Excel, with the liability, the right-of-use asset, a 240-month schedule, the entries and the classification tests.
A modification changes the contract: more or less space, a longer or shorter term negotiated now, a new rent. Exercising a renewal option already in the lease is not a modification, and neither is a CPI adjustment under an existing clause; they follow the rules on reassessment and on variable payments instead.
A modification is a separate contract only if both conditions hold: it grants an additional right of use not included in the original lease (more floor space, another machine), and the payments increase by an amount commensurate with the standalone price of that right. Extending the term of the same space is not an additional right of use, so an extension is never a separate contract.
| Modification | Liability | Right-of-use asset |
|---|---|---|
| Term extended, or more space not at standalone price | Remeasured at the new rate | Adjusted by the same amount; no gain or loss |
| Term shortened | Remeasured at the new rate | Reduced by the change; any excess over the asset in profit or loss |
| Less space (partial termination) | Remeasured at the new rate | Reduced proportionately; difference as a gain or loss |
| Full termination | Derecognized | Derecognized; gain or loss |
In every case the remaining consideration is reallocated, the classification is reassessed at the effective date, and index-based payments are remeasured at the index in effect on that date.
A fictional manufacturer leases a warehouse for 60 months from 1 January 2023 at $22,000 a month, adjusted each January to the CPI, discounted at 6.00%. On 1 January 2025, with 36 months left, it signs an amendment that extends the lease by 36 months to 31 December 2030. Rent stays at the indexed $23,408 until 2027, then is fixed at $25,500 for 2028 to 2030. Its incremental borrowing rate at that date is 7.25%.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Liability before (31 December 2024) | $726,778 |
| Remaining payments: 36 × $23,408 + 36 × $25,500 | $1,760,688 |
| Remeasured liability at 7.25% | $1,426,272 |
| Increase in liability and right-of-use asset | $699,494 |
Entry on 1 January 2025: debit right-of-use asset $699,494, credit lease liability $699,494. Nothing goes through the income statement on that date.
The new straight-line cost spreads the remaining payments plus the asset minus the liability over 72 months. Here the asset and the liability were equal before the modification, so the cost is simply $1,760,688 ÷ 72 = $24,454.00 a month, against $22,000 before.
The trap: the rent in effect on the modification date, $23,408, goes into the remeasured liability, so the CPI increases accumulated since commencement stop being variable lease cost in 2025. From 2026 the new index changes are variable cost again, measured against $23,408.
On 1 January 2026 the same company's board decides to stay in its headquarters after fitting out a laboratory there, which makes the first five-year renewal reasonably certain. Nothing in the contract changed, so this is a reassessment of the lease term, not a modification. The arithmetic is the same: the liability is remeasured at the new rate of 7.00% over 144 months, rising by $2,148,958 to $6,167,472, and the asset rises by the same amount. The monthly lease cost goes from $52,694.40 to $60,467.71.
Rules read on 17 November 2026, paraphrased, not quoted. The company and its leases are the fictional case of the book; rates are teaching assumptions, not market quotes. Not accounting advice.
A negotiated extension is a modification that is not a separate contract. Exercising a renewal option already in the lease is a reassessment of the term instead.
Yes, when it is not a separate contract: the lessee remeasures the liability with its discount rate at the effective date of the modification.
No. The right-of-use asset is adjusted by the same amount as the liability. Gains and losses arise on full or partial terminations.
Yes. Classification is reassessed at the effective date of a modification that is not a separate contract, using the facts at that date.
This article is one calculation from The Lease Accounting Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to lessee accounting under ASC 842 with IFRS 16 side by side: classification, discount rates, schedules, modifications, reassessments, impairment and the footnote, on one company and four leases.
DRM-free PDF, $19.99 · Paperback, $32.99, shipped worldwide · Free Excel model