The rate implicit in the lease if you can determine it, otherwise your incremental borrowing rate; a private company may elect a risk-free rate by class of asset.
Under ASC 842 a lessee discounts the lease payments at the rate implicit in the lease when that rate is readily determinable, and otherwise at its incremental borrowing rate: what it would pay to borrow, on a secured basis and over a similar term, an amount equal to the payments. A lessee that is not a public business entity may instead elect a risk-free rate, class by class. On a 120-month office lease starting at $50,000 a month, moving from a 6.50% borrowing rate to a 3.85% risk-free rate adds $670,426 to the liability.
Worked in full in The Lease Accounting Handbook by Julian R. Sterling.Get the DRM-free PDF, $19.99 →or the paperback
Free: the ASC 842 lease accounting model in Excel, with the liability, the right-of-use asset, a 240-month schedule, the entries and the classification tests.
The rate implicit in the lease comes first. It is the rate that makes the present value of the payments and of the residual value the lessor expects equal to the fair value of the asset plus the lessor's own initial direct costs. A lessee almost never knows the lessor's expected residual or its costs, so for real estate and most equipment the implicit rate is not readily determinable and the lessee moves on.
The incremental borrowing rate comes next. It is a lessee-specific rate: what the lessee would pay to borrow on a collateralized basis, over a term similar to the lease, an amount equal to the lease payments, in a similar economic environment. It is not the rate on the company's revolver, which is usually floating and short, nor the rate on an unsecured bond.
The risk-free rate is an option, not a fallback. Since ASU 2021-09, a lessee that is not a public business entity can elect it by class of underlying asset (real estate, vehicles, equipment) instead of for every lease at once. Even with the election, if the implicit rate of a given lease is readily determinable, the lessee uses that implicit rate.
Lease liability at commencement = Σ paymentk ÷ (1 + annual rate ÷ 12)k, k = 0 to n − 1, for monthly payments made in advance
A fictional manufacturer leases its headquarters for 120 months from 1 January 2023. Rent is $50,000 a month in the first year, up 3% each January, paid in advance. It paid a $45,000 leasing commission and received a $600,000 cash allowance from the landlord at commencement.
| Discount rate | Lease liability | Difference with 6.50% |
|---|---|---|
| 3.85% (risk-free rate election) | $5,666,492 | +$670,426 |
| 5.50% | $5,235,464 | +$239,398 |
| 6.50% (incremental borrowing rate) | $4,996,066 | $0 |
| 7.50% | $4,771,705 | −$224,361 |
At the 6.50% borrowing rate, day one is: debit right-of-use asset $4,441,066, debit cash $600,000 for the allowance received, credit lease liability $4,996,066, credit cash $45,000 for the commission. At the risk-free rate the asset would be $5,111,492.
The trap: a lower rate looks conservative because it raises the liability, but for an operating lease it changes nothing in the income statement. The straight-line cost is total payments plus initial direct costs minus incentives, divided by the term: $52,694.40 a month at any of the four rates. The rate only moves the balance sheet, and with it leverage ratios that count lease liabilities.
The same company leases a production machine for 60 months at $9,500 a month in advance, with a $40,000 residual value guarantee, a fair value of $520,000 and a remaining economic life of 72 months. Its incremental borrowing rate for that term and collateral is 7.50%.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Present value of the 60 payments | $477,064 |
| Present value of the full guarantee, discounted from month 60 | $27,524 |
| Total, against a fair value of $520,000 | $504,587 (97.0%) |
At 97.0% the machine is a finance lease. Because the test is a present value, a higher rate lowers the percentage: the rate you pick can decide which side of 90% a borderline lease lands on, and so whether its cost sits above or below EBITDA.
The rate set at commencement stays for the life of the lease unless the liability is remeasured for a reason that calls for a new rate: a change in the lease term (a renewal becoming reasonably certain), a reassessment of a purchase option, or a modification that is not a separate contract. Then the lessee uses its rate at that date. In the case of the book, the headquarters is remeasured on 1 January 2026 at 7.00% and the warehouse extension on 1 January 2025 at 7.25%. A change in an index such as the CPI does not, on its own, reopen the rate.
Rules read on 17 November 2026, paraphrased, not quoted. The company and its leases are the fictional case of the book; rates are teaching assumptions, not market quotes. Not accounting advice.
Not as it is. The incremental borrowing rate must be secured and match the lease term and amount; a floating, short revolver rate usually needs adjusting for term and collateral.
Lessees that are not public business entities. Since ASU 2021-09 the election is made by class of underlying asset, and a readily determinable implicit rate still takes precedence.
No. The straight-line operating lease cost is total payments plus initial direct costs minus incentives, spread over the term. The rate changes the liability, the asset and the accretion inside them.
No. It is updated only when the liability is remeasured for a term change, a purchase option reassessment or a modification that is not a separate contract.
This article is one calculation from The Lease Accounting Handbook, a practitioner’s guide to lessee accounting under ASC 842 with IFRS 16 side by side: classification, discount rates, schedules, modifications, reassessments, impairment and the footnote, on one company and four leases.
DRM-free PDF, $19.99 · Paperback, $32.99, shipped worldwide · Free Excel model