Free companion page

Companion page: The Vehicle Service Contract Professional

Free to print: Tool 4: Claims audit check-list ; The three formulas in words, from The Vehicle Service Contract Professional.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from The Vehicle Service Contract Professional by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Tool 4: Claims audit check-list

Use this list for a quarterly audit of paid claims. The case audit in June 2026 sampled 150 claims paid in the first half of 2026. Nine were paid outside the contract: wear items, a pre-existing failure, and a repair without the required authorization. That is 6 percent of the sample by count, and $7,380 was paid in error. The case does not project the sample to the whole book, and neither should a first audit.

Select the sample

  1. Define the population: claims paid in the period.
  2. Draw a sample large enough to see patterns, and include every large claim.
  3. Record the draw method so that the next audit can repeat it.

Test each claim

  1. Was the contract in force on the date of the failure?
  2. Is the failed part listed as covered, and is the cause outside every exclusion?
  3. Was the failure pre-existing? Look for earlier repair records.
  4. Is the item a wear item that the contract excludes?
  5. Was the repair authorized before work started, as the contract requires?
  6. Was the deductible applied once per repair visit?
  7. Do the parts, the labor time and the labor rate match the repair facility's estimate and the claims system's guide?
  8. Was an inspection done where the rules require one?
  9. Is the payment going to the repair facility or the holder as the contract provides, and is it not a duplicate?

Classify and fix

  1. Count the claims paid outside the contract and the dollars paid in error, as a rate of the sample by count and by dollars.
  2. Group the errors by cause. In the case the fixes were authorization rules in the claims system, inspection above $2,500, and a monthly repair-facility labor-time review.
  3. Name an owner and a date for each fix, and test again next quarter.
  4. Report to the claims director and the insurer's program manager, and do not call the result a rate for the book.

The three formulas in words

curve earned share = sum of the monthly curve shares for the months elapsed

pro rata earned share = months elapsed / 48

Rule of 78 earned share after n of 48 months = (48 + 47 + ... down to 49 - n) / 1,176

The Rule of 78 is a method that gives more of the amount to the early months. It is a fair way to describe interest on a loan but, as the case shows in Tool 5, a poor way to compute a refund when the contract discloses time as the measure.