Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a US Patent

Free to print: Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist, from How to Read a US Patent.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a US Patent by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist

Use this checklist with the document and its public record open side by side. Each question is one line, followed by a sentence on why it matters and the chapter that explains it. A question you cannot answer is a question for patent counsel, not a conclusion.

The Document and the Family (Questions 1 to 6)

  1. Is the document a granted patent or a published application? Only a grant carries claims that can be enforced, and the kind code on the front page tells you which one you hold. Chapter 2.
  2. Which database or copy are you reading, and is it the official record? A free copy can lag behind the official file, so confirm the text and the status where the Office publishes them. Chapter 1.
  3. Which other documents belong to the same family? Related filings can share one specification but carry different claims and different expiration dates. Chapter 8.
  4. Is any family member still pending? A pending application may still produce new claims, and nothing in it can be enforced until it is granted. Chapter 8.
  5. Is the text you are reading the original or a corrected version? A correction can change what a printed claim says, so look for one before you rely on the page. Chapter 11.
  6. Can you reach the full file history for each family member? The record behind a patent explains what the text alone cannot, and an incomplete pull hides part of the story. Chapter 1.

The Front Page (Questions 7 to 12)

  1. What are the patent number and the kind code? The number identifies the document and the code separates a grant from an application and from other kinds. Chapter 2.
  2. What is the date of patent, and how does it differ from the filing date? Several later clocks start from these dates, so mixing them up spoils every count that follows. Chapter 2.
  3. What does the related application data say? That block shows the benefit claims on which the family tree and the effective dates depend. Chapter 8.
  4. Who are the inventors, the applicant and the assignee named on the page? The names tell you where to start looking for title, but the recorded chain of ownership is the better evidence. Chapter 2.
  5. How is the invention classified? The classification places the patent in a technical neighborhood and helps you find related documents in the same field. Chapter 2.
  6. What references are listed as cited? The list shows the prior art the examiner and the applicant put on the record, which frames later arguments about scope. Chapter 2.

The Abstract, Drawings and Specification (Questions 13 to 18)

  1. What does the abstract say, and what does it leave out? The abstract is a short summary for searching and does not define the claims. Chapter 3.
  2. Do the drawings show each element that the claims recite? A claimed element with no counterpart in the figures deserves a closer look at the text. Chapter 3.
  3. Does the specification describe the invention in the same terms the claims use? The words in the claims draw their meaning from the description, so a mismatch is a warning sign. Chapter 4.
  4. Does the description show that the inventor had the full claimed scope in hand? A claim wider than the description supports invites a written description question. Chapter 4.
  5. Would a skilled reader be able to make and use the invention from the text? Enablement limits how far a claim can reach beyond what the document teaches. Chapter 5.
  6. Are the key claim terms clear enough to tell what is inside and outside the claim? Vague terms create uncertainty about scope, which a buyer notes as a question for patent counsel. Chapter 5.

The Claims and Their Construction (Questions 19 to 25)

  1. How many claims are there, and which are independent? The independent claims are the widest statements of the invention, and each dependent claim builds on one of them. Chapter 6.
  2. What does the preamble of each independent claim say? The preamble names the category of the invention and may or may not limit the claim. Chapter 6.
  3. Does the claim use an open transition or a closed one? Words such as comprising and consisting of change whether extra features escape the claim. Chapter 6.
  4. What does each dependent claim add? Dependent claims show fallback positions and hint at what the owner considers important. Chapter 6.
  5. Which claim terms would be disputed, and where does the document define them? A claim is read through its own words, the specification and the record, so a term with two plausible meanings matters. Chapter 7.
  6. Does any claim use means-plus-function language? Such a claim is tied to the structures the specification discloses, which can narrow it. Chapter 7.
  7. If you compare a product with a claim, what does the chart show, and which questions go to counsel? A claim chart organizes a reading exercise and never replaces an opinion. Chapter 7.

Priority and Term (Questions 26 to 31)

  1. What priority or benefit is claimed, and what is the effective filing date? That date sets the prior art against which the claims are measured. Chapter 8.
  2. Does each link in the chain of benefit claims hold together? A broken link can cost a claim its earlier date. Chapter 8.
  3. Is each family member a continuation, a divisional or a continuation-in-part? The type tells you whether the new filing adds subject matter or only reshapes the claims. Chapter 8.
  4. How is the expiration date counted, and from which date? The basic term runs from the earliest nonprovisional filing date to which benefit is claimed, not from a provisional. Chapter 9.
  5. What patent term adjustment is printed, and does the arithmetic make sense? The adjustment can move the expiration date by months or years, so it should tie to the record. Chapter 9.
  6. Is a terminal disclaimer on file, and what conditions does it carry? A disclaimer can cut the term short and can tie enforceability to common ownership. Chapter 9.

The File Wrapper (Questions 32 to 35)

  1. Which office actions were issued, and on what grounds? The rejections show which parts of the claims the examiner found difficult. Chapter 10.
  2. Which amendments and arguments did the applicant make in reply? Narrowing changes and statements can limit what a claim covers later. Chapter 10.
  3. Did the examiner state reasons for allowance, and does the notice of allowance say anything about scope? These statements show how the Office understood the claims at the end. Chapter 10.
  4. Is there any record of a challenge before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board, or only a proposal about how such challenges might change? A proposed rule is not a rule, so separate the two. Chapter 10.

After Grant: Corrections, Fees and Title (Questions 36 to 40)

  1. Has a certificate of correction issued, and what exactly did it change? The corrected text may differ from the printed patent, and the reason for the mistake matters. Chapter 11.
  2. Which maintenance fees have been paid, which are due next, and at what entity status? A missed fee ends the patent, and a change of entity status changes the amount. Chapter 11.
  3. Has every inventor assigned the invention, and has each assignment been recorded? A gap or a late recording clouds the chain of title. Chapter 11.
  4. Are any security interests or liens recorded, and does the deal require their release? A lender's recorded interest has to be cleared or accepted before a buyer takes clean title. Chapter 11.
  5. Does the current owner of record match the party selling or licensing, and do any ownership conditions in the file still hold? The seller must hold the title, and a terminal disclaimer can make one patent depend on another. Chapters 9 and 11.