Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a UK Pension Scheme Funding Valuation

Free to print: Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist, from How to Read a UK Pension Scheme Funding Valuation.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a UK Pension Scheme Funding Valuation by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist

Use this list when a valuation pack lands on the table. Each question points to the chapter that explains the answer. Work through the groups in order, or jump to the group that matches the document in front of you. A trustee may prefer to read the whole list once before the first meeting, and a finance director may prefer to start with the covenant and the recovery plan, because those groups touch the employer's cash most directly. The questions are for reading, not for advice: they help you see what a document says and what it leaves out.

The pack and the parties (questions 1 to 5)

  1. Which scheme, which employers and which trustee does the pack cover, and is every participating employer named? (Chapter 1)
  2. What is the effective date of the valuation, and has the trustee kept to the deadline for completing the documents? (Chapter 1)
  3. Which documents are in the pack, and which are still missing? List them against the set the chapters describe. (Chapter 1)
  4. Who signs each document: the trustee, the employer, the Scheme Actuary? Is every signature in the right place? (Chapter 1)
  5. Does the pack treat the funding code as the Regulator's expectation and the legislation as the legal rule, or does it blur the two? (Chapter 1)

Technical provisions and assumptions (questions 6 to 12)

  1. Which funding method is used, and does the report say plainly that it values benefits already earned? (Chapter 2)
  2. Who chose the assumptions, the trustees or the Scheme Actuary, and where is that choice recorded? (Chapter 2)
  3. Is the discount rate stated as a margin over a reference yield, and is the reference yield named? (Chapter 2)
  4. How much prudence does the table contain, and in which assumptions does it sit? (Chapter 2)
  5. What does the report say about the longevity assumption, and what happens to the liabilities if members live a year longer? (Chapter 2)
  6. Does the report show the sensitivity of the technical provisions to the discount rate? Can you find the reasoning behind the range shown? (Chapter 2)
  7. Are the technical provisions consistent with the funding and investment strategy, and does the document explain how? (Chapter 2)

The actuary and the statement of funding principles (questions 13 to 16)

  1. Is the Scheme Actuary's appointment and role set out, and does the actuary report to the trustees rather than to the employer? (Chapter 3)
  2. Which certificates and reports has the Scheme Actuary given, and does each one cover what it claims to cover? (Chapter 3)
  3. Does the statement of funding principles state how the trustees will meet the statutory funding objective, and was it updated for this valuation? (Chapter 3)
  4. Does the pack include the actuary's estimate of solvency, and is the basis of that estimate stated? (Chapter 3)

Strategy, low dependency and maturity (questions 17 to 22)

  1. What is the relevant date, and who decided it? Does the pack show the working behind it? (Chapter 4)
  2. How is significant maturity measured, and what duration of liabilities does the actuary project at the relevant date? (Chapter 4)
  3. What funding level does the strategy target at the relevant date, and on which basis is it measured? (Chapter 4)
  4. What low dependency investment allocation does the strategy describe, and how does the hedge ratio compare with it? (Chapter 4)
  5. Does the journey plan show how the scheme moves from today's assets towards the allocation at the relevant date? (Chapter 4)
  6. Which parts of the strategy are legal requirements and which are the Regulator's expectations? (Chapter 4)

The statement of strategy (questions 23 to 25)

  1. Does Part 1 of the statement of strategy match the funding and investment strategy the trustees agreed? (Chapter 5)
  2. Do the Part 2 entries explain how the strategy is being implemented and what the main risks are? (Chapter 5)
  3. What does the Regulator receive with the statement, and is the route chosen, Fast Track or bespoke, stated and supported by evidence? (Chapter 5)

Covenant (questions 26 to 30)

  1. Who prepared the covenant assessment, and does the report keep reported results apart from forecasts? (Chapter 6)
  2. What reliability period does the report use, and why does it stop where it does? (Chapter 6)
  3. What covenant longevity does the report adopt, and what supports that view? (Chapter 6)
  4. How much cash is available after operating costs and committed finance, and what else competes for it? (Chapter 6)
  5. Are contingent assets listed, valued and discounted, and is the discount explained? Does the pack record any covenant leakage? (Chapter 6)

Recovery plan (questions 31 to 34)

  1. How long is the recovery plan, and what options did the trustees and the employer compare? (Chapter 7)
  2. Does the plan rest on a reasonable affordability judgement, and where is the evidence for it? (Chapter 7)
  3. Is any allowance for investment outperformance stated, and how much of the plan relies on it? (Chapter 7)
  4. How will the plan be tested once the next actuarial report shows post-valuation experience? (Chapter 7)

Schedule of contributions and payments (questions 35 to 37)

  1. Does the schedule of contributions show the amount, the due date and the payee for each contribution? (Chapter 8)
  2. Are the employer's separate payments, such as administration expenses, shown apart from deficit repair contributions? (Chapter 8)
  3. What is the process for a missed or late payment: who records it, who is told and when? (Chapter 8)

Timetable, corporate events and surplus (questions 38 to 40)

  1. Do the signing dates fit the timetable, and what happens if agreement is not reached in time? (Chapter 9)
  2. Does the pack say how the trustees will hear of a dividend, a disposal or another corporate event, and what that could mean for a notifiable event or a section 75 debt? (Chapter 10)
  3. If the scheme moves into surplus, what is stated about its use, and which of the surplus and superfund rules are in force? (Chapter 11)

How to use the list

Mark each question as answered, partly answered or open. Write a short note beside each open one, saying who you will ask and when you expect an answer. An open question is a question for the Scheme Actuary, the covenant adviser or the employer, not a conclusion about the pack. Chapter 12 shows the whole sequence on one worked case, if you want to see the questions answered in context. Keep the marked list with your papers, so that the next valuation starts from what this one left open, and so that a new trustee joining the board can see at a glance which points the board has already settled.