Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a UK Government Model Services Contract

Free to print: Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist, from How to Read a UK Government Model Services Contract.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a UK Government Model Services Contract by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist

These forty questions are for a filled-in contract, not for the blank model. Many figures in the model sit in square brackets for the buyer to complete, so the answers are found in the Front Sheet, in the Schedules the buyer actually kept and in the Financial Model. A supplier can use the list to price risk before a bid or to prepare the delivery team after award. Where a question has no clear answer in the signed text, treat that gap as a point to raise with the other side before the contract is relied on. A buyer can use it to check that the contract says what the buyer meant. Each question ends with the chapter that explains the point.

Architecture and the Front Sheet

  1. Which version of the Model Services Contract is this contract built on, and is it the England and Wales edition used by central government in England? (Chapter 1)
  2. Which Front Sheet entries, Core Terms and Schedules has the buyer changed, deleted or replaced, and where are those changes recorded so that you read the contract as signed and not the blank model? (Chapter 1)
  3. Does the Procurement Act 2023 apply to this contract in full, or is it a framework call-off, a Scottish, Welsh or Northern Irish contract, or a different template that needs another reading? (Chapter 1)
  4. Has the Authority published, or does the timetable show that it will publish, the contract details notice and, where the contract is large enough, a copy of the contract? (Chapter 1)
  5. Is every section of the Front Sheet completed (parties, particulars, security, commercially sensitive information, notified sub-contractors, third party contracts, software, resolution planning, staff transfer, key personnel, IPR, notices and signatures), or does a blank remain on which the contract depends? (Chapter 2)

Implementation and KPIs

  1. Are the Term, any Extension Period and the length of implementation stated, and do the Contract Years run from the Effective Date as the Charges and the caps assume? (Chapter 2)
  2. Which Milestones are Key Milestones, and what must the Supplier show for each one to be Achieved? (Chapter 2)
  3. How is the daily Delay Payment Rate set, how does it change with the notice the Supplier gives, and exactly how is that notice counted? (Chapter 2)
  4. When does the Delay Deduction Period end, and what may the Authority do once it has ended? (Chapter 2)
  5. What counts as an Authority Cause, how quickly must the Supplier claim relief, and what may the Supplier recover? (Chapters 2 and 10)
  6. Which KPIs are set, what does each one measure, and where is the KPI Service Threshold for each? (Chapter 3)
  7. How do Service Points turn into Service Credits, what does a Repeat KPI Failure do to the points, and from which invoice are the credits deducted? (Chapter 3)
  8. On what base is the Service Credit Cap calculated in each part of the term, and do Service Points keep accruing once the cap is reached? Which events count as an Unacceptable KPI Failure or a Critical Performance Failure? (Chapter 3)

Money

  1. Which payments are Service Charges, which are Milestone Payments, and what is outside the Charges? Is VAT added on top? (Chapter 4)
  2. When must the Authority pay a valid invoice, what happens to a disputed amount, and what is the notice needed before the Authority holds back or sets off a sum? (Chapter 4)
  3. What happens to an invoice that the Authority does not check in time, and what interest runs on undisputed sums paid late? (Chapter 4)
  4. How long is the Non-Indexation Period, when is the first adjustment, which index is named, and which index replaces it if it ceases? (Chapter 4)
  5. What Open Book Data must the Supplier provide, how does it tie to the Financial Model, and for how long are the records kept? (Chapter 4)
  6. Which Allowable Assumptions did the Supplier price on, how are they tested after signature, and when does a Benchmark Review apply and who bears its cost? (Chapter 4)

Change and distress

  1. Who may start a Change Request, how long does each side have for the Impact Assessment and the decision, and which changes are Operational Changes and which are Contract Changes? (Chapter 5)
  2. What profit margin is allowed in a priced change, how does it relate to the Anticipated Contract Life Profit Margin and the Maximum Permitted Profit Margin, and what open book support is needed? (Chapter 5)
  3. How does the contract separate General Change in Law from Specific Change in Law, and what relief is denied for a change that could have been foreseen? (Chapter 5)
  4. Is there a limit on how far this public contract may be modified, and has the Authority allowed for the publication of a change before it takes effect? (Chapter 5)
  5. Which Financial Distress Events are listed, whose finances are tested (the Supplier, the guarantor or both), at what thresholds, and what meetings and plans follow? (Chapter 6)
  6. Which Key Sub-contractors are named, what may the Authority object to, do the payment terms reach down the supply chain, and how does the Supplier Code of Conduct apply? (Chapter 6)

IP and data

  1. Which of the five intellectual property options did the buyer choose in the Front Sheet, who owns Project Specific IPRs and Specially Written Software, and what licence does each side hold in the other's material? (Chapter 7)
  2. How is the IPR indemnity treated against the liability caps, and does the choice of option change what the Authority may do with the software after the contract ends? (Chapters 7 and 9)
  3. Who is Controller, Processor, joint controller or independent controller for each set of personal data, how are sub-processors handled, and is the Schedule that fixes these roles filled in? (Chapter 8)
  4. Is security assurance led by the Authority or by the Supplier, how are backups, restoration and incident notice dealt with, and who pays? (Chapter 8)

Liability and remedies

  1. Which losses are unlimited, and which caps apply to Authority property, to Government Data, to general Defaults and to abandonment, wilful breach of a fundamental term or wilful repudiatory breach? Are the bracketed figures filled in? (Chapter 9)
  2. Does the Service Credit Cap sit inside or beside the general cap, which kinds of loss are excluded, and which are expressly recoverable? (Chapter 9)
  3. What insurance is required under the insurance Schedule, in what amounts, and how must the Supplier show that it is in place? (Chapter 9)
  4. How quickly must the Supplier deliver a Rectification Plan, even when the Supplier disputes the cause, and how is a Remedial Adviser chosen? Does an appointment pause the right to terminate? (Chapter 10)
  5. What triggers a Step-In Notice, how are the Charges adjusted while it runs, who bears whose costs, and when is a Step-Out Plan due? (Chapter 10)

Termination and exit

  1. On what notice may the Authority terminate for convenience, and how is any Compensation Payment worked out and limited? What must be published after a termination? (Chapter 11)
  2. Which Supplier Termination Events are listed, and what rights does the Supplier have if the Authority fails to pay? (Chapter 11)
  3. How are the Breakage Costs Payment and the unrecovered amount calculated, and is the settlement final? (Chapter 11)
  4. When is the Exit Plan delivered, how often is it updated, and when does the final version fall due? (Chapter 11)
  5. How long may the Termination Assistance Period run, how are Termination Services charged, and who is in scope for a transfer of staff? (Chapter 11)
  6. Have you walked a year of the contract through the worked case, using your own filled-in figures for a delay, a poor quarter, a change, a default and an exit? (Chapter 12)