This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Title V Air Operating Permit by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Appendix A: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist
Keep this list beside the permit on the first read. Each question ends with the chapter that answers it. The questions run in the order a permit is usually read: the document, then the plant, then the duties that follow from it. Some are answered by a single page of the permit, others only by the permit together with the plant's own logs, so mark each question as answered, open or not applicable. Where a question names the case, the figures belong to Harnley Specialty Chemicals, Inc. and its fictional plant, Corriemoor Works, and are teaching assumptions.
The Document and Its Basis
- Which agency issued the permit, under which program (a state program approved under Part 70 or the federal program under Part 71), and what are the issue and expiration dates? A permit read without its issue and expiration dates cannot be placed in its renewal cycle. (Chapter 1)
- Is there a statement of basis, fact sheet or technical support document, and does it explain choices that the permit leaves unexplained? Remember that it informs the reader but is not itself enforceable. (Chapter 1)
- How is the permit organized: general conditions, site-wide conditions, unit-by-unit conditions, attachments and tables? Where does a condition sit that applies to several units at once? (Chapter 1)
- Which role at the permittee signs applications, reports and certifications, and does the permit file name that role as the responsible official? Compare the signer's title with the definition of responsible official in 40 CFR 70.2. (Chapter 7)
Applicability
- Which pollutant, if any, makes the site a major source, and is the source's potential to emit stated in a way you can trace back to unit-level figures? (Chapter 2)
- Are hazardous air pollutants tested both one by one and in total, and which test does the plant approach most closely? In the case, methanol is the pollutant to watch, so the single-pollutant test matters more than the total. (Chapter 2)
- Does the plant avoid major-source status for any pollutant through an enforceable limit, and if so which limit holds it there? (Chapter 2)
- Does the stated potential to emit reflect the worst-case fuel and operating scenario, for example a backup fuel burned all year? The Corriemoor Works boiler B-2 is the example, since oil all year is the worst case. (Chapter 2)
- Does the application or the statement of basis show the arithmetic behind each potential to emit figure, so that a reader can rebuild it from the unit table? (Chapter 2)
Units and Limits
- Does every emission unit at the plant appear in the unit table, with identifiers that match the plant's own drawings, logs and past permits? A unit missing from the table is a unit with no stated conditions. (Chapter 3)
- For each limit, can you name the pollutant, the unit, the averaging period and the unit of measure without leaving the condition? (Chapter 3)
- Does each condition cite the rule or approval it comes from, and can you tell which limits are federally enforceable and which are state-only? (Chapter 3)
- Which operating scenarios or alternative fuels does the permit allow, and how must the plant record a switch between them? Write down the allowed fuels and the record that shows which one was burned. (Chapter 3)
Applicable Requirements
- Which preconstruction permits carry conditions into the Title V permit, and are those conditions copied in or only referred to? (Chapter 4)
- Which state plan rules apply to which units, and does the permit say where each rule starts and stops? (Chapter 4)
- Which federal standards (Part 60, Part 61 or Part 63) apply, and is each tied to a unit, a compliance date and a monitoring method? A standard without a compliance date is hard to audit. (Chapter 4)
- Has anyone compared the permit with rules that took effect after it was issued, including any recent change to the definition of applicable requirement? (Chapter 4)
Monitoring and Testing
- For each limit, does the monitoring in the permit match the limit's averaging period, or is there a gap between what is measured and what is limited? A monthly record cannot prove a limit that is written as an hourly average. (Chapter 5)
- Where the permit adds periodic monitoring, what exactly is it, and does the statement of basis explain why? (Chapter 5)
- Does compliance assurance monitoring apply to any unit, and if so what are the indicator, the indicator range and the averaging time? (Chapter 5)
- What counts as an excursion, what response does the permit require, and what event triggers a quality improvement plan? In the case, the trigger is stated as a share of operating time in a reporting period. (Chapter 5)
- Where continuous monitors are required, what data capture and calibration duties come with them? (Chapter 5)
- Which emission factors, test methods and test schedules sit behind each limit, and does the permit name the source of every factor? (Chapter 6)
Records, Reports and Certification
- What records must the plant keep, in what form, and for how long? Could the operating logs actually produce them? A record that exists only in a supervisor's memory does not count. (Chapter 7)
- When is each semiannual monitoring report due, which months does it cover, and who must sign it? (Chapter 7)
- How does the permit define a deviation, and which kinds must be reported sooner than the next semiannual report? Note whether the permit sets its own definition or points to a rule. (Chapter 7)
- When is the annual compliance certification due, and to which offices does it go, including the EPA regional office? (Chapter 7)
- On what basis does the responsible official certify each condition as met continuously or intermittently, and who gathers that evidence? The certification is only as strong as the files behind it. (Chapter 7)
The Permit Shield
- Does the permit contain a shield, and is it express rather than assumed? (Chapter 8)
- Which non-applicability determinations does the permit list in writing, and what facts about each unit support them? In the case, there are four written determinations, and each rests on a stated fact about a unit. (Chapter 8)
- What falls outside the shield, such as later modifications, and what can the agency reopen despite it? (Chapter 8)
Changing the Plant
- Which changes may the plant make without any permit revision, and what notice and records does the permit require for each? Keep the notice and the record together, because the next application must list the change. (Chapter 9)
- Which changes need an administrative amendment, which a minor modification and which a significant modification? (Chapter 9)
- Who must be notified of a proposed change, and how long does the review clock run before the plant may act? Mark the dates on a calendar the day the application is filed. (Chapter 9)
- After a change, which conditions, records and tables must be updated so that the permit still matches the plant? (Chapter 9)
Renewal and Review
- When does the renewal application window open and close, and has the plant filed a timely, complete application to keep the right to operate while the agency reviews it? In the case, the window opens in Year 4 and closes in Year 5, ahead of the expiration in Year 6. (Chapter 10)
- For what reasons may the agency or the EPA reopen the permit before it expires? (Chapter 10)
- What public notice and comment steps apply to a draft permit, and where can a reader find the public file? Comments made at this stage can shape the final text. (Chapter 10)
- If the EPA does not object to a proposed permit, who may petition the EPA to object, and by when? (Chapter 10)
Enforcement, Fees and Transactions
- What emergency provisions does the permit contain, how is the annual fee calculated, and which of these items would a buyer or lender collect before closing: recent reports, certifications, notices of violation and pending applications? In the case, the buyer and the lender both ask for these items before the closing in Year 4. (Chapter 11, with the full case in Chapter 12)