Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Third-Party Logistics Agreement

Free to print: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any 3PL Agreement, from How to Read a Third-Party Logistics Agreement.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Third-Party Logistics Agreement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any 3PL Agreement

A draft agreement lands on the desk on a Monday morning: a master agreement, a statement of work, a rate card and a thick set of operating procedures. There is one afternoon to read it before the call with the provider. The temptation is to read the rates closely and skim the rest.

The case shows why that would be a mistake. In Month 19, a sprinkler failure the case attributes to Corbridge's negligence destroys 400 pallets worth $1,176,000 at cost. The liability clause, a single sentence few people would linger over, caps Corbridge's liability at $0.50 per pound of the goods lost. The pallets weighed 200,000 pounds, so Corbridge's liability stops at $100,000. Larchway could have declared a higher value in writing and paid $0.10 per $100 of declared value per month; on the average stock of 912.5 pallets, that would have cost about $32,193 a year. The difference between those outcomes was decided at signing, in a clause that sits far from the rate card.

The forty questions below broadly follow the order of this book, with insurance read just after liability. Each one points to the chapter that explains it. They are not a substitute for counsel, and they do not say what to accept: they make sure nothing is left unread.

The documents and the scope

Start with the structure. Before any number is worth reading, a reader needs to know which document controls, what is in scope and what each side has actually promised about volume.

  1. Which document prevails when the master agreement, the statement of work, the rate card and the operating procedures conflict?

Where to look: Chapter 1.

  1. Can the operating procedures be changed by the provider alone, and do changes bind the shipper without a signed amendment?

Where to look: Chapter 1.

  1. Are all amendments, rate letters and side emails that change terms listed and attached, so that the full contract can be assembled in one place?

Where to look: Chapter 1.

  1. Which channels, products, sites and services are in scope, and which are expressly left out?

Where to look: Chapter 2.

  1. Is the volume forecast a commitment by the shipper, an estimate for planning, or a capacity commitment by the provider?

Where to look: Chapter 2.

  1. What happens to rates, space and labor if actual volumes run well above or below the forecast?

Where to look: Chapter 2.

  1. How much notice must the shipper give of a peak, a promotion or a new product, and what does a late forecast cost?

Where to look: Chapter 2.

Service levels and credits

Service levels turn the provider's promises into measurable targets. The questions here test whether the targets are defined tightly enough to be measured, and whether the remedy bears any relation to the cost of a miss.

  1. Is each key performance indicator defined with its formula, its measurement period and its source of data?

Where to look: Chapter 3.

  1. Who measures performance, who can audit the measurement, and what happens when the two sides' figures disagree?

Where to look: Chapter 3.

  1. How is each service credit calculated, on which fees, and is there a monthly cap?

    Where to look: Chapter 3.

  2. Are service credits the shipper's only money remedy for missed service levels?

    Where to look: Chapter 3.

  3. Does the agreement define chronic failure, and does it let the shipper terminate without paying a fee?

    Where to look: Chapter 3.

  4. Are there events, such as forecast misses or late inbound shipments, that excuse the provider from its targets?

    Where to look: Chapter 3.

Rates, minimums and price changes

The rate card is where most readers start, and it deserves the attention. The questions below look beyond the headline rates to the units of charge, the minimum and the rules that move prices over the term.

  1. Is every rate tied to a clear unit of charge, such as pallet, order, unit, carton, hour or square foot?

    Where to look: Chapter 4.

  2. Which accessorial charges can be billed, and is any service priced on quote rather than on the rate card?

    Where to look: Chapter 4.

  3. Is there a minimum monthly charge, what fees count toward it, and is freight inside or outside it?

    Where to look: Chapter 4.

  4. Does the minimum rise with the rates at each adjustment, and does any fee depend on it?

    Where to look: Chapter 4.

  5. What index or formula drives annual price changes, and is there a cap on each increase?

    Where to look: Chapter 5.

  6. Can the provider pass through cost increases outside the annual adjustment, and on how much notice?

    Where to look: Chapter 5.

  7. If a cost-plus model is offered, what costs are included, what management fee applies, and what audit rights come with it?

    Where to look: Chapter 5.

  8. When are invoices issued and due, how long does the shipper have to dispute a line, and can disputed amounts be withheld?

    Where to look: Chapter 5.

Liability, inventory and insurance

This is the part of the agreement the case put to its hardest test. A cap of $0.50 per pound turned a $1,176,000 loss into a $100,000 claim. The questions below follow the same chain: standard of care, cap, declared value, counts, insurance.

  1. What standard of care does the provider accept for the goods in its custody?

    Where to look: Chapter 6.

  2. Is liability capped by weight, by item or by event, and what would the cap produce on a full pallet of your heaviest and most valuable product?

    Where to look: Chapter 6.

  3. Can the shipper declare a higher value, how must it be declared, and what is the valuation charge?

    Where to look: Chapter 6.

  4. Does the agreement or its warehouse receipt set any time limit or notice rule for presenting a loss claim?

    Where to look: Chapter 6.

  5. How often is inventory counted, by cycle counts and by full physical count, and is counting included in the fees?

    Where to look: Chapter 7.

  6. What is the shrinkage allowance measured on, and are gains netted against losses?

    Where to look: Chapter 7.

  7. How are missing units valued, and who decides the cost when the figures differ?

    Where to look: Chapter 7.

  8. Who insures the stored goods, and does the shipper's own property policy cover goods held by a third party?

    Where to look: Chapter 9.

  9. Do the provider's policy limits respond to its contractual liability, and has either party waived subrogation?

    Where to look: Chapter 9.

Transportation and systems

Freight and data both sit at the edge of the warehouse, and both are easy to overlook. The first decides a large part of the total logistics cost; the second decides whether the shipper can leave.

  1. In what role does the provider act for each flow of goods: warehouse, motor carrier or broker?

    Where to look: Chapter 8.

  2. Is freight a pass-through at cost, or does the provider add a markup, and on which charges does it apply?

    Where to look: Chapter 8.

  3. Who files freight claims, within what contractual deadline, and who pays if a late filing loses the claim?

    Where to look: Chapter 8.

  4. Has any carrier contract that covers the shipper's goods waived the shipper's rights in writing?

    Where to look: Chapter 8.

  5. Who owns the inventory and order data in the warehouse management system, and how long does portal access last?

    Where to look: Chapter 9.

Liens, termination and exit

The end of the relationship is where unread clauses become expensive. The last five questions test how the shipper gets its goods and its data out, and at what price.

  1. Is the warehouse lien limited to charges on the goods held, or does it reach all charges, including goods already shipped?

    Where to look: Chapter 10.

  2. Does the agreement add a security interest in the inventory, and does any lender's access agreement limit the lien?

    Where to look: Chapter 10.

  3. On what grounds and notice can each party terminate, and how is any early termination fee calculated?

    Where to look: Chapter 10.

  4. What holdover charge applies to goods left after the end date, and can disputed invoices hold the stock?

    Where to look: Chapter 10.

  5. Does the transition plan require the provider to keep shipping, perform a closing count and deliver the data in a usable format?

    Where to look: Chapter 10.

Using the forty questions

The questions work best in a single pass, in order, with a pen. Mark each one answered, unanswered or answered against you, and write the clause number beside it. An unanswered question is not always a problem, but it is always a conversation to have before signing, not after.

Then sort the open points into three groups. The first group holds questions the documents simply fail to answer, such as a missing definition of a service level or a silent insurance clause; these usually call for a sentence of drafting. The second group holds answers that exist but carry a cost, such as a minimum charge or a freight markup; these call for a number, run on your own volumes. The third group holds answers that shift a large risk, such as a per-pound cap or a general lien; these call for a decision, often with the insurer or the lender in the room.

Run the money questions on your own figures. The case shows the method: a per-pound cap read on the weight of a real loss, a valuation charge read against the stock it protects. A shipper, a provider, a lender and a buyer will weight the questions differently, and each will find some of them more pressing than others. All four should be able to answer every one from the documents on the desk. Chapter 11 shows how the answers combine over the life of one contract.

Key Takeaway: Forty questions cover the documents, the service levels, the rates, the liability chain, transportation, data and the exit. In the case, one sentence capped Corbridge's liability at $100,000 on a $1,176,000 loss, when declaring full value would have cost about $32,193 a year. Read every clause against your own numbers before the agreement is signed.