Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Third-Party Legal Opinion

Free to print: How to use the checklist, from How to Read a Third-Party Legal Opinion.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Third-Party Legal Opinion by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

How to use the checklist

The forty questions follow the order in which most opinion letters are built: introduction and role of counsel, documents examined, assumptions and reliance on certificates, the opinions themselves, exceptions and qualifications, covered law, and the reliance and date paragraph. A reader can therefore keep the draft open on one side and move down both at once.

Three habits make the list useful. First, read the support before the opinions: an opinion paragraph is only as strong as the definitions, assumptions and schedules beneath it. Second, write the answer to each question next to it, even when the answer is simply yes; a blank tells the reader later that the point was never checked. Third, separate questions of drafting from questions of substance. A loose phrase can usually be fixed in a comment; a missing schedule or an opinion assumed away needs a conversation with the giver.

In the book's case, the agent's counsel at Fenwray LLP would run this list on the draft letters from Pellingham & Vane LLP and Quillan Rowe PLLC before advising Merrowgate Bank, N.A. and the other lenders. A reader on the giver's side can use the same list in reverse, to see the letter as the recipient will.

Time is the constraint, so the list also suggests a triage. With an hour, a reader would spend the first part on questions 7 to 14, because a weak assumption or a missing certificate can empty several opinions at once. Next come questions 25 to 32, because schedules, orders and collateral descriptions are where gaps hide in plain sight. Questions 1 to 6 and 33 to 37 take less time but decide who can use the letter and how far it reaches. The entity and remedies questions, 15 to 24, are often the most familiar, and in many drafts they need the least work. Questions 38 to 40 apply only when a registration statement is involved.

When two letters arrive together, as in the book's case, the reader runs the list once for each letter and then once more across both. The cross-check is short but important: does each opinion the recipient needs appear in one letter or the other, under the right law, and does each letter assume only what the other actually covers?

The checklist is a reading aid, not legal advice. It does not say what an opinion must contain or what a recipient should accept; it says where a careful reader looks.