This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Tender Offer by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Tender Offer
Before anyone relies on an Offer to Purchase and a Schedule 14D-9, to price a position, to brief a board, to answer a holder's call or to sign off a filing, there should be one last pass through the documents. This chapter is that pass: forty questions, in the order a careful reader meets the issues, each followed by the reason it matters and the chapter that explains it.
The questions are written for any tender offer, not only for Varnley's. Some will not apply to a given deal: a cash offer has no prospectus, an offer for all shares has no proration, and a negotiated deal has no hostile defenses to read. A question that does not apply should still be asked, so that the reader knows why it does not.
The questions are grouped in eight sections. Use them as a working list: write the answer and the page reference next to each one, and treat any question left blank as an open point rather than a minor gap.
The documents (questions 1 to 5)
- Which documents make up the offer, and have you read each one, including the exhibits to the Schedule TO? Why it matters: the Offer to Purchase is only one exhibit, and the letter of transmittal, the summary advertisement and the agreements filed with it can change how it reads (chapter 1).
- Who is the bidder, who is the purchaser, and how are they related? Why it matters: the entity that buys the shares is often an acquisition subsidiary, and the parent's role determines whose cash, promises and obligations stand behind the offer (chapter 1).
- Does the summary term sheet agree with the numbered sections behind it? Why it matters: the summary is what most holders read, and any gap between it and the full text is a point to raise with the information agent (chapter 1).
- Who are the depositary and the information agent, and how does a holder who owns through a broker actually tender? Why it matters: most holders tender electronically through their broker, whose own cut-off can fall before the expiration stated in the offer (chapter 1).
- Has any document been amended since the offer commenced, and what changed? Why it matters: amendments to the Schedule TO carry extensions, results and new terms, and a reader working from the first version can miss them (chapters 1 and 2).
Price, consideration and the CVR (6 to 11)
- What exactly is paid per share, in what form, and is it net of withholding taxes and without interest? Why it matters: the headline price and the amount a holder receives can differ, and the form of payment decides which other questions follow (chapter 2).
- Against which unaffected price is the premium measured? Why it matters: the premium depends entirely on the reference price chosen, so the reader confirms which trading day it reflects (chapter 2).
- If part of the price is a CVR, what milestone triggers it and by what deadline? Why it matters: a CVR pays only on its own defined event, within its own period, and nothing otherwise (chapter 7).
- What efforts does the buyer promise toward the milestone, and how does the CVR agreement define them? Why it matters: after closing the buyer controls the product, and the efforts definition is the main protection the CVR holders keep (chapter 7).
- Can the CVR be transferred or traded, and who can enforce it? Why it matters: a right that cannot be sold or enforced directly by its holder is a different asset from a listed security (chapter 7).
- Do the sources of funds cover the total cash needed, and where will any later payment come from? Why it matters: the uses and sources in the source and amount of funds section should reconcile line by line, and any deferred payment rests on the payer's position at the time it falls due (chapter 7).
Timetable and extensions (12 to 16)
- When does the offer expire, stated to the minute and in Eastern time? Why it matters: the expiration fixes the last moment to tender or withdraw, and brokers set their deadlines before it (chapter 2).
- Under what circumstances must, or may, the purchaser extend the offer? Why it matters: an extension duty in the merger agreement turns a missed condition into a delay rather than a failure, up to the outside date (chapters 2 and 3).
- How will an extension be announced, and when? Why it matters: the announcement tells holders the new expiration and the shares tendered so far, which is often the first public evidence of how the offer is going (chapter 2).
- Will there be a subsequent offering period, and does the offer say so? Why it matters: whether holders get a further window after acceptance changes the choices of a holder who has not yet tendered (chapter 2).
- When will the depositary pay for accepted shares? Why it matters: the payment date, not the expiration, is the date that sets a holder's real return and an arbitrage analyst's annualized figure (chapters 2 and 9).
Conditions (17 to 22)
- What is the minimum condition, and how is it counted? Why it matters: the reader needs the exact count, including whether shares delivered by guaranteed delivery count before they reach the depositary (chapter 3).
- Which regulatory approvals are conditions, and what is their status? Why it matters: an antitrust or other approval still pending is often the condition that sets the actual timetable (chapter 3).
- How is the no material adverse effect condition drafted, and at what moment is it tested? Why it matters: the definition and the testing date decide what kind of bad news would allow the purchaser to walk away (chapter 3).
- Is there a financing condition, and if not, what does the offer say about the bidder's financial condition? Why it matters: the absence of a financing condition and the statement about the bidder's financial statements rest on facts the reader can check (chapters 3 and 7).
- What is the outside date, and can it be extended? Why it matters: the outside date caps how long the purchaser must keep extending, and so how long a tendering holder's shares can be tied up (chapter 3).
- Which conditions can the purchaser waive alone, and which need the target's consent? Why it matters: a condition the purchaser can waive gives it flexibility, while one it cannot waive alone is a firm protection for the target and its holders (chapter 3).
The second step (23 to 26)
- Does the offer state that a second-step merger will follow, and under which provision of Delaware law? Why it matters: the statute named tells the reader whether a stockholder vote is needed after the offer, and so how quickly untendered shares are converted (chapter 4).
- What do untendered shares receive in the merger, and is it the same consideration as in the offer? Why it matters: holders who do not tender need to know what their shares become, and whether waiting changes the amount (chapters 4 and 9).
- How and by when can a holder demand appraisal? Why it matters: appraisal replaces the merger consideration with a value set by a court, and only holders who follow the steps exactly keep that right (chapter 4).
- What happens to the listing of the shares after the merger? Why it matters: delisting ends any market for the shares, which matters to anyone who expected to keep trading them (chapter 4).
The target's response (27 to 31)
- What does the board recommend, and was the decision unanimous? Why it matters: the recommendation is the heart of the Schedule 14D-9, and any dissent or abstention is a point to note (chapter 5).
- What does the background section say about how the price was reached and who else was approached? Why it matters: the sequence of proposals and contacts shows what alternatives the board explored before agreeing (chapter 5).
- Which reasons does the board give, and which factors against does it list? Why it matters: a fair reading weighs both lists, since the board itself names the risks it accepted (chapter 5).
- What opinion did the target's financial adviser deliver, and on what day? Why it matters: the opinion is part of what the board relied on, and the reader notes it without redoing the analysis (chapter 5).
- What do directors and officers receive, and who approved it? Why it matters: payments to insiders, and the independence of those who approved them, are read against the rules on equal treatment of holders (chapters 5 and 6).
Holder protections (32 to 36)
- Until when can tendered shares be withdrawn, and how? Why it matters: withdrawal rights let a holder change course while the offer is open, and the procedure must be followed exactly (chapter 6).
- Is the offer open to all holders of the class on the same terms? Why it matters: the all holders and best price rules shape who may tender and what each must receive (chapter 6).
- Does any agreement with a holder, a director or an officer look like extra payment for shares? Why it matters: the reader checks how such arrangements are described and approved, because equal price is a core protection (chapter 6).
- Are there tender and support agreements, with whom, and when do they end? Why it matters: committed shares move the minimum condition closer, and their termination terms tell the reader whether that support can fall away (chapters 5 and 11).
- Does the offer forbid or describe purchases outside the offer while it is open? Why it matters: buying outside the offer on different terms would undercut the equal treatment the offer promises (chapter 6).
Issuer, fund and mini-tender offers (37 to 40)
- In an issuer offer, how is the price set, and what is the order of acceptance under proration? Why it matters: in a Dutch auction the holders' tenders set the price, and odd lots, conditional tenders and proration decide how many shares each holder sells (chapter 8).
- In a fund repurchase offer, when is the net asset value fixed, and does any early repurchase deduction apply? Why it matters: a holder may decide before the price is known and receive less than the gross amount, depending on how long the shares were held (chapter 8).
- In a partial offer, does the tendering holder own what it tenders, net of any short position? Why it matters: the net long position rule bars tendering more than one owns to beat proration (chapter 9).
- For any offer that seeks a small slice of a class, how does its price compare with the market, can shares be withdrawn, and has anything been filed with the SEC? Why it matters: mini-tenders are often priced below the market without saying so, and their terms can leave a holder unable to undo a tender (chapter 10).
On the reading desk
- Write an answer and a page reference beside each of the forty questions, and list every question left open.
- Mark which questions do not apply to the offer in hand, with one line on why.
- Reconcile every figure the questions touch, price, counts, uses and sources, against at least two places in the documents.
- Recheck questions 5, 12, 14 and 16 every time the Schedule TO is amended, because those answers move during the offer.
- Read the target's Schedule 14D-9 answers to questions 27 to 31 beside the bidder's Offer to Purchase, so that both sides of the deal are on the desk at once.
Key Takeaway: Forty questions in eight groups, from the documents to mini-tenders, give a last pass over any Offer to Purchase and Schedule 14D-9 before anyone relies on them. Each question points to the chapter that explains it, and a question that does not apply should still be answered with the reason. The answers that move during an offer, the expiration, extensions, amendments and payment date, are checked again with every amendment.