Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Sponsor Stockholders Agreement

Free to print: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Sponsor Stockholders Agreement, from How to Read a Sponsor Stockholders Agreement.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Sponsor Stockholders Agreement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Sponsor Stockholders Agreement

Before an independent director signs off on a sponsor stockholders agreement, before a fund votes its shares at the first annual meeting after a listing, and before an investor buys alongside a sponsor that still holds a large block, there is one last read to make. This chapter turns the eleven chapters before it into forty questions for that read.

The questions are written for any sponsor stockholders agreement, not only for the one that Marrowstone Freight Holdings Inc. signed with Dunmere Capital Partners Fund V LP and Oakhaven Growth Partners LP the day before its listing. Each question comes with one sentence on why it matters and a pointer to the chapter that explains it. None of them tells a reader what to sign or how to vote; they tell a reader where to look.

A practical tip on method: read the agreement once with the charter and bylaws open beside it, and a second time with the offering prospectus description in hand. Many of the answers below sit in two documents at once, and a mismatch between them is itself a finding.

Parties, definitions and counting (questions 1 to 6)

  1. Who are the parties, and does each sponsor sign separately? Each sponsor's rights, waivers and amendments usually follow its own signature, so a reader must know who holds what (Chapter 2).

  2. Are the sponsors a group, or bound by a voting agreement with each other? In the case, Dunmere and Oakhaven are not a group and have no voting agreement with each other, and that single fact decides whether their stakes are added for the controlled company test (Chapters 1 and 4).

  3. How is ownership defined: shares outstanding, voting power, or fully diluted? The denominator decides when every threshold is crossed, so a different base can move every line in the agreement (Chapter 2).

  4. Whose shares count toward the sponsor's holding: affiliates, permitted transferees, co-investors? A broad definition keeps rights alive after shares move inside the sponsor's family of funds, a narrow one ends them sooner (Chapter 2).

  5. Who is a permitted transferee, and does a transferee take rights or only shares? Rights that travel with shares to an affiliate can outlast the sponsor's own exit (Chapters 2 and 6).

  6. When is a threshold tested: continuously, at the record date, at the end of each quarter? The testing date decides whether a sale between meetings ends a right at once or only at the next slate (Chapter 10).

Nomination rights and the ladder (7 to 13)

  1. What does each rung of the ladder require, and is each rung expressed as "or more"? The words "or more" decide whether a sponsor sitting exactly on a line keeps the seat (Chapter 3).

  2. What must the company do for a designee: include, recommend, solicit, use efforts? Each verb is a distinct promise, and a weaker verb gives the sponsor less than it may think (Chapters 3 and 8).

  3. What happens to a designee when the sponsor drops a rung: immediate resignation, end of term, or nothing said? Without a resignation mechanism, a lost seat may still be occupied until the next annual meeting (Chapter 3).

  4. Who fills a vacancy in a designee's seat, and must the replacement be another designee? A vacancy clause is how a sponsor keeps its count between meetings, and it belongs to the family of board promises examined in Chapter 8 (Chapters 3 and 8).

  5. Does the company have any say over who a designee is: qualifications, background checks, a veto for cause? A reasonable approval right protects the board without turning the nomination into the company's choice (Chapter 3).

  6. Is there a cap on board size, and who can change it? A fixed board size can make a sponsor's designees a majority by arithmetic, and Chapter 8 explains why such a promise deserves a legal read (Chapters 3 and 8).

  7. Can a sponsor waive a seat temporarily and take it back, and on what notice? A waiver is the most flexible tool for meeting independence rules, so its terms matter as much as the ladder's (Chapters 4 and 10).

Committees, removal and vacancies (14 to 18)

  1. Does the sponsor have a right to committee seats, and in what proportion? Proportional committee seats are common, but they must yield to the independence rules once the company is no longer controlled (Chapter 4).

  2. Which listing-rule exemptions does the company use as a controlled company, and which does it not? A reader should know which protections public holders lack today and which will arrive on the change of status (Chapters 1 and 4).

  3. What is the phase-in plan when controlled company status ends? The plan shows which designees leave which committees, how many independents must be recruited and by which date (Chapters 4 and 11).

  4. Can a designee be removed by the sponsor alone, and can the company or other holders remove one? Removal rights decide whose director a designee is in a dispute (Chapter 4).

  5. Does the agreement say how a designee's independence is assessed? A designee is usually not independent for some committees, and the agreement should not pretend otherwise (Chapter 4).

Consent rights (19 to 24)

  1. Which decisions need the sponsor's consent, and is each one specified? A list of named decisions is easier to read, to apply and to defend than a general veto (Chapters 5 and 8).

  2. Are consent rights tiered, and at what threshold does each tier fall away? Consent rights usually fall away above the last nomination threshold, and the gap between the two lines decides when the board alone runs the business (Chapter 5).

  3. Are the consent thresholds expressed in dollar amounts or in percentages, and are they indexed? Fixed amounts lose their force as the company grows, which can quietly widen or narrow the sponsor's reach (Chapter 5).

  4. Does any consent right reach charter or bylaw changes? A consent over the charter protects the sponsor's other rights, but it also locks the company's constitution while the right lasts (Chapters 5 and 10).

  5. Is consent given by the sponsor itself, or by its designees on the board? A consent given as a stockholder and a vote cast as a director are different acts with different duties (Chapters 5 and 8).

  6. What happens if the company acts without a required consent: specific performance, damages, or nothing said? A consent right is only as strong as the remedy behind it, so the remedies and governing law clauses are where the right is tested (Chapter 8).

Transfers, standstill and voting (25 to 29)

  1. Which transfers are free, and which need board approval? A reader should know whether a sponsor can sell its block to a competitor without the board's say (Chapter 6).

  2. Is there a standstill, how long does it last, and who can waive it? A standstill protects public holders from a creeping return to control, and its waiver should sit with the independent directors (Chapters 6 and 10).

  3. When does the standstill clock start: at the listing, or when the sponsor first falls below control? The trigger decides whether the protection arrives when it is needed (Chapter 6).

  4. Has the sponsor agreed to vote for the board's slate, including the independent directors? A voting commitment keeps the sponsor from voting out the independents it helped elect (Chapter 6).

  5. Does the voting commitment end with the sponsor's designees, or with the agreement? A sponsor that has lost its seats but still holds shares may otherwise vote freely (Chapters 6 and 10).

Corporate opportunity and information (30 to 35)

  1. Where does the corporate opportunity waiver sit: the charter, a board resolution, the agreement? The place decides who can change the waiver and how easily (Chapter 7).

  2. Who does the waiver cover: the sponsor, its affiliates, its other portfolio companies, its designees? A wide circle protects the sponsor's business and narrows what the company can claim (Chapter 7).

  3. What is the carve-out for opportunities offered to a designee as a director, and how is it worded? "Expressly", "solely" or "primarily" in that capacity can move a whole deal from one side to the other (Chapter 7).

  4. What information does each sponsor receive, how often, and down to which threshold? In the case, information rights end at 10 percent, with Dunmere's last seat but before Oakhaven's seat at 5 percent, and the order matters for a sponsor still on the board (Chapter 9).

  5. Must the sponsor and its representatives sign a confidentiality undertaking before receiving anything? The undertaking is what lets a listed company share nonpublic information with one holder under Regulation FD, as Chapter 9 explains (Chapter 9).

  6. Does any observer have a right to attend, and can the board exclude the observer? An observer is not a director, so exclusion for privilege, conflicts and competitive matters is the company's protection (Chapter 9).

How a sponsor works with its portfolio companies from day to day, beyond what the agreement lets it see, is covered in The Private Equity Operating Partner.

Delaware law, term, amendment and waiver (36 to 40)

  1. Is the agreement made with the sponsors as stockholders, and is it consistent with the charter? Chapter 8 shows why both points sit at the center of the Delaware statute that now governs these contracts (Chapter 8).

  2. When was the agreement signed, and what does that mean for a challenge? Chapter 8 explains why, after Moelis, the signing date is part of the reading (Chapter 8).

  3. At what threshold does the whole agreement end for a sponsor, and what survives? The final threshold and the survival clause together decide what a former sponsor still owes and still has (Chapter 10).

  4. Who must approve an amendment on the company's side, and which sponsors must sign? If only the board approves, sponsor designees may be voting on their own sponsor's rights (Chapter 10).

  5. Does a waiver bind only the sponsor that gives it, and must it be in writing? Clear waiver rules let the agreement adapt to events without anyone losing rights they did not give up (Chapter 10).

Using the forty questions

The list is long, but it is not meant to be read in one sitting by one person. An independent director will spend most time on questions 14 to 18, 26 to 29 and 39. Sponsor's counsel will spend most time on questions 3 to 13 and 19 to 24. A public investor will read questions 2, 15, 16, 20 and 38 first, because they decide how long one holder keeps special powers.

In the case, the agreement was written for this book with its main terms stated, and even so some questions, such as the testing date, are left to the reader. Real agreements leave gaps too, and a gap is itself an answer: it means the general law, the charter or the board's judgment will fill it. A reader who finds a gap should write it down rather than guess.

On the reading desk

Key Takeaway: Forty questions, grouped in seven blocks, cover the whole of a sponsor stockholders agreement: parties and counting (1 to 6), nomination (7 to 13), committees (14 to 18), consents (19 to 24), transfers and voting (25 to 29), corporate opportunity and information (30 to 35), and Delaware law and term (36 to 40). The answers decide how long Dunmere, Oakhaven or any sponsor keeps powers that ordinary holders lack. A question the agreement leaves open is a finding in its own right.