Free companion page
Free to print: Appendix A: The Reading Checklist: Forty Questions for Any Separation Agreement, from How to Read a Spin-Off Separation and Distribution Agreement.
This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Spin-Off Separation and Distribution Agreement by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
This checklist is for the first full read of a separation and distribution agreement and of the documents around it. Each question is followed by one sentence on why it matters and by the chapter that explains the point. The questions are numbered from 1 to 40 and grouped by subject. Use them as a map of what to find, not as a verdict on what the agreement should say.
A practical way to use the list is to read the agreement once for its structure, then return to it with the questions in hand and mark where each answer sits. Some answers will be in the separation agreement itself, and others in an ancillary agreement, a schedule or the Form 10. A question that cannot be answered from the documents is itself a finding, because it shows a point that the reader must take up with the people who prepared the documents. The groups follow the order of the chapters, so a reader who is stuck on a question can turn straight to the chapter named after it.
Which companies are parties, and which one is the distributing corporation and which the controlled corporation? These labels carry through the tax sections, so a reader who confuses them misreads who owes what (Chapter 1).
How is the agreement organized into articles, and where does each subject sit? A map of the articles shows what the master text settles and what it hands to other documents (Chapter 1).
Which ancillary agreements are listed, and does the separation agreement prevail if they conflict? A conflict rule decides which document controls on the day a dispute starts (Chapter 1).
Is the transaction a plain spin-off, or does it add an exchange offer, a split-off or a combined step? The variant changes who receives shares and what a shareholder must do (Chapter 1).
What does the internal reorganization move, and in what order? The steps before the distribution decide what the new company actually holds when it becomes independent (Chapter 1).
Which principle allocates assets and liabilities, and what catches an item that no schedule names? The catch-all definition settles every item the schedules miss (Chapter 2).
How is a shared contract treated when the counterparty has not agreed to split it? The answer shows who keeps the contract, who pays and who receives the benefit in the meantime (Chapter 2).
What happens to an asset that cannot lawfully move on the distribution date? A delayed transfer clause says who holds the asset, who bears its cost and risk, and when it moves (Chapter 2).
What is the rule for a payment received by the wrong company? Look for the trust language, the deadline for paying over, the ban on set-off and the interest on late amounts (Chapter 2).
Do the schedules, the definitions and the catch-all agree with one another? Inconsistent lists are the usual source of later disputes over who owns what (Chapter 2).
Who sets the record date and the ratio, and where is the ratio written? The ratio and the record date fix how many new shares each holder receives (Chapter 3).
How are fractional shares handled, and who sells them? Cash in lieu is the usual answer, and the clause names the agent and the way proceeds are shared out (Chapter 3).
Which conditions must be satisfied before the distribution? The list shows what must happen first, such as effectiveness of the registration, board approval, financing and listing (Chapter 3).
Which conditions can the parent waive, and can the parent abandon the distribution? Waiver and abandonment rights show who controls timing (Chapter 3).
When does the distribution take effect, and what notice goes to the stock exchange and to holders? The effective time and the notices fix the order of events around the record date (Chapter 3).
What does each company release, and which claims are carved out of the release? The carve-outs keep the agreement itself and the ancillary agreements enforceable (Chapter 4).
Does the mutual release reach directors, officers and employees, and in what capacity? The scope of the release decides who can later be sued over pre-distribution facts (Chapter 4).
Who indemnifies whom, and for which categories of liability? The indemnities turn the allocation principle into a payment obligation (Chapter 4).
Are the indemnities net of insurance, capped or subject to a deductible, and is any shared liability handled separately? Caps, deductibles and negotiated exceptions change who ends up paying (Chapter 4).
What is the procedure for a third-party claim? Notice, control of the defense and settlement consent rules decide how a claim is run once someone sues (Chapter 4).
What tax treatment does the separation rely on, and what supports it: an opinion, a ruling or both? The support behind the treatment tells the reader how much rests on one document (Chapter 5).
Who bears taxes for periods before the distribution and for periods after? The split of tax periods assigns audits and adjustments to one company or the other (Chapter 5).
Which covenants restrict the controlled corporation, for how long, and what releases them? The restrictions limit mergers, asset sales, buybacks and changes in the business during the restriction period (Chapter 5).
Who pays if the intended tax treatment fails because of one company's act? The tax matters agreement usually ties the payment to the cause of the failure (Chapter 5).
How does section 355(e) interact with an acquisition of the controlled corporation, and does the agreement allocate that risk? An acquisition near the distribution is where this rule matters most (Chapter 5).
Which employees transfer on the distribution date, and which transfer later? Delayed transfer employees stay with the parent for a stated period, and the agreement says who pays for them (Chapter 6).
How are equity awards converted? The conversion formula aims to keep the value of each award about the same before and after the distribution (Chapter 6).
Which pension and benefit liabilities move, and how are they funded? The assets that move with a plan decide whether the new company starts with a surplus or a deficit (Chapter 6).
Do transferred employees keep service credit for vesting and eligibility? Without credit, employees lose seniority they already earned (Chapter 6).
Is there a non-solicitation covenant, and what exceptions does it carry? The covenant shows how free each company is to hire from the other (Chapter 6).
What new debt does the controlled corporation raise before the distribution, and how much is paid to the parent? The cash transfer ties the financing to the parent's own balance sheet (Chapter 7).
Is the parent released from the new company's debt and guarantees? Release and guarantee clauses show whether the parent stays exposed after the distribution (Chapter 7).
Who owns each patent, which licenses are granted, and on what terms? License scope, field limits and grant-backs decide what each business may do with shared technology (Chapter 8).
May the new company keep using the parent's name and marks, and for how long? A phase-out period shapes the cost and timing of rebranding (Chapter 8).
Do the Form 10 and the information statement describe the agreement accurately? Shareholders read these documents, not the agreement, so any gap between them matters (Chapter 9).
What access to records does each company get, at whose cost, and for how long are records kept? Audits, tax filings and litigation all depend on the old records (Chapter 10).
How is confidential information protected, and for how long? Trade secrets and ordinary confidential information often carry different terms (Chapter 10).
Who controls privilege over legal advice given before the distribution? A shared privilege can be lost if one company waives it alone (Chapter 10).
What is the dispute path: escalation, mediation, arbitration, seat, and a court carve-out for injunctions? The path and the duty to keep performing decide how a disagreement is contained (Chapter 11).
Who may amend or terminate the agreement and until when, which law governs, and which clauses survive? These final clauses show what binds the companies for years after the distribution (Chapter 11).