Free companion page

Companion page: How to Read a Securities Class Action Complaint

Free to print: Appendix B: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist and the Pleading Map, from How to Read a Securities Class Action Complaint.

This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Securities Class Action Complaint by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.

To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.

Appendix B: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist and the Pleading Map

Use this checklist with a complaint open beside you. The forty questions run in eight groups of five, from the caption to the settlement. Each question is followed by one sentence that names the chapter where the book answers it. After the questions comes a pleading map that links each part of a complaint to the element it supports and to the line of attack the defense usually takes.

Group 1: Parties and Class Period

  1. Who is the lead plaintiff, and does the complaint say when and how that plaintiff bought the stock? Chapter 9 explains how the lead plaintiff is chosen and what its purchases must show.
  2. Which defendants are named, and is each one tied to a statement or to a claim, including any claim based on control? Chapter 1 shows how to match each name in the caption to a count.
  3. Which company securities are at issue, and on what market or in what offering did they trade? Chapter 1 explains why the security and the market shape every later claim.
  4. What are the first and last dates of the class period, and what event marks each one? Chapter 1 shows how the period is built from the first challenged statement and the last corrective disclosure.
  5. Who is excluded from the class, and does the definition match the period stated elsewhere? Chapter 8 covers how a class definition is read and tested.

Group 2: The Statements

  1. Is each challenged statement quoted word for word, with its speaker, date and setting? Chapter 4 explains how a complaint should present a statement.
  2. Is the statement one of fact, of opinion, of belief or of prediction? Chapter 4 separates these forms and the different tests each one meets.
  3. Does the complaint challenge words that read like marketing enthusiasm rather than something checkable? Chapter 4 explains puffery and why courts treat it differently.
  4. Is a statement challenged for what it leaves out as well as for what it says? Chapter 4 describes the half-truth theory.
  5. Does each statement fall inside the class period, and who is alleged to have made it? Chapter 4 shows how each statement is tied to its speaker and date, and Chapter 6 how each defendant is tied to it.

Group 3: Falsity and Materiality

  1. For each statement, does the complaint say why it was false when made, with specific facts? Chapter 4 explains how reasons for falsity are pleaded.
  2. Do the facts that make a statement false come from a source that existed at the time of the statement? Chapter 6 explains why timing matters when a complaint relies on later events.
  3. Would a reasonable investor have cared about the fact allegedly misstated or hidden? Chapter 2 covers materiality and how it is argued.
  4. Does the complaint rely on the offering document, and if so, which statements sit inside it? Chapter 3 covers claims that arise from a registration statement.
  5. Is any allegation presented as fact when it is only an allegation or an inference? Chapter 1 reminds the reader that a complaint only alleges.

Group 4: Safe Harbor

  1. Which challenged statements look ahead, and which describe present or past facts? Chapter 5 shows how to sort the two.
  2. Was a forward-looking statement accompanied by a warning that names real, specific risks? Chapter 5 explains what makes a cautionary statement meaningful.
  3. Was a spoken statement preceded by an oral warning that points to written risk factors? Chapter 5 covers oral statements and the way they are tied to written warnings.
  4. Does the complaint allege that the speaker knew the forward-looking statement was false? Chapter 5 explains why actual knowledge becomes the issue.
  5. Does the statement arise from an initial public offering, where the safe harbor may not reach? Chapter 5 covers the exclusions, and Chapter 3 covers the offering claims.

Group 5: Scienter

  1. Does the complaint plead facts that show what each defendant knew, rather than only the defendant's title? Chapter 6 explains why a position alone does not show knowledge.
  2. How many confidential witnesses are cited, and what is each one's role and dates of employment? Chapter 6 shows how to read a confidential witness paragraph.
  3. Does each confidential witness describe first-hand knowledge or only an impression of company culture? Chapter 6 separates the useful witness from the decorative one.
  4. Are insider stock sales alleged, and does the complaint compare them with each person's holdings and say whether they were made under a written trading plan? Chapter 6 explains how sales are read.
  5. Taking all the facts together, is the inference of intent at least as persuasive as an innocent explanation? Chapter 6 covers the strong inference test.

Group 6: Loss Causation and Damages

  1. Does the complaint identify each corrective disclosure by date and by what it revealed? Chapter 7 explains what a corrective disclosure must do.
  2. Does each disclosure reveal the alleged truth, or only bad news that anyone might have expected? Chapter 7 shows how the link between truth and price is tested.
  3. Does the complaint include an event study, and does it explain how it separates company news from the market and sector? Chapter 7 covers how an event study works.
  4. Is each price decline statistically significant, and is the dollar decline stated per share? Chapter 7 explains the reading of abnormal returns and of the t-statistic.
  5. Does the complaint say how damages will be measured, including any cap after the disclosure? Chapter 11 covers the damages methods and the lookback.

Group 7: Reliance and Class

  1. Does the complaint plead that the stock traded in an efficient market, with facts rather than labels? Chapter 8 covers fraud-on-the-market and the facts that support it.
  2. Does the complaint rely on any other route to reliance, and does it fit the claim? Chapter 8 explains the other routes and their limits.
  3. Could the defense show that the statements had no effect on the price? Chapter 8 explains price impact and how it is contested.
  4. Are the class claims typical, and is the lead plaintiff able to represent every purchaser in the period? Chapter 8 covers the conditions for certification.
  5. Does the complaint propose a way to measure class-wide harm that matches its own theory of falsity? Chapter 8 explains why that match matters at certification.

Group 8: Procedure, Insurance and Settlement

  1. Was a notice published, and did the lead plaintiff motion follow the stated deadline? Chapter 9 explains the notice and the lead plaintiff contest.
  2. Is this the first complaint or the consolidated one, and what did the consolidation add? Chapter 9 compares the two.
  3. When will the defense move to dismiss, and does discovery wait until the motion is decided? Chapter 10 covers the motion and the discovery stay.
  4. Are the claims filed within the time limits that apply to each count? Chapter 10 sets out the limits and how they are checked.
  5. If the case survives, who pays and how is a recovery shared among class members? Chapter 11 explains settlement and the plan of allocation, and Chapter 12 reads the case from three desks.

The Pleading Map

The map lists twelve parts of a complaint. For each part it names the element the part supports and the attack the defense usually makes.

Part of the complaint Element it supports What the defense attacks
Caption and parties Standing of the lead plaintiff and the role of each defendant A defendant with no tie to a statement; purchases outside the class period
Class period definition Who may recover and for which statements A period that starts or ends on a date the facts do not support
Quoted statements A statement made by a named speaker Wording that is opinion, puffery or a prediction
Reasons for falsity A false statement or a misleading omission Facts that came later, or that do not contradict the statement
Materiality allegations An item that mattered to investors A fact too small or too general to change a decision
Safe harbor pleading A forward-looking statement outside protection A meaningful warning, or no pleaded actual knowledge
Confidential witnesses Knowledge and intent of the speakers A witness with no first-hand knowledge, or who left earlier
Insider sales Motive to mislead Sales that are small, routine or planned in advance
Corrective disclosures The truth reaching the market News that revealed nothing new about the earlier statements
Event study and loss causation A price decline caused by the revelation Other causes of the decline; a drop that is not significant
Reliance and class allegations A presumption that buyers relied on the price An inefficient market; no price impact; atypical plaintiff
Counts, prayer and jury demand Each legal claim and the relief sought Counts that restate labels; claims filed after the time limits