Free companion page
Free to print: Appendix B: The Forty-Question Reading Checklist and the Pleading Map, from How to Read a Securities Class Action Complaint.
This page is free and needs no sign-up. It reproduces material from How to Read a Securities Class Action Complaint by Julian R. Sterling so you can print it or keep it open while you work.
To print it, use your browser's print button. Figures are as stated in the book; check the official source before relying on any of them.
Use this checklist with a complaint open beside you. The forty questions run in eight groups of five, from the caption to the settlement. Each question is followed by one sentence that names the chapter where the book answers it. After the questions comes a pleading map that links each part of a complaint to the element it supports and to the line of attack the defense usually takes.
The map lists twelve parts of a complaint. For each part it names the element the part supports and the attack the defense usually makes.
| Part of the complaint | Element it supports | What the defense attacks |
|---|---|---|
| Caption and parties | Standing of the lead plaintiff and the role of each defendant | A defendant with no tie to a statement; purchases outside the class period |
| Class period definition | Who may recover and for which statements | A period that starts or ends on a date the facts do not support |
| Quoted statements | A statement made by a named speaker | Wording that is opinion, puffery or a prediction |
| Reasons for falsity | A false statement or a misleading omission | Facts that came later, or that do not contradict the statement |
| Materiality allegations | An item that mattered to investors | A fact too small or too general to change a decision |
| Safe harbor pleading | A forward-looking statement outside protection | A meaningful warning, or no pleaded actual knowledge |
| Confidential witnesses | Knowledge and intent of the speakers | A witness with no first-hand knowledge, or who left earlier |
| Insider sales | Motive to mislead | Sales that are small, routine or planned in advance |
| Corrective disclosures | The truth reaching the market | News that revealed nothing new about the earlier statements |
| Event study and loss causation | A price decline caused by the revelation | Other causes of the decline; a drop that is not significant |
| Reliance and class allegations | A presumption that buyers relied on the price | An inefficient market; no price impact; atypical plaintiff |
| Counts, prayer and jury demand | Each legal claim and the relief sought | Counts that restate labels; claims filed after the time limits |